Newbie 1428 Game Over

[Nobody Special]

Sakura Hana replaces Cat Clancer effective immediately.

[Sakura Hana]

Hi guys, reading the thread now.

[Sakura Hana]

First of all

Unvote: Whoever my predecessor was voting

Page 1, only 1 post looked weird to me.

19 - Doesn't sit well with me the reasoning, wagons are good in RVS to get reactions going.

Page 2.

28 Hi Dys!
30 This looks very genuine, Dys can go to my early townpile.
35 Doesn't sit well with me, like he points stuff but stays on the sidelines, bigterp can go to my early scumpile.
36 You could say the same thing about Post 35, why didnt you comment on it?
43 Also doesn't sit well with me, it's like saying "it might be scummy but it might not"
44 This neither, questions pieguy then votes someone else because he wants to see what happens with 2 wagons going?...
45 Ok cheery can go into my early townpile as well.
48 Going into comedy muddies the waters and gives scum hiding places, jsyk.

On to page 3...

[BigTerp]

First of all

Unvote: Whoever my predecessor was voting

Page 1, only 1 post looked weird to me.

19 - Doesn't sit well with me the reasoning, wagons are good in RVS to get reactions going.

Page 2.

28 Hi Dys!
30 This looks very genuine, Dys can go to my early townpile.
35 Doesn't sit well with me, like he points stuff but stays on the sidelines, bigterp can go to my early scumpile.
36 You could say the same thing about Post 35, why didnt you comment on it?
43 Also doesn't sit well with me, it's like saying "it might be scummy but it might not"
44 This neither, questions pieguy then votes someone else because he wants to see what happens with 2 wagons going?...
45 Ok cheery can go into my early townpile as well.
48 Going into comedy muddies the waters and gives scum hiding places, jsyk.

On to page 3...

Welcome to the game!! Glad to see your coming in ready to play. I'll address above what pertains to me.

We've already addressed 19 as being a joke.
How am I staying on the sidelines in 35? I questioned Dys' vote to put someone to L-1 early, he responsed and I agreed.
Feels like your really trying to reach with pointing out my 43
Yes, early wagons help the town. Just like you said when questioning my 19
So what about others voting because someone said "turf" or someones school mascot is the wolf. RVS is just that, random. Nothing wrong with adding a little humor to it.

[Viera Assassin]

Hi guys

We all know why you came here...

[BigTerp]

Hi guys

We all know why you came here...

Waiting to hear your take on the game. In case you missed it, I had some questions for you here 215

[Sakura Hana]

Page 3.

54 Just replying that you can highlight text in a post before clicking quote to only quote the highlighted part.
55 Would be nice if you said why you think those are weak reasonings.
58 Why do you have to overexplain such a simple thing?
60 newbscum tend to buddy people, newbtown are paranoid of people, my predecessor should be obv newbtown at this point.
64 Are you scumreading anyone?
69 Why do you think you are an easy target? do you plan on doing anything to prove to me that you're not scum instead of complaining about the wagon on you?
70 Ravenpaw seems to be questioning people with alignment determinent questions, goes to townpile too.
71 If you're town, less AtE and more scumhunting, If you're scum, continue on, you're heading to the rope the way you're going.
72 He's not sounding nervous, he's sounding frustrated, but he just sits there instead of trying to find scum.

Page 4.

81 You really got some explaining to do.
83 So are you gonna explain why arent you doing it here?
92 Quotes or it didnt happen.
93 So ok, you proved he's nervous, so?

On to page 5...

P-Edit: I'm probably reaching and I hope you've done something by the time i finish reading all pages

[Sakura Hana]

Page 5

100 Totally agreeing with my predecessor here.
104 I've seen scum do "reaction tests".
106 Ok Ravenpaw is my strongest townread now.
112 Will love to see said explanations then.
113 Is pinging me the wrong way, seems like pieguy is more concerned about looking town than being town, mostly because he seems too worried about his actions matching what he's saying. So pieguy, you unvoted, why arent you doing anything with your vote when you have to have by now

at least

1 scumspect?
115 Good question.
116 I agree, who do you think is scum?
117 That's called tunneling, it's a null tell at most, and your vote is callled an OMGUS.
118 Except she's townreading him?
119 Reads change over time, specially in newbie games because newbies are the most unpredictable players.
122 I disagree, her posts look like legit scumhunting to me, do you even have any scumreads yet? oh right you haven't scumhunted at all, oh wait no, you're scumreading her, for scumhunting, right.

Page 6.

128 Oh looks like someone is starting to discredit people.
130 I entirely agree with Raven here and Flareon's probably who I'm going to vote after I'm done here if nothing changes my mind.
147 If it's on the wiki most likely most scum are aware of it and will avoid it, so Null. Tryhard discrediting much?
149 I thought alts couldnt join newbie games?

On to Page 7....

[Sakura Hana]

Page 7

Not much to comment on (considering there's like a penta post in there)

Page 8

Seeing Grimgroove as possible scum too, I think we got the scumteam!
184 I do agree with Cheery here tho, even if that point doesnt have scum motivation, I still like Flareon for scum.
188 Uhh no, that's not how it works, if you want to accuse her of unhelpful questioning you need to bring evidence.
194 Yeah, why are you comparing 2 different people who could potentially have 2 very different playstyles?

On to Page 9...

[Sakura Hana]

Page 9

201 So what's your stance on Grim?
204 Oh cool you're here too (tho i had already noticed when i did my last P-Edit ), unfortunately tho i think you replaced into a scum slot.
[post[214[/post] Leans town to me which nullifies the scum read i had on him earlier. I concede and i'll give you a null-town for now.

And I guess that's about it.

Vote: Viera Assassin

@VA: Have you iso'd your predecessor? What do you think about them? What do you think about Raven?

Current Reads:
Town: Raven
Null-Town: Dys, Cheery, Groovy guy
Null-Scum: pieguy
Scum: Viera Assasin.

Null: The rest.

Guess we can start forming a town bloc from here.

[weberer]

First of all, SORRY FOR NOT POSTING.

I got the FBI virus (for those of you who don't know what it is, it was a thing like a year ago and is scary as fuck, you should look it up). So I've spent the last couple days trying to save my dying baby, but lo and behold, success!! I have returned it to life, so now I will take an active role in this game.

That virus is becoming epidemic, to be prepared and for those in need, here are all the best removal instructions collected by my brother:
http://privacy-pc.com/how-to/fbi-moneypak-virus-computer-locked-by-fbi.html
http://privacy-pc.com/how-to/remove-fbi-moneypak-virus-if-safe-mode-doesnt-work.html

Sorry if it looks like spam but people should be prepared

[pieguyn]

unvote

hi Sakura =w=

64 Are you scumreading anyone?

it's in the post right below that

83 So are you gonna explain why arent you doing it here?

that wasn't even directed at me, I was just pointing that just cause someone thinks something is acceptable doesn't mean that they necessarily have to do it all the time

92 Quotes or it didnt happen.

you're not gonna get any, cause it wasn't a serious townread :>

113 Is pinging me the wrong way, seems like pieguy is more concerned about looking town than being town, mostly because he seems too worried about his actions matching what he's saying. So pieguy, you unvoted, why arent you doing anything with your vote when you have to have by now at least 1 scumspect?

in the same post v

Haven't thought much about who it could be cause I just woke up T_T

then 30 minutes later after I woke up completely I started my whole case on Cat kthx

Null-Scum: pieguy

I love how you just continued what Cat was doing instead of coming up with new things. trying to finish what Cat started as scum mb? I find it so hard to believe that both of you can coincidentally accuse the same person with incorrect logic = =

vote: Sakura Hana

[Dyslexicon]

My reads:

Dyslexi, Bigterp and Pie are all strong town reads and should never be lynched.
Cheery I lean town on, but he really needs to post more to solidify this read.
Grim is null and I don’t really trust myself atm in being able to read him as it’ll be strongly tainted by my own personal bias.
Michael is null leaning scum, mainly because of his lack of content, as well as Banksys mentioning his name in her last post, makes me paranoid.
Cat leans scum due to the stuff I discussed above.
Viera is scum and needs death immediately.

Can you explain your read on BigTerp further?

Welcome to the game!! Glad to see your coming in ready to play. I'll address above what pertains to me.

We've already addressed 19 as being a joke.
How am I staying on the sidelines in 35? I questioned Dys' vote to put someone to L-1 early, he responsed and I agreed.
Feels like your really trying to reach with pointing out my 43
Yes, early wagons help the town. Just like you said when questioning my 19
So what about others voting because someone said "turf" or someones school mascot is the wolf. RVS is just that, random. Nothing wrong with adding a little humor to it.

To be fair I think your stance and questioning on me was kind of blah.

60newbscum tend to buddy people, newbtown are paranoid of people, my predecessor should be obv newbtown at this point.

Hi Sakura!^^

How is that post relevant to what you are saying here? It says basically nothing.

Current Reads:
Town: Raven
Null-Town: Dys, Cheery, Groovy guy
Null-Scum: pieguy
Scum: Viera Assasin.

Null: The rest.

Guess we can start forming a town bloc from here.

I didn't check your every post you linked to, but I think you spent a good amount of time to question BigTerp, so how is your read on him null?

[Sakura Hana]

Oh yeah I knew i was forgetting someone, considering he didnt have that much content later on i forgot about him.

[Sakura Hana]

He's also null-scum btw.

[Viera Assassin]

Still technically on V/LA.

Can't really promise anything yet.

[Dyslexicon]

Oh yeah I knew i was forgetting someone, considering he didnt have that much content later on i forgot about him.

And my other question?

[Sakura Hana]

I have null reads until I ISO.
ATM

This shows that the player is paranoid, so he doesnt know who's town or who's scum.

[Viera Assassin]

Tough luck replacing into a scum slot, eh

[Sakura Hana]

I love how you just continued what Cat was doing instead of coming up with new things.

Coincidentially we ended up with you and Viera in the scumpile, your reasons for voting him is that he didnt explain anything, and so far I've explained everything? Is there anything you want to ask me?

Unrelated, get an avatar

[pieguyn]

no I voted him cause everything he did was antitown
he just blindly followed people by making up a bunch of incorrect reasoning and then didn't explain any of it even when I asked him multiple times. he also misrep'd me like 4 or 5 times. Then he made no effort to pressure me any further or anyone else, really

So far you're doing the exact same thing he did by not replying to anything I said.

ok since you seem to want questions here's some

newbscum tend to buddy people, newbtown are paranoid of people, my predecessor should be obv newbtown at this point.

explain this plz. In fact I'd expect the opposite, newbscum are afraid of people cause they're afraid saying anything will get them lynched..
also, explain how he was paranoid of people. for me it just seemed like he wasn't posting anything

Is pinging me the wrong way, seems like pieguy is more concerned about looking town than being town, mostly because he seems too worried about his actions matching what he's saying. So pieguy, you unvoted, why arent you doing anything with your vote when you have to have by now at least 1 scumspect?

why do you think I'm worried about my actions not matching what I'm saying, when what you claim I did is exactly something that doesn't match what I said?
and anyway, I did do something with my vote which proves how BS that statement really is

Totally agreeing with my predecessor here.

except he's guilty of doing pretty much the same thing. why do you follow someone whose own "reasoning" would call himself out as suspicious?

Yeah, why are you comparing 2 different people who could potentially have 2 very different playstyles?

why do you call him out in particular when I'm sure other people mentioned words such as "playstyle-based" etc.

aw come on I'm too lazy to get an avatar = = and I don't take orders from scum kthx :>

[Sakura Hana]

explain this plz. In fact I'd expect the opposite, newbscum are afraid of people cause they're afraid saying anything will get them lynched..
also, explain how he was paranoid of people. for me it just seemed like he wasn't posting anything

I learend that from Nacho actually, tho they usually buddy strong people (or are paranoid of strong people)

why do you think I'm worried about my actions not matching what I'm saying, when what you claim I did is exactly something that doesn't match what I said?
and anyway, I did do something with my vote which proves how BS that statement really is

Because when you got caught by Raven you immediately went into fluff.

except he's guilty of doing pretty much the same thing. why do you follow someone whose own "reasoning" would call himself out as suspicious?

Regardless of what you think about it, I still agree with that reasoning, you've done almost nothing in terms of scumhunting, and a supposed reaction test that.... didnt test much in the end.

why do you call him out in particular when I'm sure other people mentioned words such as "playstyle-based" etc.

Because playstyle for 2 different people is going to be different, just because one person's playstyle is the same as another person's scum playstyle doesnt mean that the former is scum, in fact anything playstyle related should be a null tell.

[Sakura Hana]

and I don't take orders from scum kthx :>

lol
You dont take orders from scum, yet im your "scumread" and you did ask me question as i asked you to ask me.

[Sakura Hana]

EBWODP: the questions*

[pieguyn]

I learend that from Nacho actually, tho they usually buddy strong people

(or are paranoid of strong people)

yeah that's what I said

Because when you got caught by Raven you immediately went into fluff.

that's not fluff, that's me responding to what he said. I also stated I had an intent to go back and do something more useful at the end of the post, cause I hadn't woke up yet = =
plz tell me exactly where in that post I seem worried about "my actions not matching up with what I said" btw

Regardless of what you think about it, I still agree with that reasoning, you've done almost nothing in terms of scumhunting, and a supposed reaction test that.... didnt test much in the end.

I agree the reaction test didn't work, but saying I did almost nothing is a huge misrep

Because playstyle for 2 different people is going to be different, just because one person's playstyle is the same as another person's scum playstyle doesnt mean that the former is scum, in fact anything playstyle related should be a null tell.

hey wait a minute

This shows that the player is paranoid, so he doesnt know who's town or who's scum.

this whole "scum buddy people and town are paranoid" is the exact same thing, classifying scum playstyles. convenient you're using this kind reasoning to defend the previous player in your slot who now might as well be you, while also attacking someone else with it