Mini 1597: Runecast Mafia - Day 5

[Ansuz]

back off kthnx, Bone, he always is like this.

Hiya UT, Bone still needs to explain his vote on me for my post. I will not let it go as not explaining things is scummy to me.....especially when he goes from 'kthx is caught scum' to 'I agree with caught scum and will follow with a vote because I agree so much with caught scum'.

Can't have it both ways and I want it explained.

This is pretty town.

[Ansuz]

No, actually gameplay vote seems legit

Why?

[Ansuz]

Lynx... I've read this post about three times now and I dint know why you're voting d3x. It seems to me like your main beef with him is that he called you fluffy while ignoring tunnel mates, but in reality it seems like he called both of you fluffy (no where in his posts does he call you fluffier than tunnel, and he's voting gameplay as opposed to either of you), which means that you're voting him because he says you're fluffy and that's it?

[Ansuz]

Okay, well

UNVOTE
VOTE: LYNX

Everything has already been said...

What's been said, exactly?

[Ansuz]

Could you also explain how HighShroomish going after game play in the same fashion would be townier than going after you?

Also, explain the hiplop read because it makes no sense at all.

[Ansuz]

Did you forget my vote was from a while ago? What's wrong with me waiting for other's reactions before making my choice final?

Many have reads and don't vote for them. I can't live my life in a way that makes you happy.

So, are you saying my reasons for finding them scummy aren't legit? Humor me.

A while ago, as in... last page?

[Ansuz]

Wanting mantis to post more. Not seen anything from him to move him away from the scum side of things.
Hiplop should post more
Highshroomish needs to be better.

I cannot see me voting for d3x at all today. If a wagon forms there I won't be on it.

Ossy opportunistically jumped onto a vote on me. I can understand one person voting for me, but the second so quickly meh...

Why is two people voting for you a big deal?

[Ansuz]

Wanting mantis to post more. Not seen anything from him to move him away from the scum side of things.
Hiplop should post more
Highshroomish needs to be better.

I cannot see me voting for d3x at all today. If a wagon forms there I won't be on it.

Ossy opportunistically jumped onto a vote on me. I can understand one person voting for me, but the second so quickly meh...

Are we playing the same game? Because I was the first to vote and am the only vote on you currently.

Holy crap.

Vote: kthxbye

Scum caught.

What did you even scumread in that post?

I didn't like his comments about RVS. I felt that saying "acum have a harder time with RVS' was a ridiculously scummy thing to say. So I poked at it to see what would happen.

yup are right. Sorry. Kthxbye didn't vote for me, just raised strong scum. Suspicions and then you came along and said I agree and voted. There wasn't actually a vote on me when you voted. Sorry
But you did join in with a tiny tiny mini wagon on me very easily.

So? By your definition of easy, every wagon formed is easy but I haven't seen you criticizing too many of them at all.

[Ansuz]

I think kthx is probably town for the angles he's been taking so far, particularly how he bothered Osseus as much as he did about the scum caught post. I also think that kthx as scum tends to be pretty tunnely while he's been all over the place this game, so I'm pretty sure he's town here. D3x aggression is looking good, gameplay seems so incredulous that people are scumreading him that it's hard to see him being scum, Lynx's logic is too fucked up to gauge whether he's scum playing reactively badly or just flailing about trying to figure out what's going on, geriantim seems pretty scunmy for how he's treating the vote on him, hiplop's still not doing shit, everyone else is being uninteresting (EVEN NOTSCIENCE AND BERT).

VOTE: geriantim

[Mantisdreamz]

Mantis, my love... why?

cause... dex, my love.. i'm just not seeing anything atm. i only really know you and kthx in this game (though, apparently bert, nacho, and NS are in it??) <- i can work with them too.

but you and kthx haven't said a whole ton that makes me think "town". so was gonna lay back for a bit and see.

i don't think that Osseus pseudotripodis (purely copy-pasted) was justified in voting kthx.

Bert and notscience are tunnel mates, desperado and nacho are in this hydra.

thanks

[Mantisdreamz]

I for one would very much like to hear Mantis's responses to OP's p84.

Mantis, my love... why?

cause... dex, my love.. i'm just not seeing anything atm. i only really know you and kthx in this game (though, apparently bert, nacho, and NS are in it??) <- i can work with them too.

but you and kthx haven't said a whole ton that makes me think "town". so was gonna lay back for a bit and see.

i don't think that Osseus pseudotripodis (purely copy-pasted) was justified in voting kthx.

Not.....justified? Do you even see what you just typed? I shouldn't vote a player I think is scummy? You even just said "....and kthx haven't said a whole ton that makes me think "town". So if you don't think they are town at the moment, why is it crazy for me to vote one of them?

well.. it was more that you seemed to be voting him for his style of posting.

you said,

Holy crap.

Vote: kthxbye

Scum caught.

in response to his post 51

maybe that wasn't the case.. but i kind of assumed that (possibly wrong assumption).

that's why i responded.. nah, kthx always posts like that

[Mantisdreamz]

*responded: "nah, kthx.." should be quotes there^

[Mantisdreamz]

There are 4 people scummier than d3x and you are voting d3x? Um no, sorry:

VOTE: Lynx
Not to mention that your scumreads are all people who have voiced suspicion on you. This is just so bad ( scummy).

i don't think it's scummy though. as town, i often get sus of those raising suspicions

[Osseus pseudotripodis]

typically, scum will wait until they're close to lynch to start flailing

geri... went a different way

[Mantisdreamz]

i'm undecided though on whether i think lynx is scum or not. gameplay seems town.

[gameplay506]

typically, scum will wait until they're close to lynch to start flailing

geri... went a different way

Why arent you voting me?

[gameplay506]

If you think I am scum, vote me, don't just talk about it.

[Mantisdreamz]

Dislike konowa referring to themselves in the 3rd person, but happy enough with their posts so far
Gameplay seems defensive
Mantis had so e posts and then a vote. The two seem unrelated to me.

Tunnel mates - my god I hate hydras. So much posts. So little content. Much annoyance. Because I can't say they aren't not talking but they give me nothing to go on. I hope they improve when the game gets serious


Just realised, I be been in a game with nacho mama too.

D3x is my fave in this game. I want them to stick around

Ansuz - posting but post 49 got my back up. The kind of post to get others to contribute proper content without themselves having to do so. If there is much depiction of this then I will vote against it

Plz translate this into reads. Use the words 'town' and 'scum'

Surely you don't need to see those two words to understand my post?

Konowa - more town than most

why?

Mantis - more scum, didn't like how his vote and his content didn't match up

i didn't even have any content though. except that i thought ossy wasn't justified in voting kthx.. for which looked like he was voting due to kthx's style.
my vote was random the first time. 2nd time, it was cause i saw kthx voting him, and figured the pressure would be good.

^saying that though, i had planned to remove it, cause i got thinking again that it still is a little useless. he's not around, so how much pressure can he really feel... that and how much longer should i keep my vote there.

Tunnel mates - no read, but I dislike a posting style that generates quantity but little quality. It allows a character to be in the game but give no one else anything to go on. So whilst I don't think yet they are scum, their style of posting is something someone scummy might do.

i like hydra, but personally am wondering about them at this point in the re read.

D3x - most town in the game to me.

ya

Ansuz - one of their posts I really didn't like so I will keep my eye on them for a while as I think they are scummier than most

which one?

Happy?

kinda sounds like you just quickly flung a few reasons together tbh..

[Mantisdreamz]

oh ya
UNVOTE: highshroomish

going to finish reading before putting one down

[Mantisdreamz]

typically, scum will wait until they're close to lynch to start flailing

geri... went a different way

Why arent you voting me?

he's talking about geri?
geraintm

[gameplay506]

Oh lol then forgot that post.

[Mantisdreamz]

Konowa likes LynxKuroneko as town. This is mainly due to the back and forth between gameplay506 and LynxKuroneko. Konowa was worried that LynxKuroneko had some godawful posting restriction at first. Thankfully that is not the case.

at first i was thinking it was town versus town as well. but i dunno how much i like lynx's reasons for his reads
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 7#p6100617

Konowa is pretty set on gameplay506 being scum.

D3x lol just lol. I am wondering how can somebody twist posts like that. So lets get this right:In post 31 I say that in your post 28 you make a big deal of me calling the formed wagons RVS wagons.Yet note that I didn't vote you for this. Then in post 62 you continue making a big deal out of it and finally in post 82 I vote you for both things. So where exactly does the misrepping come from? You are just twisting it so bad. And considering this now I think the liar tag fits you better.

Nope, nope, nope. Clearly in post 31 gameplay506 says that d3x is making a big deal out of things and is using later posts for "aggressive" justification.

Post #146 is nothing but loaded questions designed more to frame d3x as scum rather than try to determine d3x's alignment.

Konowa feels like he needs to look at other people. Konowa will do that soon.

oh wait. you didn't think it was T v T. actually, i kind of liked gameplay's push on lynx... maybe not the way he went about it. cause i didn't like that he said "everything about lynx is wrong", or whatever. but.. ya seemed more like town thinking they've caught scum for sure.

[Mantisdreamz]

Burning Earth reads town to me.

d3x, surprisingly, is reading town to me atm.

I don't like Tunnel, but I think it's posting style atm more than scummy.

HighShroomish is top scum on my radar.

noo i think it's more than his posting style.
reads-

mantis

d3x

hiplop

my scumreads, idk about my other head

we are both here right now

our faces have gone from red hot to ice cold

true facts, get it straight bro

we a high-profile addition to the division of town

why hiplop, why d3x? k.. i can get scum read on me maybee, cause i wasn't posting, and usually spam.


that and NS saying that he thought lynx was town, after lynx just stated that her gut scum read could be them
seems kinda... like maybe he was trying to appeal/buddy?

unless he was trolling and knows lynx's play.. or if he's had experience with lynx reading him as scum before, as town.
still don't like his reads though

[geraintm]

Wanting mantis to post more. Not seen anything from him to move him away from the scum side of things.
Hiplop should post more
Highshroomish needs to be better.

I cannot see me voting for d3x at all today. If a wagon forms there I won't be on it.

Ossy opportunistically jumped onto a vote on me. I can understand one person voting for me, but the second so quickly meh...

Are we playing the same game? Because I was the first to vote and am the only vote on you currently.

Holy crap.

Vote: kthxbye

Scum caught.

What did you even scumread in that post?

I didn't like his comments about RVS. I felt that saying "acum have a harder time with RVS' was a ridiculously scummy thing to say. So I poked at it to see what would happen.

yup are right. Sorry. Kthxbye didn't vote for me, just raised strong scum. Suspicions and then you came along and said I agree and voted. There wasn't actually a vote on me when you voted. Sorry
But you did join in with a tiny tiny mini wagon on me very easily.

So? By your definition of easy, every wagon formed is easy but I haven't seen you criticizing too many of them at all.

It was post 97 from ozzy. He just said "I agree with this and would like to raise you a...."

And voted for me. I thought it was ozzy voting for me very easily (just agreeing with someone else's reasoning).
Wagons are fine, but I tend to notice when someone voted for me. I was confused though and forgot it was actually only the one vote on me. I've said sorry for that.

[geraintm]

typically, scum will wait until they're close to lynch to start flailing

geri... went a different way

Am I flailing. I've been asked some questions and answered them to the best of my abilities.