481 - Speed 1: Romeo and Juliet Mafia - Game Over!

[logicticus]

i think you need to work on your critical reading skills

i didnt say i have my opinion and you have yours.

i said i have my way and you have yours in reference to the topic at hand, gathering information.

you seem to believe only questions can gather information, i disagree.

[poppinpuffin]

vote: Jimmy R

For not knowing that I am so totally NOT a guy.

hey to everybody who I haven't met yet!
I like you... you like me?

[xyzzy]

my final points regarding discussion:

1) theres more than one way to gather information
2) you have your way, i have my way

Ah, you seem to be applying the transitive property as well as the hand in your avatar!

X=good strategy!
x=strategy
y=strategy
y=your strategy
x=y=good strategy!
NO

Stop applying the transitive property to set elements. It doesn't work. And you fail.

[Dragon Phoenix]

More than ih other games we need to focus quickly and get a bandwagon going. If we do have the traditional bad luck and bandwagon the cop, we need the time to get someone else to the quotum before the deadline.

FOS: non bandwagonners.

[poppinpuffin]

isnt there a better way than a random bandwagon?

[Dragon Phoenix]

If there is on day one, I'd love to hear it.

[somestrangeflea]

i didnt say i have my opinion and you have yours.

you have your way, i have my way

So, now we have to ask, how similar is "way" to "opinion"?

[Kinetic]

Sounds like semantics to me.

[Jimmy R]

Unvote, Vote Kinetic

lets rolllllll

[Kinetic]

... We still have 6 days left. This blatant bandwagoning is just a scum trick to try and not make them look scummy for doing an obvious town roll. If you let this go on the scum will just bandwagon every townie by starting a bandwagon and once it is 3-4 people full will say everyone not on it is scummy.

This is ridiculous and counter productive...

True, we have a deadline, but for cripes sake it is still 6 days away. You don't get a prize for lynching someone 5 days before deadline. And just because someone says its scummy not to bandwagon at this point doesn't make it so!

[Jimmy R]

It's not scummy not to bandwagon. But it's a good way to get info and get discussion going, which it will.

[logicticus]

my final points regarding discussion:

1) theres more than one way to gather information
2) you have your way, i have my way

Ah, you seem to be applying the transitive property as well as the hand in your avatar!

X=good strategy!
x=strategy
y=strategy
y=your strategy
x=y=good strategy!
NO

Stop applying the transitive property to set elements. It doesn't work. And you fail.

i hope you were drunk when you wrote that.

[logicticus]

i didnt say i have my opinion and you have yours.

you have your way, i have my way

So, now we have to ask, how similar is "way" to "opinion"?

are you guys kidding me? you are playing semanties

"way" as in method, as in method for gathering information.

Which was what was being talked about.

[Brutal Assassin]

Not understanding the argument being made xyzzy at all :/

Kinetic hasn't given me a reason to unvote yet, personally.

[AutumnEvenings]

It is day 1.

12 players remain: Brutal Assassin, Dragon Phoenix, Jimmy R, Kinetic, Mert, PoppinPuffin, Stewie, kravhen, logicticus, schismatized, somestrangeflea, xyzzy.

7 votes are needed for a conviction or to go to night without lynching..

4 votes for Kinetic (Brutal Assassin, Dragon Phoenix, Mert, Jimmy R)
2 votes for Jimmy R (xyzzy, PoppinPuffin)
1 vote for kravhen (kravhen)
1 vote for logicticus (Kinetic)
1 vote for schismatized (somestrangeflea)
1 vote for Mert (schismatized)

2 players have not voted: Stewie, logicticus.

About 5 days and 12 hours remain.

[AutumnEvenings]

Mert

--it has been 25.5 hours since your last post. You have entered into your grace period. Don't make us modkill you.

Schismatized

--it has been 37.5 hours since your last post. You have 10.5 hours left to post. If you fail to do so, you will be modkilled immediately. This means you are dead, whether the mods post to annouce it right on the hour or not. Should that happen, you are no longer permitted to post. Please don't let that happen.

kravhen

--you have 45 minutes in which to post. If you fail to do so, you will enter into your single grace period. Shame to use it so early...

[xyzzy]

It's an obvious argument and if you don't get it you're stupid. (Okay, not stupid, but, you know.)

His argument is equivilant to the argument that "God is love, love is blind, Ray Charles is blind, hence, God is Ray Charles."

He's saying that since some scum-hunting methods are good, and that all scum hunting methods are scum hunting methods, his MUST be good. I was merely putting it in terms of set theory, where if:

A is a member of set B and
A is a member of set C
set B is not necessarily the same set as set C.

That's the crap logic he was using, and I believe that's 3 ways I've explained it now. If you don't understand now, than you really are stupid.

[Kinetic]

BA: You voted me for saying good luck, you are encouraging a bandwagon with your scum partner Dragon Phoenix. Got it, your actions are dully noted.

[logicticus]

BA: You voted me for saying good luck, you are encouraging a bandwagon with your scum partner Dragon Phoenix. Got it, your actions are dully noted.

Good job on identifying the scum, the next step is to actually vote for them.

It's an obvious argument and if you don't get it you're stupid. (Okay, not stupid, but, you know.)

His argument is equivilant to the argument that "God is love, love is blind, Ray Charles is blind, hence, God is Ray Charles."

He's saying that since some scum-hunting methods are good, and that all scum hunting methods are scum hunting methods, his MUST be good. I was merely putting it in terms of set theory, where if:

A is a member of set B and
A is a member of set C
set B is not necessarily the same set as set C.

That's the crap logic he was using, and I believe that's 3 ways I've explained it now. If you don't understand now, than you really are stupid.

Alright, I get what you are saying.

I guess I was just confused because you are completely wrong and I dont think you have been reading the posts correctly.

[Brutal Assassin]

BA: You voted me for saying good luck, you are encouraging a bandwagon with your scum partner Dragon Phoenix. Got it, your actions are dully noted.

Hippocritical argument of what you're accusing Logictus of doing there.

Really, the right play would be to lynch before we lose 3 players due to not posting, so they get 48 hours to get in shape. Not advocating it, but that would be the correct play.

[Kinetic]

BA: I'm continuing to point out how ludicrous your argument is. I want everyone to understand that the reason you are voting me and actively advocating my lynch is because I said, and I quote "good luck". I want everyone to understand how absolutely stupid that is so if I do get lynched you won't survive 24 hours. At anytime you can drop this idiotic bandwagon and actually look for scum.

I honestly think logic is making quite the case for himself, and while it may be slightly OMGUS of me, I think that your baseless attack on me is very scummy. At best its a hunch and you're comfortable with a quick mislynch. Like I said, your blatant disregard for the interests of the town is noted.

[logicticus]

I honestly think logic is making quite the case for himself, and while it may be slightly OMGUS of me, I think that your baseless attack on me is very scummy. At best its a hunch and you're comfortable with a quick mislynch. Like I said, your blatant disregard for the interests of the town is noted.

Dude, you arent helping your case. I was just pointing out that while you are calling BA and DP the scum, you are still voting me.

And then in your next post you are trying to convince BA, the same BA you think is scum, to join a wagon against me...

It just looks really scummy

[Kinetic]

I really don't think BA is scum, I think he is acting scummy and stubborn. I'm trying to get him to realize that and reevaluate his behavior. You are being scummy and illogical. I think you actually are scum, as opposed to I just think BA is being scummy. Understand the difference?

Plus, even if I thought BA and you were both scum, guess what: The possibility exists that all three of you could be scum, because guess what, there are three scum in the game! Imagine those odds!

I think DP, BA and you are acting scummy. I think you are the scummiest of the three so I'm voting for you. Get it now?

[Brutal Assassin]

Really, the right play would be to lynch before we lose 3 players due to not posting, so they get 48 hours to get in shape. Not advocating it, but that would be the correct play.

Thoughts please?

[logicticus]

just because you cant comprehend what i am saying doesnt mean i am being illogical