Animal Crossing Mafia: Game over

[ckillor]

has grek posted why he didnt use his ability last night like he said he would to confirm?

[Tarhalindur]

That depends on whether we think the last scum(s) is investigation-immune.

If we think that the last scum(s) is NOT investigation immune, then I'm clear (Lowell got a town result on me); otherwise, only Lowell is clear.

[Yamahako]

Maybe Grek can't use his ability on a night he kills... there were two kills last night. Assuming 1 Scum left - Perhaps he used a certain item and made a kill? Also considering we haven't heard from him yet

Vote Grek

Until he responds

[Primate]

I'm going to set a deadline for Oct 30th. Getatit.

[Tarhalindur]

I'm going to set a deadline for Oct 30th. Getatit.

It would help if we were voting for lynch instead of still voting for bells...

[Primate]

Sorry, I was under impression they were both simultaneous.

Lowell gets his one bell, town can lynch someone now.

Deadlines sticking though.

[Tarhalindur]

Before we lynch, I want to hear from Grek (or else I will likely vote for his lynch today).

Mod: Can we have a PROD on Grek?

[Primate]

Mod: Can we have a PROD on Grek?

For various reasons, no.

[ckillor]

reasons within the game?

[Lowell]

FOS grek

Is he the one who claimed the odd restriction? If so, here you go.

[Tarhalindur]

So, apparently Grek tried to use his ability after all.

Either he was lying about his actual ability or he was mistaken as to how his role works, since my items weren't roleblocked last night (and apparently Lowell got an investigation).

[Yamahako]

So he disappears today? And can't post? I don't remember him saying that was his ablity...

This doesn't seem like a pro-town ability, can he be lynched? If so that really sounds like something that would be good as mafia. Hiders are usually (but not always) pro-town... but I've been a hider as mafia before.

[HackerHuck]

Well, unfortunately, he wouldn't be the only one in this game. If I recall, NAR was some owl character that couldn't post except for when he was voted or FOSed.

[Tarhalindur]

So he disappears today? And can't post? I don't remember him saying that was his ablity...

This doesn't seem like a pro-town ability, can he be lynched? If so that really sounds like something that would be good as mafia. Hiders are usually (but not always) pro-town... but I've been a hider as mafia before.

Wait, I'm an idiot - I misread Grek's claim .

I can confirm myself. I am Saharah, the camel. Once in the game, I can leave the town on foot(hoof?) and no night actions will work

on me

because I'm not there. If I choose to do this, I am unable to post the next day.

Grek has confirmed his ability, and that pretty much clears him in my mind (especially given how NAR's claimed ability worked).

Unvote, Vote: HackerHuck

Two reasons:
1) I have extreme difficulty accepting 3 cop-like roles in this game, even without a doc, especially since there is an item (Lantern) that can grant any player a 1-shot investigation.
2) Since Grek has confirmed his ability and is probably town, HackerHuck is the most likely to be scum by PoE (the other candidate is Yamahako, and despite his bad rolename I think he's slightly more likely to be telling the truth).

There is one more piece of information that I now want out in the open.

Yamahako - Can you please tell us the names of every player who has purchased an Axe during the course of the game?

[Yamahako]

There is one more piece of information that I now want out in the open.

Yamahako - Can you please tell us the names of every player who has purchased an Axe during the course of the game?

I wish I could, Primate didn't have all the information. As of when I took over the role, only 1 person had an axe - grek :-/ Primate could only give me an inventory of what each person has right now.

This was my other reason for suspecting him - the weird death last night. But I don't suspect you would need to be scum necessarily to use an axe.

Unless people used items last night (I don't know when or who uses them) I did know what everyone had and of course can confirm this.

Unvote

I had forgotten the full claim as well

[HackerHuck]

Grek has confirmed his ability, and that pretty much clears him in my mind (especially given how NAR's claimed ability worked).

Unvote, Vote: HackerHuck

Two reasons:
1) I have extreme difficulty accepting 3 cop-like roles in this game, even without a doc, especially since there is an item (Lantern) that can grant any player a 1-shot investigation.
2) Since Grek has confirmed his ability and is probably town, HackerHuck is the most likely to be scum by PoE (the other candidate is Yamahako, and despite his bad rolename I think he's slightly more likely to be telling the truth).

I must admit that I cannot really refute this line of reasoning. The fact that we have three cops is also difficult for me to reconcile, which is why I'm trying to figure out whether Lowell could be scum.

That seems to be a long shot, so I'm resigned to looking elsewhere first. I think that if we've only got one scum, we're not at LYLO, so assuming Lowell is town won't hurt us in any way today. I believe Grek's claim and I'm not really sure about anyone else right now. I'll have to reread some of the more recent days to try and pick something up. I think it would be helpful to find out who used the axe last night. If you're town, then it's important for us to know who is responsible for all of the killing.

[Tarhalindur]

There is one more piece of information that I now want out in the open.

Yamahako - Can you please tell us the names of every player who has purchased an Axe during the course of the game?

I wish I could, Primate didn't have all the information. As of when I took over the role, only 1 person had an axe - grek :-/ Primate could only give me an inventory of what each person has right now.

This was my other reason for suspecting him - the weird death last night. But I don't suspect you would need to be scum necessarily to use an axe.

Unless people used items last night (I don't know when or who uses them) I did know what everyone had and of course can confirm this.

Unvote

I had forgotten the full claim as well

So, you're saying that Grek's the only player who had an Axe at the time that you replaced in, and noone had bought an Axe since then?

I think we can be pretty sure that Grek was responsible for the cleaving kill last night. That makes him look considerably worse, since TS claimed a power role crumb earlier in the thread.

This doesn't matter today, however, because if Grek is scum, I doubt that he's the only one (there was a regular NK last night, Grek used his ability, and I'm pretty sure that no player can use two regular night actions). I still think that Hacker is the best lynch for today.

[Lowell]

We are NOT at lynch or lose.

[Tarhalindur]

We are NOT at lynch or lose.

There can be two scum (1 Mafia, 1 SK) and we still wouldn't be in LyLo.

[Lowell]

Ah yes, as in fact there seem to be. Fair enough.

[ckillor]

are people allowed to use axes more than once? because then grek is a much bigger suspect

[Tarhalindur]

Axe is a 1-shot kill.

Yamahako has proved that his role works as a kind of information role, which makes HackerHuck's claim even more dubious.

[Lowell]

give slot machine to first person to say they want it

I dont' want it. Take it please.

[Lowell]

Oops I take that back. I already used it. Nevermind.

Regardless, at this stage of the game it's a relatively useless item. Carry on.

[ckillor]

ill take it if you still want to give it, just to see what it does.
oh wait you used it. proddy prod for grek please