Newbie 342: CHAOS in Peaceville - Game Over - who won?

[Peter Venkman]

DLMF has made one post.

It was a vote that put you at -2.

You said everyone vote on him.

You also said putting someone at -2 is not scummy.

I don't understand what part of his post you don't like. I asked a clear and striaghtforward question. Why do you continue to respond in vague terms??

-Peter

[zePPeLiN]

Seriously, guys, you should all be voting for DLMF right now.

If you have to ask that, it probably means that you are his scumbuddy.

Mr Stoofer, you are jumping to conclusion very fast on people with little evidence, which seems like a diversion. This is my first Mafia game but this seems very scummy to me. Anybody agree or am i totally wrong?

FoS Mr Stoofer

[Peter Venkman]

Anybody agree or am i totally wrong?

Whenever you ask this question to the players, remember that the remaining scum can respond. Listen to the players, but don't let them sway your vote too much.

-Peter

[Mr Stoofer]

We're back!!!

As you can see from this announcement, while the site was donw we lost a lot of posts.

Never mind, I suggest we just carry on from here!

As I remember, we had established that I had been jerking around to get discussion going.

The one thing that stood out was that DLMF had expressed strong suspicion of zePPeLiN. But despite numerous requests, DLMF had not explained why. I recall that I was happy with my vote on DLMF for that reason.

@DLMF

: Can you remember why you found zePPeLiN suspicous?

[Peter Venkman]

<phew>

That was a frustrating few days.

I'd like to get a "I'm here and paying attention" post out of everyone so we confirm everyone knows the forum is back in action.

-Peter

[zePPeLiN]

Im Here!

unvote

[Alasdair]

Let's cut to the chase! I am the cop. I investigated Peter Venkman and found him to be scum.

Vote Peter Venkman

Can I get a doctor?:(

[Norinel]

I'm back.

Let's cut to the chase! I am the cop. I investigated Peter Venkman and found him to be scum.

Vote Peter Venkman

Can I get a doctor?:(

Are you trying to kid us?

[Mr Stoofer]

~sigh~

Unvote: DLMF

,

Vote: Alasdair

.

(For those like Alasdair who haven't realised, the cop doesn't get an investigation until after day 1. Well, I suppose this is a Newbie Game, in which mistakes are supposed to be made. I hope we all learn something from this: i.e. if you are scum, make sure you understand the set-up properly before you make a fake claim.)

[zePPeLiN]

Let's cut to the chase! I am the cop. I investigated Peter Venkman and found him to be scum.

Um...Im pretty sure you couldnt have investigated anyone since it is still 1st day.. good try though..I really hope you are scum, becuase if you are a townie and fake claiming cop you just screwd us.

vote Alasdair

[Drunky McDrinksalot]

I can get down with that

Vote Alasdair

. Wow, just wow... This would be vote number 3... Even though there is little to no chance in hell that Alasdair isn't scum, we still need to let him say

something

.

[Mr Stoofer]

OK: NO MORE VOTING!

Nothing Alasdair says will stop me from voting him now. But a quicklynch is not in the interests of the Town: the only way we'll find the other scum is by discussion (unless he'd like to make such an error...) So there is no need to rush his lynch. We should still have a discussion.

In particular:

• I'd still like DLMF to explain hos attack on zePPeLiN.
• I'd also like Alasdair to flail around for a bit and hopefully incriminate his partner.

[Peter Venkman]

I love it when the scum make our job easier! =)

Almost Vote

on Alasdair.

-Peter

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

It's time for the first vote count of the day:

3 - Alasdair (Mr Stoofer, zePPeLiN, Drunky McDrinksalot)

1 - Peter Venkman (Alasdair)
1 - Mr Stoofer (DLMF)

Not Voting: Norinel, Peter Venkman

[Peter Venkman]

We appear to be waiting for DLMF to return?

I'll be certain to add my hammer vote when he gets back. I don' think Alasdair is going to say much now, after that incredibly stupid post.

-Peter

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

DLMF has been prodded for not yet posting after the downtime.

[Mr Stoofer]

I don't want anyone to hammer until DLMF or his replacement has posted.

[Alasdair]

With my last breath I curse Zoidberg!

[Mr Stoofer]

With my last breath I curse Zoidberg!

I'll take that as a confession. Pity. I was hoping he would defend himself and that his scumbuddy would give himself away in the ensuing debate.

I don't want anyone to hammer until DLMF or his replacement has posted.

This still applies.

[Drunky McDrinksalot]

I agree with you Mr S, but of course that means that people do need to post (I am just as guilty as the rest of the town here). No one really seems to want to post anything as they are waiting for the scum to make another mistake, which I doubt is going to happen today. At this point I almost wish someone would just hammer and get the day over with as I think that the well of info will be rather dry now that Alasdair has completely outed himself.

[Mr Stoofer]

Yeah, I know what you mean.

I said there were two things I wanted before the hammer:

• I'd still like DLMF to explain his attack on zePPeLiN.
• I'd also like Alasdair to flail around for a bit and hopefully incriminate his partner.

We're not going to get the second but I'd still like to get the first, though, before the hammer.

[Drunky McDrinksalot]

Agreed.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

DLMF still has not picked up his prod, so now I will begin searching for a replacement.

[Mr Stoofer]

OK, DLMF so is not coming back.

Let's wait for his replacement to check in and post his/her thoughts, and then someone can hammer Alasdairscum.

[zePPeLiN]

Quick question to people who have played, When DLMF gets replaiced, im guessing he keeps his role. Now the question is why did DLMF flake...

Option 1: He saw that the forums were down and thought they would be down for a while and just hasnt checked lately.

Opton 2: Saw that his scum buddy pulled the most OMGUS move ever...and thought there was little way he can win.