The rereading the first 8 pages has left me slightly at a loss. I was so sure that Para was scum Day 1 that I didn’t really pick up on some things…couple things I would like to note, not really cases per say, but things I need to look into more when I have time.
Post 57:
Oman attempts to make a case against DFN (now Jordan) but does not put a vote on him. He later states that he thinks DFN(Jordan) or Oj (now para) is scum.
Hmmm..post 70:
Oman makes a big deal that DFN (Jordan) thinks OJ (para) is scum(post 61) by “noting” it. However, in post 63, Elias, makes the same statement and Oman doesn’t say a thing. Why would Oman noted that DFN thinks OJ was scum, but not note that Elias 2 posts later did too?
Post 72:
Oman votes DFN (Jordan) mainly because he feels everyone makes a good case.
Post 74, a hypocritical comment from SPAG, almost like a forshadowing.
SPAG wrote:oj is a bit of a loser really, he doesn't even read any games he just votes. In another game he voted for me when i was at -1 and i had character claimed.
Anyway, he could be town, he could be scum, theres just no way to tell.
quote really doesn’t mean anything yet..just thought it was funny, given his actions at the end of Day 1.
Post 84:
Oman, states he feels like Gorckat is mostly pro-town…still pushing DFN and now adds Nelly to possible scum lists.
Again, the Gorckat comment might not mean anything at this point, Oman could be trying to get Gorckat off of his back.
Post 88: DFN, attempts to attack me with crap logic and tried changing the quotes to suit his case. It was caught quickly and struck down just as quickly. Later (91) Dfn explains he misquoted by accident.
Ugh, post 99:
TheHermit wrote:I'm starting to think we're best off killing ojpower immediately so his lurking, random-voting self can't kill us later when we're at LyLo. At this point I don't even care whether he's scum or not, I want him gone.
Vote: ojpower
by itself this is a scummy post, however it should be noted that Thehermit did not hammer Nelly or OJ(para later) when he had the chance.
Post 102: Oman mentions that thehermit post was scummy, but that hermit explains it in (101) to Oman's satifaction. Still attacks DFN
Post 106:
Gorckat votes Nelly because Nelly unvoted at vollkan’s request. Should be noted that vollkan later is discovered to be town/vig/mason.
Post 123:
Pulse(now Set) thinks Hermit’s play is scummy..votes.
Post 124: Nelly self votes?..strange play, but sets up a ton of action.
Post 132:
Elias questions both Hermit’s and Nelly’s self vote…so he votes Nelly
Post 135 Oman vote nelly
Post 136: Para miscounts, votes, and puts Nelly at –1. Last 4 votes are put on Nelly in a 3 hour period.
Post 148 Interesting comment from Sir tornado (now Shanba)
Sir Tornado wrote:I don't like the way Oman put Nelly on -2, and simply left.
Why did he not mention that Para put Nelly at –1 “and left”…neither had posted after their vote.
Post 155: Nelly explains his actions…Gorckat/Elias/Oman/Para trap of sorts…puts vollkan and myself on the townie list…votes para for many the same reasons many of us pushed for the lynch.
Post 156:
Oman votes Para. I was so head strong about Para, I thought Oman was just distancing.
Post 159: Vollkan puts Para/Oman/Elias under suspicion…also claims he is the vig.
Post 162: nelly asks Para to roleclaim. Missed this before. Vollakn also mentions that he might kill Oman and Elias too….Nelly doesn’t ask anyone else to RC…but I guess Vollkan DID suggest Para over the other two.
Post 165: Vollkan asks if anyone objects to Para being vigged.
Post 167: Oman says he would like to see Para vigged and he thinks Elias is more pro-town then Pulse…not sure why he mentioned Pulse at this point…or compared Elias to Pulse….
Post 187:Back from Vacation, Gorckat unvotes Nelly, thinks Nelly contradicts himself in reference to a comment he made about me, challenges vollkan and thinks he might be a scum vig.
Post 197: Gorckat rereads and places his vote on the vote leader Para.
Post 199: Gorckat unvotes Para but states Elias or Para would be good lynch targets (this is a strange post).
-----------------------------------------------
Ok so that is the end of Page 8…I actually have to work so I will continue later..
To address this recent statement:
gorckat wrote:iirc, the 3 names on the list were drawn from the Nelly wagon, weren't they? Oman wasn't just pulling names out of the air.
I was the first to vote, Nelly self-voted, and the names on the list (and Oman himself) all voted Nelly afterwards, with one of them going on after Nelly unvoted, correct?
Why do you think Pulse voted for Nelly?