In post 5371, Slandaar wrote:Axle in terms of Boon I think you are giving him too much credit for thinking through his actions.
I don't really know what you mean by what the other team knows... if Boon claims PR and then BP what do they know? The BP claim is legit?
There is no way for them to decipher if that is a town, SK or scum claim. IF they had no PR's then yes, there is something in that, but evidently this isn't the case. Take for example the mafia with their Even night RB and compare to 1shot BP? seems fine to me but at the same time it could be a town PR there is no way to know. Obviously its also possible they have both of those PR's and wolves have 2 PR's and again there wouldn't be a way to know if the claim was Town/Scum/SK.
I am sure you claim that he wouldnt know is MB. I am sure team size will have told him that.
I think you are claiming that asymmetric scum teams seems fine and perhaps they are. But in MB where the scum teams are vs one another and town.
BP is pretty big edge to give one team and not the other.
I think you claiming Boon will think the scum teams might be asymmetric where one has BP and the other does not, is giving him too much credit. AND i think it wont balance with BP on one team.
At the very least I claim that if scum boon was BP the obvious thing to think is the other team has a BP too. or at least for Boon to believe that is likely enough that making a d1 plan based on hoping it is asymmetric seems very unlikely to me.
Boon is town. (unless you can explain this away)