Mini 427 - Clue Mafia 3 - Game Over - Is this what happened?

[Skruffs]

DOS - you did get a guilty on AL_KO, right? Or did you get an innocent on me?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Wadsworth: "Let's consider each murder one by one. Professor Plum, you knew that Mr. Boddy was still alive. Even psychiatrists can tell the difference between patients who are alive or dead. You fired the gun at him in the dark and missed, so you pretended he was dead. That's how you were able to kill him later, unobserved."

Miss Scarlett: "That's right! He was the missing person in the kitchen after we found the cook dead!"

al_kohaulec, Professor Plum, SK, is dead.

Game over, town wins!

[Skruffs]

yay
To quote Mr. Green:
"I *TOLD* you I didn't do it!"

[Battle Mage]

YAY, WE ROCK!

I was cringing when i thought you were gonna let Ecto off the hook. AlKo was a good catch though.

great game guys.

BM

[BillyTwilight]

Interesting.

Looking forward to seeing the role reveals. Should be kewl.

[Skruffs]

It feels like town was a little overpowered, but if there had actually been a possibility of 6 kills a night... maybe not so much.
I thought maybe if more than one SK targeted teh same player, the kill wouldn't go through.

[Ectomancer]

yay
To quote Mr. Green:
"I *TOLD* you I didn't do it!"

Yeah, I killed BM last night. When al_ko said that he saw me targeting someone else, I knew he had something in mind and that he was the other scum. So of course I went along with it, and tried to use BM's death as reason to kill Skruffs. I still didnt see a way to pull off a win or tie, but I was going to keep trying anyhow.

[Skruffs]

Accuse:Ectomancer

what were your words? Oh yeah, i want to see you struggle.

/struggles weakly

[Haschel Cedricson]

I got the setup right away, and if I hadn't botched my claim, I think I could have gotten al_ko lynched.

I wonder how it was decided who got to kill at night.

[Skruffs]

err, last post, actually. I didn't realize he'd posted since the game ended. ^.^

[DragonsofSummer]

I did just what I said I'd do and investigated al_ko. He came up scum.

If I had investigated Skruffs instead of al_ko and he came up innocent then I wouldn't have been as quick to vote al_ko as I was because even though c_d was 90% cleared in my eyes I would still want to look at everything again just to make sure.

Good game town... I enjoy the fact that we all did have power roles... it made the game rather interesting.

[al_kohaulec]

Thanks for your help ecto . I really wanted to avoid SK lynches as much as possible... but oh well.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Each SK had restrictions on who they could kill, which I hinted towards in their role pms. Wadsworth had no restrictions, hence "Godfather". He was also investigation immune, I think.

[Skruffs]

AHhhh, okay. Did the godfather also nkow who all the SKs were?

[chaotic_diablo]

yay
To quote Mr. Green:
"I *TOLD* you I didn't do it!"

Yeah, I killed BM last night. When al_ko said that he saw me targeting someone else, I knew he had something in mind and that he was the other scum. So of course I went along with it, and tried to use BM's death as reason to kill Skruffs. I still didnt see a way to pull off a win or tie, but I was going to keep trying anyhow.

I had the same idea.

Did al_ko fake his results N1 and end up lucky?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Yea. Alko attempted to kill Jack as well.

No, godfather didn't know the other SKs.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Role PMs:

You are Mrs. Peacock. When you found out that the cook, who used to be your cook, and Mr. Boddy's other informants were in the house tonight, you decided to get rid of them once and for all. You'll sneak through the house when it's dark and off them one by one until they're all gone. Then there'll be no proof of the bribes you've been taking to control your husband's influence over United States government defense contracts. Please confirm by PM.

You are Wadsworth. You're the true Mr. Boddy, and you've been blackmailing everyone since the beginning. Now that you've got them all gathered together, it's time to rid yourself of the evidence, including your informants. You'll sneak through the house when it's dark and off them one by one until they're all gone. There won't be any proof of what you've done, and you can walk away with the blackmail money scot-free. Please confirm by PM.

You are Mrs. White. When you found out that Yvette, who had an affair with your husband, and Mr. Boddy's other informants were in the house tonight, you decided to get rid of them once and for all. You'll sneak through the house when it's dark and off them one by one until they're all gone. Then there'll be no reason for information about your last husband's mysterious death to reach the authorities. Please confirm by PM.

You are Professor Plum. When you found out that Mr. Boddy and his informants were in the house tonight, you decided to get rid of them once and for all. You'll sneak through the house when it's dark and off them one by one until they're all gone. Then there'll be no reason to pay blackmail to cover up your infidelity with patients in the past. Please confirm by PM.

You are Mr. Green. As an FBI Agent, you're here to track down the true criminals before its too late. If necessary, you're prepared to fire upon suspects in order to prevent any more murdering from happening. Should you choose, you may attempt to incapacitate someone in the mansion and keep them from killing anyone else if they're the killer. Please confirm by PM.

You are Colonel Mustard. When you found out that the motorist, who used to be your driver in the war, and Mr. Boddy's other informants were in the house tonight, you decided to get rid of them once and for all. You'll sneak through the house when it's dark and off them one by one until they're all gone. Then there'll be no proof that the money you came into during the war was due to profiting on stolen radio parts sold on the black market. Please confirm by PM.

You are Miss Scarlet. When you found out that the cop, whom you had bribed to keep your "escort service" in business, and Mr. Boddy's other informants were in the house tonight, you decided to get rid of them once and for all. You'll sneak through the house when it's dark and off them one by one until they're all gone. Then there'll be no way for anyone to shut you down, and you can get back to business without any worries. Please confirm by PM.

You are Yvette. As a former employee in Miss Scarlet's "escort service", you're quite good at keeping a man company. As such, you are able to keep someone "busy" when the lights are out, preventing them from going anywhere else during that time. Please confirm by PM.

You are Mr. Boddy. You have come to the mansion to play the role you've been given tonight, but if you're not careful, you may not make it out alive. Once while in the mansion, you may flip the light switch off, dousing everyone in darkness. Be careful, someone out there may come after you in the dark. Please confirm by PM.

You are The Cop. Though you've been known to take bribes in the past, that doesn't mean you're bad at your job. You're determined to find out what's going on in this house, so you've decided to snoop around and check up on people to see what they're up to. Please confirm by PM.

You are The Cook. Not only can you cook, but your food is so good that's it's said to have healing properties for anyone who consumes it. Emboldened by such praise, you've decided to provide nourishment to people in the house in case the killer should come after them next. Please confirm by PM.

You are The Motorist. You think you see some familiar people in this strange house, and you don't know what's going on. You've got to find out, so you've decided to follow people around the house and see where they go. Please confirm by PM.

Role Assignments:

chaotic_diablo - The Cook
al_kohaulec - Professor Plum
Haschel Cedricson (replacing Cogito Ergo Sum) - Mrs. White
DragonsofSummer - The Cop
dahen - Yvette
Jack - Mr. Green
Skruffs (replacing Ancalagon) - Mr. Boddy
The Central Scrutinizer - Colonel Mustard
Ectomancer - Miss Scarlet
MrBuddyLee - Wadsworth
Battle Mage - The Motorist
BillyTwilight - Mrs. Peacoc

[Mastermind of Sin]

Night 1:

DragonsofSummer - BillyTwilight
Alko - Jack
Jack - BillyTwilight
BillyTwilight - Ectomancer
Battle Mage - Alko
CES - BillyTwilight
dahen - DragonsofSummer
MrBuddyLee - Jack
Ectomancer - c_d
c_d - BillyTwilight

Results:

DoS inv BT
Alko fail
Jack kill BT
BT fail
BM tracks Alko to Jack
CES fail
dahen blocks DoS's inv
MBL kill Jack
Ecto fail
c_d fail


Night 2:

alko - BM
DoS - HC
c_d - alko
BM - Ectomancer
HC - BM
dahen - HC
Ecto - BM

Results:

alko fails
DoS inv HC
c_d protects alko
BM tracks Ecto to BM
HC fails
Ecto fails

Night 3:

alko - BM
DoS - Dahen
dahen - Ectomancer
BM - DoS
c_d - DoS
Ecto - BM

Result:

alko kills BM
dahen blocks Ecto
DoS inv dahen
BM tracks DoS to dahen
Ecto fails
c_d fails

Night 3:

alko - DoS
DoS - alko
dahen - alko
c_d - DoS

Result:

dahen blocks alko
DoS inv alko
c_d fails
alko fails

[Mastermind of Sin]

nvm read the later post.

[Battle Mage]

wow. 5 people attempted to kill me, over the course of 2 nights. :p

[Mastermind of Sin]

Mod Notes:

Mrs. Peacock could only kill The Cook
Wadsworth was investigation immune and could kill anyone
Mrs. White could only kill Yvette
Professor Plum could only kill Mr. Boddy
Mr. Green could kill anyone
Colonel Mustard could only kill The Motorist
Miss Scarlet could only kill The Cop
The Cop couldn't investigate Miss Scarlet
The Cook couldn't protect The Cop or Mr. Green
The Motorist couldn't track The Cook
If there are 4 of less people alive, or if 4 or more scum are dead, kill restrictions are lifted. Anyone whose target has died has restrictions lifted.

[Skruffs]

Now, would the SKs and Waddsworth have won if all the informants were dead? Or did it become a matter of getting to final two?

[Mastermind of Sin]

The SKs would have turned on each other.

[al_kohaulec]

yay
To quote Mr. Green:
"I *TOLD* you I didn't do it!"

Yeah, I killed BM last night. When al_ko said that he saw me targeting someone else, I knew he had something in mind and that he was the other scum. So of course I went along with it, and tried to use BM's death as reason to kill Skruffs. I still didnt see a way to pull off a win or tie, but I was going to keep trying anyhow.

I had the same idea.

Did al_ko fake his results N1 and end up lucky?

It wasn't luck, I considered quite a few options before roleclaiming, and also decided to do it very quickly, because claiming only hours after the guilty result on me helped make me look more cleared. I admit there was a level of luck, but I did consider many possibilities and watcher strongly outweighed my other claims.

Among those were: miller, tracker, actually I don't remember any others right now. I just remember those two.

What I really regret though is that my gut was telling me to claim "2" before our massclaim on day 2, but instead I tried to go a 'safer' route by claiming to have been roleblocked. That helped screw me over, but with all of the power roles, there's not much I could've done.

[dahen]

Interesting setup. This was fun.
Claiming role names helped us find scum but also helped scum in finding their targets. Also interesting with a doc who couldn't protect the cop (or the FBI agent). I'd like to try that in another game some day.

I blocked scum three out of four nights, but only the last scum block had any effect. I also blocked our cop from getting a guilty on BT, but he died anyway At least it cleared the cop from my point of view.