BM mentioned this as well. Claiming watcher doesn't shake off a scum result. It was a long time ago that this happened, and I can't remember exactly what I was thinking to tell you, but it was likely that he was either paranoid or insane. Thinking back, a sudden claim by me probably wasn't the best idea, but again, scum trying to pass off a scum result would've reacted more heavily towards either sanity, lying from BM, or to have just claimed miller, as BM mentioned. I did none of those, what I did had no effect on a guilty result, and matched perfectly with what he really was and really got before I was even aware that he was anything of a tracker.chaotic_diablo wrote:The manner in which you presented your claim is strange. If you were protown, then you would realize that BM's investigation would be inaccurate. As a result, I don't find it likely that you would have blurted out your claim and result without prompt.If you were scum, then I'd bet you would be tricked by it and try to pass it off as something else.That is the more likely case and probably worked successfully given that BM wasn't a cop.
What are you talking about?dahen wrote:[qutoe="alko"]
in which case there would be much less crosskills and double targets than we've had
Your ability to turn off the lights and go to night makes sense in that context.Most commonly the Traitor knows who is in the Mafia, but the Mafia do not know who the Traitor is. The Traitor works, through his or her Vote, to keep the Mafia from getting Lynched.
My only question is, why didn't you save MBL? The answer is that he was caught red handed with cross confirmation. His main blunder was to send in the kill himself and not you, but I guess he figured being investigation immune would save his skin if suspected. He just didn't plan on a tracker AND a watcher being on hand to account for everyone's actions. The way BM played that pretty much prevented you from saving his butt.Hmmmm. I don't think that any of the serial killers had any other abilities, except waddsworth.
You're under the assumption that the godfather is the only one capable of sending in kills. It's perfectly plausible for both the godfather and a SK to send in their night choices on the same night. Even after the godfather dies, it still accounts for why there are still kills going around.al_ko wrote:Statement one is plausible, there's a leader with all of his SKs, and they can communicate, but the SKs want to kill each other.
Statement two makes some sense in SK interaction, because if there's no communication, they won't know about each other and will want to kill each other. The problem here is that with the godfather being the one sending the kills, that doesn't account for any crosskilling or kills after his death. So Statement 2 doesn't work.
Statement 3 depends upon the previous statements to be true in that the SKs know who the godfather is, but fails for the same reason as 2.
Statement four talks about how the scum are working towards their own goals, which is reason for the cross kills and such. Well, they're all coming up as SKs, so it only makes sense that they would be looking out for only themselves. This actually fights more against the previous statements.
Lucky guesser.al_ko wrote:BM mentioned this as well. Claiming watcher doesn't shake off a scum result. It was a long time ago that this happened, and I can't remember exactly what I was thinking to tell you, but it was likely that he was either paranoid or insane. Thinking back, a sudden claim by me probably wasn't the best idea, but again, scum trying to pass off a scum result would've reacted more heavily towards either sanity, lying from BM, or to have just claimed miller, as BM mentioned. I did none of those, what I did had no effect on a guilty result, and matched perfectly with what he really was and really got before I was even aware that he was anything of a tracker.