Mafia v. Wolves Redux: Finally Over!

[Mastermind of Sin]

This is more perfect than I could've imagined. Mafia can kill Raffles all they please, they'll just get rid of likely scum for us.

Vote: IH

He's still two away, I believe, so we'll wait for Akbar before adding more.

[XReyoX]

I think IH would be my first priority for the lynch for today now. If he turns out to be mafia, then we would be able to know wheter ese=mafia. Also since you've investigated raffles last night and most of the cases against raffles was based on him being potential ese and him trying to persuade people that ese is not cult or something like that. This would be clearer soon i believe.

@shanba: I'm thinking that flay wasn't allowed to post since the middle of D2.

@everyone: What do you think have happened to flay. If it is a scumkill, I believe that it will happen again.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I have no information to base a guess on what happened to Flay, so I'm not going to try.

[TBuG]

I'd like IH to at least

post

before we lynch him. As well as Akbar.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Indeed

[bird1111]

In the process of rereading, will post if day is still going once I am done

[The Greg]

Yeah, the only reason I'm not voting yet is because I want to hear from Akbar and IH.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Do we need to get prods on them?

[XReyoX]

IH said he needed replacement. He have to wait till he is replaced

[Phoebus]

Last I heard IH was going to be playing.

[Battle Mage]

you forget that N9V claimed prematurely before in a game with 2 scumgroups. in fact, its so remarkably similar, its uncanny!

However, i think his claim can be verified, as there is one person in this game who should know almost certainly that it is true: The Cop who can detect Wolves.

in the meantime, i think an IH lynch is the best way to go.

Vote: IH

@BM: According to your theory suggesting n9v is scum, what do you think he is trying to achieve? trading 1 town lynch with his life? not quite profitable for his scum group at this time of the day I believe.

if that happens, he could easily claim insanity. otherwise, its quite possible that hes throwing his buddy IH under the bus, in order to confirm himself. Then he can go on to claim each of his other buddies are innocent.

BM

He'd have to be really stupid scum to claim right now. If scum are really stupid, they tend to give themselves away sooner or later anyway. Hence, I see no reason not to test his result.

Vote: IH

Also, why is everyone assuming N9V gets nightkilled? Last time i checked, we didn't have a dead doc yet.

[~N9V~]

Hmm yes. I sure as hell hope the doc isn't one of the inactives.

[XReyoX]

@BM: Were you trying to defend for IH when n9v first claimed, went silent to see how the wagon is heading, then now decide to bus him? The change of view from the last one to this one and the time gap between the two looks suspicious.

[Battle Mage]

no i wasnt trying to defend IH, moreso to raise a valid point AGAINST N9V. The fact that my stance has changed is due to the number of good points made against me, and the fact that his claim needs to be tested.
Nice try though. planning to lynch me tomorrow after you have bussed your buddy?

FOS: Xreyox

@BM: Were you trying to defend for IH when n9v first claimed, went silent to see how the wagon is heading, then now decide to bus him? The change of view from the last one to this one and the time gap between the two looks suspicious.

[XReyoX]

Nice try though. planning to lynch me tomorrow after you have bussed your buddy?

FOS: Xreyox

How would that work? And why would I want you to be lynched tmr if I were his buddy? You would be clear of suspicion if n9v investigate you tonight anyway, wouldn't it?

[DrippingGoofball]

I guess lynching DGB under LynchAllLiars for claiming that Battle Mage is not annoying can wait.

I will never, never again say that BM is not annoying. I am deeply ashamed of having suggested otherwise.

Take that to the bank. If I am ever in a game with BM, and he survives the night, I am not a vig.

[Kison]

Take that to the bank. If I am ever in a game with BM, and he survives the night, I am not a vig.

That is my new favorite Mafiascum quote.

Battle Mage, why is it that every time someone says something incriminating against you, that you assume that they are scum not only targeting you, but BUSing whoever they are voting for? How about looking from their perspective. By playing like this on a consistent basis, you imply that your play style is flawless.

[Phoebus]

Vote count:

2 Akbar (Kison, Shanba)

8 IH (~N9V~, Battle Mage, Dripping Goofball, Fuldu, Lowell, Mastermind of Sin, theopor_COD, The Fonz)

7 not voting

9 to lynch

[XReyoX]

Please hold off from voting IH for the moment, I wanna see him responding to the situation, as well as akbar responding to shanba. I don't see any point in rushing for the lynch for now.

[Battle Mage]

im guessing this is because i criticised your logic in another game today, after you made some rather silly comments.
OMGUS ALERT.

@Xreyox-post 1289 made no sense. Think, then type.

I guess lynching DGB under LynchAllLiars for claiming that Battle Mage is not annoying can wait.

I will never, never again say that BM is not annoying. I am deeply ashamed of having suggested otherwise.

Take that to the bank. If I am ever in a game with BM, and he survives the night, I am not a vig.

[Kison]

Nice try though. planning to lynch me tomorrow after you have bussed your buddy?

FOS: Xreyox

How would that work? And why would I want you to be lynched tmr if I were his buddy? You would be clear of suspicion if n9v investigate you tonight anyway, wouldn't it?

He wouldn't be cleared, necessarily, because N9V can only detect Mafia, so he claims.

[XReyoX]

Clear of being mafia. Thats what I'm trying to say. Because I am suspecting him being IH's scummate if IH turn out to be mafia.

[XReyoX]

@BM: which part(s) do not make sense?

[Fuldu]

Think, then type.

If I thought he was doing it deliberately, that would have gotten him nominated for a Coffee on the Monitor Scummy.

Since Battle Mage doesn't seem to care about waiting to hear from IH before we lynch him, I'll back off, but this is just to prevent a lynch before we can get additional information.

unvote: IH

[Mastermind of Sin]

Thanks, Fuldu. I was reading the thread and going "ohshit" when I saw he was one away, but you got to the unvote before I did, so I feel better now.

BM, I'm pretty sure DGB is referring to recent comments of yours in this game.