The trick there, I think, was that you were only trying to convince BM and Chronx. Atticus was basically a non-player and then the 3 scum were never going to allow Gorgon to be lynched. You would have had to have absolutely all three of you (for a deadline lynch) or convince Atticus of it for a regular lynch if you wanted to get Gorgon. We'd have sacrificed ourselves before we'd have let you lynch him.Hang 'em High wrote:Lynch 3: ChronX. I didn't vote for him, although I did think there was a good chance he was the GFer. I wish I had done a more effective job of arguing for Gorgon's lynch. By this point I was convinced he was Scum -- and I was right. I just didn't pursuade the rest of the town effectively. I don't know if we would have won even if we had lynched Gorgon here, but we would have still had a chance. If we had lynched him I'm sure I would have been NKed, leaving Battle Mage, ChronX and Atticus versus distad and SonicPulsar. We'd still likely have lost, since I think ChronX would have been the most likely choice for lynching the next day.
Your only real hope, in my opinion, was to get a lynch on me or Distad. It would have been hard to convince enough people to vote for me over Atticus (thanks again Atticus) so that really only left you (the town) with pushing a Distad lynch, which I never felt was going to happen unless we (the scum) basically pushed for it.
