SMITE Role Madness Mafia (OVER AT LAST!)

[Cephrir]

These are both townposting and, surprisingly, I find myself agreeing with them. I'm agreeing with FourTrouble guys, I think we've entered the twilight zone.

Why is agreeing with me surprising?

In both our previous games, I have found your thought processes to be counterintuitive / opposite the way I think as town. I thought you might turn out to be the kind of player I just tend to butt heads with all the time. But maybe I just needed to be town.

[Solar Wind]

f-16 has a strong townread of FT. I think I'd be leaning pretty town on my own, but that's a read where I feel f-16 is more likely to get it right than I am.

[Cephrir]

Spoiler: Cephrir sits on his ass looking at maps in the captain's cabin because not much happened on these pages

I was thinking about this game and thought about the gambit MS played against Xombie. I guess I'm too influenced by the playstyle of UberNinja and drmyshotgun but when you think about it, Xombie didn't have a reaction really which is weird because when I think about it more, I would have screamed and condemned Metal Sonic and created an ultimatum to get him lynched. But Xombie didn't do that. Instead, he was like "uhhh ok" which doesn't strike me as what a town player would usually say in that situation.

Why does Xombie reacting differently than you in that situation mean he is scummy?

Hi. It's not just reacting differently than me. It's just the fact that he supposedly knows he's town and is like "uhh ok" instead of "ur scum" sort of mentality and I would assume a newer player would shift towards "wtf are you doing im town" mentality if that happened to them.

This was my thought process, plus when you look at the wording he believes the claim is fake and then votes.
It's like, oh wait I said that was scummy let me vote.

I read this post. It didn't convince me. Meh.

post 28, FourTrouble"]/confirm

Town.

/confirm

Probscum.[/quote]
I would not have this entry post any other way. By the way I'm in this game because I saw AP/mastin/ffery/Tammycho on the playerlist

Mastin, you're voting someone that Nacho and I are both reading as town. :/

My read's not changing, but alright, as long as you realize I get MASSIVE "I told you so" rights postgame if I'm right.

Vote: -Blonde-

.

Why are you voting blonde? Please don't do that.

???

Are you expecting AP to post while he's V/LA?

I expect nothing from AP.

What I'd HOPE for from AP would be having a constant stream of readable content where his heart was in the game rather than in whatever place his distracted mind has placed it in (via his V/LA and multi-game priorities) so that one way or another I'd have a read locked down.

I don't.

Is it a null read or leaning scum read then?

Has AP had scum games where he doesn't have this constant stream?

I love this persistence. Reminds me of me when I get a bee in my bonnet!

Hey mastin. Who would you track tonight if you had the chance, and why?

I'm not in any way saying that i'm a tracker, or anything. I'm just trying to spark some interaction.
Mightve looked like I'm a tracker looking for advice or something, in hindsight.
eye

I'm not sure I love the level of self-consciousness here.

Hypocritically, however, I'm going to note this caused me to realize my spoiler titles could be taken as a crumb. They shouldn't be.

Matin why are you voting for someone who has been pretty much a non entity in the game?

Because he's the only scumread I'm comfortable voting. You'd be my vote if not for the Rach defense squad (still calling for bragging rights if you guys are wrong and I was right), and I'm not yet comfortable enough with the idea of AP being scum to vote him. I mean, I

could

vote him, a-la a "Hi, AP" in the same vein my Imperium vote was a "Hi, Nacho" type thing (no, I didn't actually think anything they posted on page one was scummy, it's just that I wanted to vote someone on P1 and they're the people I decided to go along with), but it would be just that, whereas with Blonde, here I'm actually making an accusation, vanity-driven as it may be.

Also, what ffery said; I've commented plenty on people being town.

This coooooould be town mastin.

Mastin
I call conf bias on me. I can't remember offhand a game when you did not think I was scum and every time I turned out to be town, so I would not be pushing on bragging rights just yet.

On the contrary, I have a rather excellent history reading you. You've turned up scum when I've said you would far more often than not, and vice-versa, too. Now, in spite of being a scumhunting god, no, my accuracy is not a perfect 100%. But nor is this confirmation bias. I'm scumreading you because you're posting things which I put a fair amount of confidence behind being scum, albeit not absolute confidence. Thus, why I backed down. You're a scumread, but I'm not going to push you when you're not absolute and you've got a defense squad insisting to the contrary. I'll just gripe about it in the background. A sort of, "I'm willing to admit I could be wrong, thus why she's this high, but if not for the defense she wouldn't be nearly this high; she'd be my vote" type of deal.

I have seen reads on Rach both ways now and I don't have a read at all. Feel free to enlighten me, anyone.

{read list with ZZZX near the top}

Eh?

Yo.

Vote: Imperium

.

Why?

Because screw you all, I am a scumhunting GOD.

I'm almost willing to sheep you based on the one post he's made since yours.

Not because it's a prod dodge, but that it looks like an opportunistic way to active lurk, given the two posts prior to it.

Mastin's vote was a joke.

I'm not sure what you mean by the two posts prior being an opportunistic way to active lurk.

p-dodging right after 2 others do also? Looks pretty opportunistic, to me. Drowning it in a group of post dodges increases town apathy.

Nah mate

[iHouse]

Was there something specific you wanted?

Not really, I just think you'd be easier to deal with at present because you aren't throwing a fit and S&S has taught me not to even try reading F-16.

You're nobody to criticize others for being difficult to deal with when you make walls the size of the Empire State Building.

I don't even bother responding to those posts because I don't feel like breaking out a jackhammer to break it down.

[Cephrir]

Yeah, catchup posts are so hard to deal with. Totally similar to completely flipping a shit.

I spoiled them so you don't have to read them if you don't want to.

[iHouse]

Yeah, catchup posts are so hard to deal with. Totally similar to completely flipping a shit.

I spoiled them so you don't have to read them if you don't want to.

I don't mind reading them. I was just telling you why I'm not bothering with responding to them.

[Solar Wind]

Jesus falcon.

Stop.

I hadn't posted for hours up until that point.

[Cephrir]

That's fine.

I make them half for my own benefit anyway. Having to put things down on paper helps me think.

Pedit: I don't read timestamps.

[Solar Wind]

Do you think you are particularly good at reading Ffery?

Also, if you wanted the argument to stop, why wasn't your post accompanied by a similar appeal towards Imperium/wanting Nacho to post more?

[Cephrir]

I don't know, I'm basically not played against ffery scum. I really want to though, I've always wanted to try my hand at catching her.

I can't answer that question without offending you, I'm afraid.

[Solar Wind]

It feels like you wanted to stoke the argument rather than mediate. I found it odd that of the people that posted after, Rach and Vezok winded up appealing to both of us, and you popped in with a "falcon stop," let Ffery post more. The others weren't effective at mediating but they were trying to.

[Cephrir]

I don't think I've ever intentionally stoked an argument in my entire life, mafia or otherwise.

Let's just not discuss this, I don't think it's going to help anything.

[Solar Wind]

I think it's relevant to your alignment but I'll let you catch up so we can comment on other things.

[Cephrir]

If you want to scumread me for my reaction fine, but I really don't want that to become the focus of this game.

[Solar Wind]

I don't see how you can read the past few pages and make the conclusion you did as opposed to telling us both to stop (which while lame is what I would a normal person to do like two other players did), or ignore it entirely which would have been preferable. Your post just felt like discrediting and manipulating what happened to scum advantage.

[Cephrir]

You're really going to make this impossible for me aren't you.

As tempted as I am to make cryptic statements that could help explain my actions and probably lead to you pushing me on it until I say more than I should, I'm going to stonewall the conversation here in the interest of everyone's emotional health.

[Solar Wind]

You made Post 1336 which makes no sense at all in context and actually fits with scum motive from you. If you can't see why I would think that, regardless of your alignment here, I don't know what to tell you.

[Cephrir]

I understand. That's not how I play scum, but I understand why you would think that.

I'm just asking you to drop it.

[Solar Wind]

Sorry, you're gonna have to explain because I'm not seeing some revelation here that explains your thoughts. This isn't out-of-game stuff.

[FourTrouble]

Why? I would love an answer that involved meta.

Answer that involves meta: F-16's emotion and timing.

[Cephrir]

Sorry, you're gonna have to explain because I'm not seeing some revelation here that explains your thoughts. This isn't out-of-game stuff.

Yes it is

[Cephrir]

I'm not talking about this anymore and I don't care if that bothers you.

[Cephrir]

Why? I would love an answer that involved meta.

Answer that involves meta: F-16's emotion and timing.

I'm sure you can guess that I'd like more than this. He was plenty emotional in S&S.

[Solar Wind]

I don't get why you are stonewalling here and I can easily see you do it alignment regardless. What is important is you explain the context of your comment because it is actually relevant to me figuring out your alignment. We aren't in any other games together so it can't be about ongoing games.

[Cephrir]

You won't take "you don't want me to explain" for an answer?