Max seven.In post 2928, Xiao Long wrote:I dunno, I think doing a list of who to claim can prevent any scum from trying to CC or lie about being a PR. How many PR's can we have?
After looking it over I think that massclaiming is a bad idea. I think the massclaim helps the mafia more than it helps us. I'm open to arguments against it, but right now I would not support a massclaim.In post 2931, Flench wrote:I've been spending some time looking at the setup and I doubt there are any PR's left that haven't claimed (haven't done the math). Mass claiming would be ok I guess, I disagree with letting people wait, hinting they are a PR but not actually claiming, that lets mafia just never claim until the end and say yea I'm a PR so I waited, it's a bad idea.
So when are you going to be read up? It's been what, almost a week now? Can you post some reads? Make a case on someone? Or are you just going to ride other people's wagons until someone finally pays you attention?In post 2926, SalmonellaDreams wrote:Still not completely read up, but I'm willing to lynch jmo/dys.
that's not my pointIn post 2932, TunnelVision wrote:I think the massclaim helps the mafia more than it helps us.
I thought bolding my correction would be helpful.In post 2938, Saki wrote:that's not my pointIn post 2932, TunnelVision wrote:I think the massclaim helps the mafia more than it helps us.
there is no need to massclaim since wePROBABLYalready have all our PR's out on the table.
No broseph. Fail. If CherryDrPepper is SK instead of TownVig, they could be a 1 shot bulletproof SK and survived the hit last night. Or, the mafia targeted Titus last night because they figured CherryDrPepper was lying about hitting Titus. Or... OR... ORRRRRRRRRRRRRRR MORE WIFOM.In post 2940, Xiao Long wrote:If you guys are thinking all of our PR's are out, then Jmo is confscum as there was no doctor save.
I know Rank, and this is sarcasm. It's not cool. By page 90, and staying current with this dayphase (I know you have), you can contribute. Please do. We won't be mad at you if you miss something, we'll just point you to it. What do you think of the DYS or Oriole case?In post 2937, TunnelVision wrote:Oh ok, cool.
This is why we should stop talking and lynch JMO because what you're doing is creating the very same WIFOM you love to hate.In post 2941, TunnelVision wrote:No broseph. Fail. If CherryDrPepper is SK instead of TownVig, they could be a 1 shot bulletproof SK and survived the hit last night. Or, the mafia targeted Titus last night because they figured CherryDrPepper was lying about hitting Titus. Or... OR... ORRRRRRRRRRRRRRR MORE WIFOM.
The problem is, it makes no sense for mafia to target Titus as apparently not many people saw how obvtown she was. Also, there were two outted PR's that they could have targetted. I think the only possibilities are: saki roleblocked correctly, or Cherry is 1-shot bulletproof. Judging from Jmo's play all game, I think the former is correct.In post 2941, TunnelVision wrote:No broseph. Fail. If CherryDrPepper is SK instead of TownVig, they could be a 1 shot bulletproof SK and survived the hit last night. Or, the mafia targeted Titus last night because they figured CherryDrPepper was lying about hitting Titus. Or... OR... ORRRRRRRRRRRRRRR MORE WIFOM.In post 2940, Xiao Long wrote:If you guys are thinking all of our PR's are out, then Jmo is confscum as there was no doctor save.
I already think Oriole to be town, and I think that Flench or Dys is scum.Dig into Oriole, or Dys. Or Flench or Salmonella or Bulbazak. We have 6 people that we need to figure out and you're stuck on 1 of them. Even if you're right about JMO, there's still another scum floating around. Let's find that person.
That doesn't work if the scum nails CherryDrP to the wall tonight. We don't get the NK's we want as quickly as we need them. They kill off our conftown's as fast as we kill off the VT's and we're not where we should be.In post 2944, Xiao Long wrote: I already think Oriole to be town, and I think that Flench or Dys is scum.
Salmonella and Bulb are null to me. I'm not stuck on just Jmo, though, I've already listed an easy win for town if Cherry cooperates. It's simple, we kill the VT's.
Town vastly overpowers scum atm; there is no reason for town to wait for a night phase.In post 2945, TunnelVision wrote:That doesn't work if the scum nails CherryDrP to the wall tonight. We don't get the NK's we want as quickly as we need them. They kill off our conftown's as fast as we kill off the VT's and we're not where we should be.In post 2944, Xiao Long wrote: I already think Oriole to be town, and I think that Flench or Dys is scum.
Salmonella and Bulb are null to me. I'm not stuck on just Jmo, though, I've already listed an easy win for town if Cherry cooperates. It's simple, we kill the VT's.
-1-
Suggesting a plan is bad because of an obvious possibility != trying to create WIFOM, whether you agree with the logic or not.In post 2947, Saki wrote:"That doesn't work if the scum nails CherryDrP to the wall tonight."
Also note that there is the chance that I roleblock correctly.
It's also noted that you were trying to create wifom around who scum would target at night when you obviously think (as everyone else should) that Cherry is the primary scum NK target?