Open 34 - Dethy (Game Over) - before 474

[somestrangeflea]

Let's face it, having 4/5 players online at once is rare for me. We may as well not waste this chance while we have it.

[Ms Piggy]

chances are, though, that someone else won't be there next time, so this is a good time to try, since 4 of us are on simultaneously, and this isn't that likely usually. =D

[somestrangeflea]

EDWOP: That made no sense...

Remove the "let's face it" part...

[Patrick]

Put it forward to :45 if there is some disagreement about this.

[Ms Piggy]

hehe!


simul posted!

[somestrangeflea]

Investigated: Thok
Result: Guilty

[Thok]

Invetigated: Miss Piggy
Result: Innocent

[Patrick]

Thok Guilty

[Ms Piggy]

Investigated: JDodge

Result: Innocent

[Patrick]

Guess we didn't put it forward afterall

[Ms Piggy]

When I was posting, no one had responded, yet after I typed it, I was the last to post my result.... interesting that two people got Guilty on Thok though.

[somestrangeflea]

Yeah. Not too sure what's going on there. We'll figure it out though...

[Thok]

Feh, remember that if I'm town, SSF/Patrick could be any combination of paranoid/insane/scum.

[somestrangeflea]

EDWOP: I'm currently compiling a list of all the possible meanings of the results. I'll report back in around 10 minutes...

[Ms Piggy]

I was wondering, the wiki/dethy description was sort of ambiguous about this; if a cop dies, is his sanity revealed?

[Patrick]

Sanity is not revealed on death. I have my pen and paper ready.

[somestrangeflea]

PiggySane = JDodge Innocent
PiggyInsane = JDodge Guilty
PiggyNaive = JDodge ?

PiggyParanoid

= Not possible
PiggyScum = JDodge Innocent

ThokSane = Piggy Innocent
ThokInsane = Piggy Guilty
ThokNaive = Piggy ?

ThokParanoid

= Not possible
PiggyScum = Piggy Innocent

PatrickSane = Thok Guilty
PatrickInsane = Thok Innocent

PatrickNaive

= Not possible
PatrickParanoid = Thok ?
PatrickScum = Thok Innocent

FleaSane = Thok Guilty
FleaInsane = Thok Innocent

FleaNaive

= Not possible
FleaParanoid = Thok ?
FleaScum = Thok Innocent

JDodge has submitted no results to date.

Thoughts?

[Thok]

Generally sanity is not revealed (that makes the game harder for scum); the goal is to try to deduce sanities from results. (Generally game play involves lots of no-lynching).

It's better to work with each of the 5 cases where X is scum (for varying values of X), and work out sanities in each of those cases. We can't tell SSF and Patrick apart yet. Nobody is cleared yet (I think), although JDodge's result could change that.

[Patrick]

When I played it on scumchat, the usual way we were looking at things was to assume each player is scum (in turn) and see if that was possible from the results we had, and what each cop would be in that case. I'll probably do that when we get JDodge's result if someone else hasn't.

As a general observation, I asked the mod before the game, and you can't investigate yourself (you can but you will get an innocent result regardless of sanity). Not sure if that would be a good strategy night 0 but it's out anyway.

[somestrangeflea]

OK. I'm new to the Sanity mechanic, so I'll try my hardest to give relevant information!

[somestrangeflea]

Oh, looks like I typed PiggyScum instead of ThokScum above. It'll be fixed next time.

[Thok]

Fun Fact to test your skills: Both me and Piggy are provably not insane. (Which is more interesting then the fairly trivial fact that neither of us is paranoid.)

[Patrick]

JDodge is on. I am excited ><

[somestrangeflea]

I agree.

Fun Fact to test your skills: Both me and Piggy are provably not insane. (Which is more interesting then the fairly trivial fact that neither of us is paranoid.

I'm actually finding quite hard to see why it's "probably" and not "definately". I've been racking my brains and I can't find a single possible situation where one of you are. Please enlighten me.

[Thok]

SSF-you're misreading Provably (as in able to be proven) as probably.