Open 34 - Dethy (Game Over) - before 474

[Ms Piggy]

I'm here too. I've played this game once, on Scumchat. If I remember correctly, it was quite confusing, or shall I say "frustrating", to figure out the results, but I guess maybe it was because of the pace in Scumchat.

[Ms Piggy]

How about in 15 minutes. We can wait for as many people as possible to confirm when to do so.

I'm Central time, which is 5:23 PM right now.

[Ms Piggy]

Yes sir I got an error last minute too.

If there is an error at that exact minute, try to refresh until your mouse almost breaks down, and your hand starts swelling, and then post as soon as possible using beastly typing speed.

[Ms Piggy]

chances are, though, that someone else won't be there next time, so this is a good time to try, since 4 of us are on simultaneously, and this isn't that likely usually. =D

[Ms Piggy]

hehe!


simul posted!

[Ms Piggy]

Investigated: JDodge

Result: Innocent

[Ms Piggy]

When I was posting, no one had responded, yet after I typed it, I was the last to post my result.... interesting that two people got Guilty on Thok though.

[Ms Piggy]

I was wondering, the wiki/dethy description was sort of ambiguous about this; if a cop dies, is his sanity revealed?

[Ms Piggy]

Interesting. I'll ponder upon this result for a bit I guess.

[Ms Piggy]

Yeah, I've basically convinced myself that there isn't a forced win from what we have. I've also decided the best set of investigations for tonight (in terms of maximizing our chance of winning) is that we have everyobdy investigate Patrick, except that Patrick investigates his choice of JDodge/SSF.

(I don't really want to explain much about my thought processes on how this works, except to note that I'm willing to discuss which of SSF/Patrick should be the target of mass investigations; my reasoning for suggesting Patrick over SSF is a slight amount of gut.)

I have a gut feeling it's SSF, on the contrary, but I say let's go with your plan. I see how you might feel it's Patrick, especially his quick x:38 result giving that just said Thok Guilty. It seemed rushed a bit as if he had to think quick of a result, though I think it's just a feeling that doesn't mean anything.

Anyways, I can't think of any way to force a win, and we don't have much else to discuss, so let's no lynch and go with it.

Vote: No Lynch

if there are any objections, say so.

[Ms Piggy]

If you aren't scum, then don't say who you are going to investigate, and report the results tomorrow I guess?

[Ms Piggy]

no.

[Ms Piggy]

I guess so. Choose a time.

[Ms Piggy]

We can set a time, but I think only 2 people are on right now, since JDodge and Patrick aren't.

[Ms Piggy]

My computer is next to my room, so I can basically choose any time within the next few hours.

[Ms Piggy]

Let's say the next X:30

which is about 45 minutes from now.

[Ms Piggy]

Cool. Too bad that one of you three is scum, that likes to drink human blood.

How nasty are you???? You also stopped me in a marvelous dream last night.


I want peace with you if I can't catch you. =P

[Ms Piggy]

Patrick-Innocent

[Ms Piggy]

Sorry, I had RL issue earlier that came up unexpectedly.

[Ms Piggy]

SSF you're scum for sure.


Here are the results from N1 and N2

Jdodge = Thok-Guilty , then Patrick-Guilty
SSF = Piggy-Innocent, then Patrick Guilty
Piggy = JDodge-Innocent, then Patrick-Innocent
Thok = Piggy-Innocent, then Died.
Patrick = Thok-Guilty, then ???


Therefore, I (Piggy) must be sane or naive, since I am not paranoid since I got two innocents, and not insane, since I got two same results from two people. I also can't be scum, since three people got guilties on Thok on Day 1. Thok or I am sane, as Thok also got an innocent on me, and I am innocent. Therefore, he cannot be insane or paranoid.

SSF must be scum, because he cannot be sane or naive, since Thok and I are a combination of the two (sane and naive). He also cannot be insane, since he got an innocent on me, and I am already proven innocent. He cannot be paranoid, or he would have gotten guilty on me.

That's about it.

[Ms Piggy]

Anyways, it doesn't matter what Patrick's result is, though I would like to know. But here's the rest of the good stuff:

Jdodge must be innocent and paranoid, since he cannot be sane or naive, and is not insane since he got two of the same result, and not naive because he got guilties from investigations.

Patrick must be insane, as Thok was innocent, and he can't have been paranoid since JDodge is by process of elimination of possibilities. He is not sane or naive because Thok and I am. It doesn't matter though. SSF is definitely scum. Anyways, SSF also went after JDodge by voting him with no logic. Therefore, he either got an innocent on SSF, or a guilty on JDodge.

[Ms Piggy]

Oh wait. AHHHH. I mixed SSF up. one second.

[Ms Piggy]

Yeah I noticed that. Let me think again.

[Ms Piggy]

NEVER MIND, EXCUSE MY LAST POSTS AND FORGET ABOUT IT.

I just realized, Patrick must be insane, so we are waiting for his result.

JDodge is paranoid or scum.

SSF is paranoid or scum.

I'm sane or naive

Dead Thok is sane or naive.

Patrick is insane.

[Ms Piggy]

Since Jdodge and SSF both got guilties twice, they cannot be naive or sane or insane.

Since three people got guilties on Thok which is not possible, during the 1st night, I must be innocent, and dead Thok is too. One of us is sane, and one of us is naive, as we are the only ones that got innocents during the 1st night.

That clears Thok and me.

Then, Patrick must be insane by process of elimination, as Jdodge, SSF, Thok, and I are all not insane.

Therefore, the possible scenarios of Patrick's last investigation on JDodge/SSF:

1) a guilty on Jdodge, then Jdodge is paranoid, and SSF is scum.

2) an innocent on Jdodge, then Jdodge is guilty, and SSF is paranoid.

3) a guilty on SSF, then SSF is innocent, and JDodge is scum.

4) an innocent on SSF, then SSF is scum, and JDodge is paranoid.

[Ms Piggy]

No more no-lynches. Patrick must be insane and investigated either Jdodge or SSF.

[Ms Piggy]

Patrick could be paranoid...

WRONG.

Thok was sane or naive.

I am sane or naive.

JDodge and you both got guilties twice, so both of you aren't insane.

Therefore, Patrick must be insane.

[Ms Piggy]

That means Patrick is insane or paranoid.

Yeah I really shouldn't be up at 3 hours past midnight hehe.

I hope that Patrick got an innocent on JDodge or SSF, so that he can be insane, and the game will be over.

[Ms Piggy]

Alright, I have a plan.

We go no lynch today. Me and SSF investigate each other, and Piggy and Patrick both investigate SSF.

By doing this, we can probably figure out sanities a bit better.

That might not work.

If the mafia kill Patrick, and I am actually naive, then both of you will say you got an innocent or guilty on each other and say you're insane or paranoid or whatever result could make the other scum, or whatever. Then, it's just luck on who is lynched.

[Ms Piggy]

*prays that Patrick gets an innocent result and goes to sleep for 2 hours because of tiredness from staying up late for 5 nights in a row.*

[Ms Piggy]

You know, the mod could really pattern the game to make us lose.

Thok got an innocent on Patrick definitely, as did I.

Therefore, he could make me sane and give me a 50/50 chance on investigating scum, or could make me naive on purpose and make me get an innocent and know nothing.

[Ms Piggy]

That's just assuming the moderator is evil, which hopefully is not the case here.

[Ms Piggy]

Vote: bird1111

Bandwagon!!!

[Ms Piggy]

Moderator Bird111, you are at lynch -1. Please claim.

[Ms Piggy]

Let's plan ahead in case Patrick did not get an innocent.

If Patrick got a guilty on either of you, that means he is paranoid.

What are our investigations tonight, then? Maybe we should keep our investigations a secret?

[Ms Piggy]

Darn!

So it looks like:

Patrick: Paranoid Cop
Ms Piggy: Sane/Naive
JDodge: Insane/Scum
SSF: Insane/Scum

I think this is virtually impossible to have a 100% chance of winning, because:

Since one of JDodge of SSF is insane, and one is scum, they can basically make up ANY result to show that they are insane. As in, JDodge could say he got a guilty on me, or an innocent on SSF. SSF could say that he got an innocent on JDodge, or guilty on me.

[Ms Piggy]

Oh wait, I messed up my post, disregard it. I got 2 hours of sleep last night and it's still in the morning. I keep messing up my posts today grrrr....

[Ms Piggy]

Patrick, SSF didn't get a guilty on me.

[Ms Piggy]

OMG I MESSED UP MY POST AGAIN!!!!


GRR Yeah I'm not going to get on this website again today.

Bye.

[Ms Piggy]

The play tonight is for me to investigate JDodge, and Ms Piggy to investigate SSF. JDodge and SSF investigate each other. Whoever is nightkilled, tomorrow the two suspects should probably have to claim their results simultaneously, and before the confirmed innocent.

Let's do it.

Vote: No Lynch

[Ms Piggy]

Good luck town!!!

[Ms Piggy]

Maybe we lynched the Mod by accident with those italicized votes. =D

[Ms Piggy]

Any news?

[Ms Piggy]

Bah! Go town! And I hate you scum! However, I believe in the good of people, so maybe the scum can be peaceful?

[Ms Piggy]

You died.

I don't know whether I was sane or naive. I didn't receive my result.

[Ms Piggy]

Cool! My 1st completed game. Well, it could easily have been JDodge as scum, but I guess it didn't seem that likely to you, Patrick?

[Ms Piggy]

They found you dangerous, not scummy.