In post 2898, Dyslexicon wrote:
If you don't see anything alignment indicative, how come you had me as scum in your first posts?
Same reason I'm voting for you now. I don't see what everyone else did to call you town, and I think that your scumhunting, if you can call it that, is not genuine.
I'm advocating finding and lynching scum, but to each his own.
In post 2902, Xiao Long wrote:
Anyone reading Jmo as town seriously needs to go back to newbie queue, though.
No need to insult anyone who disagrees with you. Having played with Jmo before, I just don't think that your case holds water, as Jmo is like this as town, and given his interactions with Varsoon d1, I think that he's town this game and not scum.
In post 2904, Saki wrote:i have very huge problems with all of you atm (except for xiao, maybe)
y'all are saying jmo isn't confscum
that tells me one of these things
a) you don't believe me TRB claim
b) you're trying to deny the obvious (every single possibility in which jmo is not scum is total bullshit)
a.) I believe that you're town roleblocker, so no need to get huffy.
b.) There are multiple ways that you can block someone who is town and a kill still not go through. It's understandable that you have to vote that person, given your view of the game, but that doesn't mean that everyone else has to.
In post 2904, Saki wrote:
numbers must obviously be a good argument since y'all had hard-ons using it to try and get me lynched D1
I don't deal with numbers. I deal with possibilities, and assume that anything is possible unless proven otherwise, which I think is a good line of thought, since I've seen some crazy crap in my time. Just because the odds are low that something is the case doesn't stop it from being true.
No.
In post 2919, Paschendale wrote:
On that note, if Jmo is such an obvious lynch, why is Dys sitting at L-2 and Jmo not? Some people have some explaining to do.
I think Jmo is town and that Dys is scum.
In post 2933, TunnelVision wrote:
So when are you going to be read up? It's been what, almost a week now? Can you post some reads? Make a case on someone? Or are you just going to ride other people's wagons until someone finally pays you attention?
VOTE: salmonelladreams
Attention granted. What are you doing in this game? Because right now it feels like you're just skating along under the radar.
Rank
It took me about a week and a half to catch up. It's not surprising that Salmon is still not current in the game. Given his progress, it won't be long before he's on the same page as everyone else.
In post 2942, Saki wrote:I'm saying all the PRs are out.
If there was truly a doc save then they would've claimed by now so they could clear JMO. (+1 conftown, never bad)
No they wouldn't. A doc protect would have been on one of the PRs, not on Jmo, and a doc claim still would do nothing to clear Jmo other than saying that someone else was protected. All a doc claim would be doing would be putting a target on the doc's back. Therefore, the doc should not claim. Period. I also find any insistence on massclaiming to be highly suspect at this point in time.
Question: Who first proposed a massclaim?
In post 2944, Xiao Long wrote:I think the only possibilities are: saki roleblocked correctly, or Cherry is 1-shot bulletproof.
You are leaving out other obvious possibilities, such as a PR being protected by a doc.
In post 2948, Paschendale wrote:So let's look at behavior instead. Specifically, Bulb's. I see questions and some analysis, but not much in the way of conclusions. One vote for the lurkiest player, and no opinions that could later be used against him. This is safe play. With all the wacky shit going on, safety is not a priority for a town player right now. Bulb is almost textbook active lurking.
We have 4 claimed/confirmed PRs. That leaves a pool of 6 other players to find scum in. I have town reads on Jmo and Salmon. I think Oriole and Flench are likely to be town, although I'm starting to wonder about my Oriole read. I have a scum read on Xiao, but TV got an innocent on him, so there's nothing to pursue there. That only leaves Dys, who is
actually
active lurking. If you can't see any conclusions in my posts, then you aren't looking hard enough or asking the right questions.
