Mini 1764: Netherspite's SORM III [Game Over]

[3dicerolling]

You are right. We run too much of a risk lynching.

We are not no lynching today.

[Firebringer]

No lynching on d1 for a sc2 game is usually better imo.
Let night actions sort themselves and then d2 we will have more information to go on to decide shit.

[3dicerolling]

Town gains a huge amount tonight. Generally I would say lynch is fine but we are getting no where. Day 1 lynches almost always hit town. Look at previous iterations.

The odds of us hitting town are 7/13. That's incredibly low compared to most games. And info is only going to help us so much when 1-3 townies end up dead and we dont possess a majority anymore.

This is one of the few reasons I'm not voting aronis. This is a really town minded statement and it holds truth here.

[Xkfyu]

The types that be dancin' round hopin' for dead cthulhu to rise again from the briny deep in his palace o' R'lyeh. They also be lovin' that fishy Dagon fellow.

They be dancin' round their idols, hopin' that cthulhu be opening the gate in reality so that the realm o' Yog-Sothoth be invadin' us; those types.

Bad news, they be.

I'm following you now.

UNVOTE: Aronis

VOTE: Rory

i dont like this
for someone trying to keep independent thoughts
which is something i get from your iso
i dont like you sheeping so blindly

Well, if you have indeed read my ISO, then you would have read this:

However, this being my first role madness game, it's entirely possible that I'm just talking out my ass and am way off base. I think it's better to just defer to the more experienced here.

And yes, I HAVE given this quite a bit of thought, and I've come to the conclusion that I can't find any holes in Yarr's approach. And since I fully believe that Rory is not town, I have no problems sheeping Yarr.

also i still think its worth noting
that if we lynch rory automatically for claiming
the other 2 neutrals will joint wit scum

This, I still don't get. That assumes that the neutrals will react emotionally and seek revenge on town, rather than in accordance with their win conditions.

Furthermore, it assumes that the neutrals will know for sure who the Mafia are, which I guess will inevitably happen, but I don't think it's much of a concern right now.

[Xkfyu]

You are right. We run too much of a risk lynching.

Are you still on this?

I'll ask you this again, what risk do we run with lynching Rory, a claimed 3rd party?

[Xkfyu]

If you believe this:

Town gains a huge amount tonight. Generally I would say lynch is fine but we are getting no where. Day 1 lynches almost always hit town. Look at previous iterations.

The odds of us hitting town are 7/13. That's incredibly low compared to most games. And info is only going to help us so much when 1-3 townies end up dead and we dont possess a majority anymore.

This is one of the few reasons I'm not voting aronis. This is a really town minded statement and it holds truth here.

then what was this about?

Why are you guys unvoting aronis?

[3dicerolling]

If you believe this:

Town gains a huge amount tonight. Generally I would say lynch is fine but we are getting no where. Day 1 lynches almost always hit town. Look at previous iterations.

The odds of us hitting town are 7/13. That's incredibly low compared to most games. And info is only going to help us so much when 1-3 townies end up dead and we dont possess a majority anymore.

This is one of the few reasons I'm not voting aronis. This is a really town minded statement and it holds truth here.

then what was this about?

Why are you guys unvoting aronis?

I wasn't fully read up when I made that post, and changed my mind somewhat.

I'm still kind of conflicted on him tbh. I have hard a difficult time reading aronis when I play with him.

[droog]

And yes, I HAVE given this quite a bit of thought, and I've come to the conclusion that I can't find any holes in Yarr's approach. And since I fully believe that Rory is not town, I have no problems sheeping Yarr.

what do you mean by 'yarr's approach'?

[Xkfyu]

I wasn't fully read up when I made that post, and changed my mind somewhat.

I'm still kind of conflicted on him tbh. I have hard a difficult time reading aronis when I play with him.

Are you suddenly floundering on your Aronis read? I don't remember you being a flounderer.

[3dicerolling]

I wasn't fully read up when I made that post, and changed my mind somewhat.

I'm still kind of conflicted on him tbh. I have hard a difficult time reading aronis when I play with him.

Are you suddenly floundering on your Aronis read? I don't remember you being a flounderer.

Conflicted =/= floundering

You can talk to me about my Aronis read if you would like, or you could be scum and try to mis-represent me. Your choice.

[Xkfyu]

And yes, I HAVE given this quite a bit of thought, and I've come to the conclusion that I can't find any holes in Yarr's approach. And since I fully believe that Rory is not town, I have no problems sheeping Yarr.

what do you mean by 'yarr's approach'?

Lynching a claimed 3rd party instead of lynching someone who hasn't claimed yet, in hopes of lynching Mafia, but at the risk of lynching town.

[Xkfyu]

I wasn't fully read up when I made that post, and changed my mind somewhat.

I'm still kind of conflicted on him tbh. I have hard a difficult time reading aronis when I play with him.

Are you suddenly floundering on your Aronis read? I don't remember you being a flounderer.

Conflicted =/= floundering

You can talk to me about my Aronis read if you would like, or you could be scum and try to mis-represent me. Your choice.

Well, it certainly looked like floundering but ok, let's talk.

That I can recall, your vote was never on Aronis, nor did you express any concerns before your "why are you guys unvoting Aronis" question. Why were you so upset, at the time, that we were unvoting?

[droog]

floundering?
why floundering over "conflicted"?

and why does 'floundering' look scummy to you?

[3dicerolling]

I wasn't fully read up when I made that post, and changed my mind somewhat.

I'm still kind of conflicted on him tbh. I have hard a difficult time reading aronis when I play with him.

Are you suddenly floundering on your Aronis read? I don't remember you being a flounderer.

Conflicted =/= floundering

You can talk to me about my Aronis read if you would like, or you could be scum and try to mis-represent me. Your choice.

Well, it certainly looked like floundering but ok, let's talk.

That I can recall, your vote was never on Aronis, nor did you express any concerns before your "why are you guys unvoting Aronis" question. Why were you so upset, at the time, that we were unvoting?

I have been very busy lately, so not a lot of time to invest in mafia. I have been somewhat following the game, and noticed Aronis had dropped off from posting, something he does in his scum game, that I found fishy. I also remembered he acted like that in a recent towngame, so I was conflicted their, and wanted more posting from aronis to get a better read on him.

I did not want people to unvote him because the pressure got him to keep posting and also that I hadn't read the post that made me slightly town read aronis.

Why do you feel about aronis the way you currently do?

[Xkfyu]

floundering?
why floundering over "conflicted"?

and why does 'floundering' look scummy to you?

I'll circle back and address this once I'm done interacting with 3dr.

[3dicerolling]

floundering?
why floundering over "conflicted"?

and why does 'floundering' look scummy to you?

I'll circle back and address this once I'm done interacting with 3dr.

Circling back! You flounderer!

[Xkfyu]

I wasn't fully read up when I made that post, and changed my mind somewhat.

I'm still kind of conflicted on him tbh. I have hard a difficult time reading aronis when I play with him.

Are you suddenly floundering on your Aronis read? I don't remember you being a flounderer.

Conflicted =/= floundering

You can talk to me about my Aronis read if you would like, or you could be scum and try to mis-represent me. Your choice.

Well, it certainly looked like floundering but ok, let's talk.

That I can recall, your vote was never on Aronis, nor did you express any concerns before your "why are you guys unvoting Aronis" question. Why were you so upset, at the time, that we were unvoting?

I have been very busy lately, so not a lot of time to invest in mafia. I have been somewhat following the game, and noticed Aronis had dropped off from posting, something he does in his scum game, that I found fishy. I also remembered he acted like that in a recent towngame, so I was conflicted their, and wanted more posting from aronis to get a better read on him.

I did not want people to unvote him because the pressure got him to keep posting and also that I hadn't read the post that made me slightly town read aronis.

Why do you feel about aronis the way you currently do?

I can understand your read change after you read that townish post of his, but before that, if you wanted to keep the pressure on him, you could have just voted him yourself.

As for me, I do have a scum read on Aronis, as outlined in 346, and that's probably about the scummiest thing I've seen from anyone outside of claimed/suspected 3rd parties. So, if we wanted to try to lynch Mafia today, then he'd probably be my vote.

[Xkfyu]

floundering?
why floundering over "conflicted"?

and why does 'floundering' look scummy to you?

I'll circle back and address this once I'm done interacting with 3dr.

Circling back! You flounderer!

I don't like interruptions.

[Espeonage]

On phone so I'll keep it succinct. Is anyone else disturbed by the fact that Xk is trying to strongarm himself in to a leader position? Because it feels fishy to me. Yarr's argument for Rory makes sense so I will probably compromise to there.

[Randomnamechange]

Unless Xk is a mason leader or something then it is def dodgy.

[3dicerolling]

@xkyfu - Like I said, I was barely posting in here at all, and I also like where my vote is right now.

What you have there isn't bad, it's just something I kind of expect from aronis from playing with him.

[Xkfyu]

On phone so I'll keep it succinct. Is anyone else disturbed by the fact that Xk is trying to strongarm himself in to a leader position? Because it feels fishy to me. Yarr's argument for Rory makes sense so I will probably compromise to there.

That's really strong wordage for my play, I think.

[Aronis]

Please claim Aronis.

With 2 votes? One of which is from a person who has been out to get me from game start and the second from someone mindlessly sheeping them. So neither of which are very credible. Not to mention you've played like a complete VI. I'll pass up this opportunity, tyvm.

Actually, you have 3

VOTE: Aronis

oops, I mean 4 votes on you. You really should start reading better.

So what?? 3 votes, 4 votes? Who cares???

[Aronis]

And we are getting a N1 result list REGARDLESS of the outcome of the lynch. Why do you people keep acting like we're not?

Who said that?

Please claim Aronis.

At L–4 or so?

Yarrrrgami cannot even vote properly

Whut?
You care about everything but scumhunting.

How about we all play one o' me favorite games for long voyages like this.
It be called "Stop talkin' to the snowpirate, he be a jestin' deckhand."
The rules be pretty self-explanatory.

Yarrgami, I like you. But I don't think Snow is a jester. That is jsut a easy way to dismiss him.

He may or may not be a Jester... what a shame would it be if he died at Night trolololol!

He was reffering to SORM Ihe missed the game not you. In that game town got screwed over by a massclaim (especially my fault)

Yeah, I actually didn't remember who was that Nightkill at Night1. However, it wasn't your fault, I think.

VOTE: aronis
This should be 5.

Is there a reason for that, or are you just hopping on a wagon?

Wait-oh. You did the very same right before Shos...
Or was that a pressurizing vote to make Aronis post something relevant?

By the way,
Aronis.
Read list. Now.

Uhh, no thanks.

[Aronis]

floundering?
why floundering over "conflicted"?

and why does 'floundering' look scummy to you?

I'll circle back and address this once I'm done interacting with 3dr.

Dodging questions. Omfg, what a scumtell.

VOTE: xkfyu