I read through pistachi0n's ISO.
pistachi0n (13 posts) Scum-lean read
RVS votes on Dierfire and herrcombs:
post 4,
post 14
I have mixed feelings with
post 123. pistachi0n votes Gamr. I disagree with his
"chiming in RVS to say you don't see anything scummy when nobody prompted you is scummy"
- I do not believe it is out-right scum-indicative.
- I agree. It feels like pistachi0n is attacking Gamr's playstyle more than anything:
"He hasn't posted a scumread based on anything other than OMGUS."
(defensive/narrow-focus play / OMGUS can come from town and scum).
I agree with pistachi0n view that the use of "honestly" is not scum-indicative (
post 175).
"Null/weak town"
: pistachi0n's now no longer scum-reads Gamr:
"But I like his responses and how he's challenging the accusations against him"
- I would like to see the responses pistachi0n liked. (I.e Why would only town 'challenge the accusations').
pistachi0n's now scum-reads Gamr:
"But I like his responses and how he's challenging the accusations against him" - in pistachi0n's previous statement now void?
Defending the Gamr wagon:
In post 225, pistachi0n wrote:@herrcombs--There are 4 votes. There need to be some votes to apply pressure, even early in the game. But nobody's rushing to instalynch. So what are you worried about?
This exchange of posts feels unnatural between pistachi0n and Hieirama
:
In post 267, pistachi0n wrote:
Okay, fine, it either takes guts or it's scum who wants to gain town points.
Another change on his Gamr read:
In post 385, pistachi0n wrote:Garmr--I'm not as certain of my scumread as I was earlier, when he claimed it seemed like he was making an appeal to emotion but then he came back strong, I thought
242 and after were good.
It feels like pistachi0n is adjusting his read on Gamr to fit the general consensus.
I would like to see pistachi0n explain where Gamr "came back strong", and explain why post 242 was "good".
In post 385, pistachi0n wrote:Implosion--Weak scum,
I still think the defense of Garmr was to try to get town points
, whether or not Garmr is scum.
"Get town points" - this would only work if Gamr is town (or if pistachi0n believes/knows Gamr is town).
VOTE: pistachi0n