I know this wasn't supposed to be a PBPA, but this is more notes for myself, so ignore if you want and go to the bottom of this post.
STD's first serious post does a pretty good analysis of several players in the game, calling out Cesspit and Mathcam as scum, with Pooky and SV to a lesser degree, and Yos/Ibae as confusing scumtownies. He brings up a decent point about Yos in this post, but since Yos was town, I guess it really didn't mean much.
He votes Cesspit a few posts later.
I'm confused by his argument against Mathcam, but he was protown, too, so I guess that one was wrong anyways.
Unvotes Cesspit, no reason why. Quotes a couple of my posts with a "?" after them, I don't know what he was getting at with that.
Asks me some questions about Cesspit, then asks me another question that I didn't understand and asked for some context about.
Ignores my request and moves on to vote MMoD when it's pointed out that he keeps saying he'll reread but never does.
Goes back to Cesspit, no reason given.
FoS's Pooky, no reason given
FoS's HP, gives some sort of reason, I'd have to read in context to understand it.
Willing to vote Cesspit and MMoD
Responds to my argument with MBL, where I asked someone else to field his post for me, but since he's not convinced of MBL's scumminess, he won't. Wonders why I didn't respond to him FoSing Pooky.
Wonders why I reacted to his Pooky FoS after he pointed it out. (I explained that I didn't think the FoS meant anything, so there was nothing to respond to, but then he said that it meant something about me that I didn't say anything in response to a baseless FoS, so I responded to him asking what he was expecting)
Unvotes (confused)
Votes for Fuldu, no reason given
Doesn't like Pooky appealing to emotion
Further response to me about the Pooky issue. (I don't know why STD was expecting me in specific to respond to the FoS: Pooky, but apparently that's what he wanted to see)
More discussion about the Pooky issue
Not seeing MBL as scum
Makes a kill/no kill list:
Kill - armlx (Protown), Uraj (Protown), Coron (Alive), Fuldu (Scum), H_P (Alive (Quagmire)), MBL (Protown), MMoD (Alive), Pooky (Alive), mathcam (Protown), Oberon (Protown)
No Kill - ibaesha (Alive (Thok)), Mastermind of Sin (Alive), Save The Dragons (Alive), spectrumvoid (Alive), Yosarian2 (Protown)
Gives reasons for putting people on the list.
Forgot reason for voting Fuldu, unvotes
Confused
Thinks MBL is town, slowly becoming more suspicious of Mathcam (I like his analogy)
Points out that SV blocking MBL and Mathcam doesn't clear them, asks when SV blocked them. FoSes SV, close to voting SV
Equally split between voting Fuldu, SV, and Uraj
Votes SV
Unvotes, Votes Fuldu
Votes Uraj for metagaming this late in the game (This is where the money for dragon preservation starts, in case you care)
Wants Uraj to be lynched, thinks MoS is scum
Asks questions and reads thread to answer them
Still wants Uraj dead.
Wants his old office back.
Nothing in his new office. Wants back in Jack Phillips' Office
Analysis/Questioning of STD begins here:
Unvotes Cesspit, no reason why. Quotes a couple of my posts with a "?" after them, I don't know what he was getting at with that.
Asks me some questions about Cesspit, then asks me another question that I didn't understand and asked for some context about.
Ignores my request and moves on to vote MMoD when it's pointed out that he keeps saying he'll reread but never does.
Goes back to Cesspit, no reason given.
I would like an explanation of this, both the lack of reason for unvoting and revoting Cesspit, plus the ignoring my clarification request when you had apparently unvoted Cesspit based off something I said/did, then moving straight to MMoD and disregarding the whole thing with Cesspit.
I'm still confused somewhat by the whole FoS Pooky thing, but I think I kinda see where STD was coming from, so I guess that's fine. I think it was mostly miscommunication between us, anyways.
I'd like to hear what STD has to say about Coron, Quagmire, MMoD, and Pooky (those four in particular).
I also want to know why STD went from saying that he felt I was genuine and shouldn't be lynched, then was stating I was scum while wanting Uraj lynched, but today, the only posts he's made have been about his new office and wanting his old one back. If you really think I'm scum, why haven't you voted me or presented reasoning to get me lynched, since your #1 suspect, Uraj, was lynched yesterday?
Also, why has SV bounced around in your suspicion list? You had her on your no kill list, but then you wanted to lynch her, Fuldu, and Uraj equally, and even voted her. Then, yesterday, you went after Uraj and mentioned that I was scum, but never even talked about SV at all.