I just picked the first person I saw who hadn't posted. Since Raffles is on vacation, I'll unvote.
As to the first question about how many times has the SK posted? However many times you've posted in this thread.
There is always the possibility that he is mafia and one of them could be his partner, so no, that is not the only possible answer.Stewie wrote: The only possible answer is that the chose randomly/arbitrarily, since he has no other information to base his vote on (or if he does, he's not gonna tell you). Can you really think of any other method of picking who to vote between two people who haven't posted yet?
I didn't expect any other answer from DeepSouth. Stewie, on the other hand, who the question didn't concern, shouldn't automatically have assumed an innocent motive (how is he to know if the motive is innocent or not).Mgm wrote:But it is the only answer he's gonna give you. Or did you expect him to admit to being a scumbag?
You are wrong, there are several answers he could have given...(as I have stated before)..I wanted to see what he had to say...but Stewie obligated to answer it for him.Mgm wrote:Stewie correctly identified it as a dead end question. I don't see the problem.
There's no problem with answering someone else's questions when there's only one likely answer they'd give (regardless of what their intentions are).
Another example, if I ask you to claim, it would be perfectly all right for someone else to point out you'd claim townie. There's no other claim, unless the SK can convince us he wants to help kill the mafia, but I for one would lynch him on the spot if it doesn't make us lose instantly.
Several answers? Name one then.curiouskarmadog wrote:You are wrong, there are several answers he could have given...(as I have stated before)..I wanted to see what he had to say...but Stewie obligated to answer it for him.Mgm wrote:Stewie correctly identified it as a dead end question. I don't see the problem.
There's no problem with answering someone else's questions when there's only one likely answer they'd give (regardless of what their intentions are).
Another example, if I ask you to claim, it would be perfectly all right for someone else to point out you'd claim townie. There's no other claim, unless the SK can convince us he wants to help kill the mafia, but I for one would lynch him on the spot if it doesn't make us lose instantly.
this is the second time you have spoke without reading or doing a little leg work, it is getting old..Mgm wrote:Several answers? Name one then.curiouskarmadog wrote:You are wrong, there are several answers he could have given...(as I have stated before)..I wanted to see what he had to say...but Stewie obligated to answer it for him.Mgm wrote:Stewie correctly identified it as a dead end question. I don't see the problem.
There's no problem with answering someone else's questions when there's only one likely answer they'd give (regardless of what their intentions are).
Another example, if I ask you to claim, it would be perfectly all right for someone else to point out you'd claim townie. There's no other claim, unless the SK can convince us he wants to help kill the mafia, but I for one would lynch him on the spot if it doesn't make us lose instantly.
not sure what is sigificant about whether the SK posted before or after the SK post by the Mod. We do not know how long the request from the SK to the mod set in the Mod's box. So actually, that "list" could be cut in half, we have no way of telling.Mirth wrote:
If we're going into whether the SK posted before the kill or not, the following people posted pre-kill (in order of first post):
Kinetic
CKD
MGM
Mirth
D3sisted (obviously not the SK, being dead)
Heatherlou
Stewie
I'd like a real answer to the question. You said the SK already posted, and when asked why you responded with a joke. What leads you to believe that the SK posted before the kill? This question actually goes to anyone who actually said that, because I can't see how we can narrow down the field either way (ie: we can't say that the SK didn't post before the kill either).deepsouth wrote:
As to the first question about how many times has the SK posted? However many times you've posted in this thread.