In post 558, Thor665 wrote:I don't even understand how this constitutes a defense or response.
Well, yeah, I lied, but it was *content* so it was okay. Also, town doesn't *know* that their case is perfect, so it's totally legit that I lied to advance a case because, hey, who knows, maybe my lies would be real.
I am amazed you expect anyone to buy this.
What are you talking about? Our job is to look at facts and create theories about them. We have to appear confident in our theories to draw out reactions. You insist on calling it
lying
. Are you doing this to make me look bad to the others? It's a cheap trick.
In post 561, Elyse wrote:Your argument of you doing your "fake case" to break Thor's hold on the game is A) contradictory and B) nonsensical.
Think long and hard about this. I don't make sense to you, so that makes me confirmed scum? Only confirmed scum would not make sense? Or are you simply failing to understand how I play and what I post because we are two different people?
You're saying that I would start the day with posting little to no content, absorbing the game, then turn against the one person in the game that was defending me, Thor.
Yes, because Thor also contradicted himself, much worse than anything else in this game, here:
In post 557, Thor665 wrote:His case was...not complicated.
I presume he went after me, as I've already said, because I'd already indicated distrust of him and was the only other experienced voice in the game.
Thor was the only one to actually defend me at the beginning of the game:
In post 201, Thor665 wrote:I actually think I agree with ABR there.
Let's lynch Slandaar now.
From my point of view, he was the friendliest and the one that defended me the most. It makes no sense for me to go after him as scum. It would be extremely non-strategic of me.
Elyse, work with me here. Don't throw away the lynch because you don't trust me. Re-evaluate. If you're town, you're going to have a harder time in this game with a Day 1 lynch on me with no counterwagon whatsoever, just like IceNinja says. You won't get much information. I'm gong to flip vanilla townie.
You can proceed to wrongly blame me as Sir Bastion, saying I made "mistakes". No, I made no mistakes. I'm uncertain about who is scum. That's not a mistake, it's a real challenge. I can't say who is scum for certain, but out of everyone, Thor is playing the most black and white, and therefore I think he's the scum. He started as a gut read, back when I thought he was defending me with meta. I chose that time to go against him. I derailed the wagon on him because of my own doubts. Not because "I was going to get caught". If I stayed on Thor, it would be in the same shoes as Slandaar right now, exchanging wall posts with Thor, each arguing our points without ever agreeing. There was a chance he was going to get lynched as well, which I wasn't prepared to take responsibility for. The reason why I asked Slandaar if he was certain about Thor, that he would not unvote once Thor gained a bigger bandwagon, was because I myself had doubts about it, and Thor plays scum well enough to create doubts in my mind.
It's your decision to lynch me, it's your responsbility to think about all the pieces in this game, beyond contradictions, beyond the mind games we play, beyond changing our tactics midway through something. I haven't done anything crazy scummy, Thor is pushing way too hard on me instead of scumhunting, I made a very direct claim, and it's time to move on. I will unequivocally represent a real and dangerous threat to scum, if left alive. If they don't lynch me now, it will be hard for them to do so later. Don't let them have this lynch. And if you do, don't you dare come blaming me later. This is on you.
Guard your honor. Let your reputation fall where it will. And outlive the bastards.
