Key: absta101 -> absta, Alabaska J->AJ, Bub Bidderskins->Bub, DCLXVI->DCL, Generic->Gen, Kid A->Kid A, Kingsrush->KR, levio->levio, NotThePope->NTP, Om of the Nom->Om, RadiantCowbells->RC, Smudger->Smudger, TMTOLBTWNTOF->TMT, yessiree -> yessiree
23 (DCL) - Minor RVS backpedaling by DCL. I would have expected DCL to stick to his guns instead of argue semantics over "serious" vs. "
more
serious."
24 (NTP) - Would have expected NTP to vote for DCL after calling him out. Instead shifts to RC. AJ spots this in 25.
26 (Smudger) - Inappropriate RVS vote. Really should have had something to say by then.
38-40 (Kid A, RC, Gen) - Ditto. Where's the content? Some points for wagoning though.
42 & 43 (absta) - I might be biased, but I like this pair of posts.
44 (NTP) - NTP spends an awful lot of time arguing with DCL in defense of Bub. Especially considering that NTP is voting for RC.
49 (absta) - Good point against AJ.
51 (Bub) - And Bub manages to show exactly why wagons move the day along. Also, he calls NTP town. Definite link, but that doesn't mean much while they're both still alive.
54 (NTP) - What is this hydra bullshit. One head thinks RC is town and the other thinks he's scum. Great.
58 (Smudger) - No stance taking, but I'll hold my judgment until his next post.
65 & 66 (KR & Kid A) - Thanks for the input...
79 (Om) - Case on NTP feels padded, but at the same time I can't say that NTP is very townish.
98 (levio) - So levio is annoyed that people don't think absta is scum but levio isn't even voting absta, she's voting NTP.
I guess levio's newbTown, but the .gif avatar and the run-on writing style just makes her posts annoying to read.
105 (RC) - Good post.
112 (Smudger) - I still don't know who you think is scum. Looks like absta was thinking the same thing (114).
119 (Smudger) - Trying to discredit Bub. Kind of like OMGUS, except without a vote and actually scummy.
132 (Kid A) - Bad vote on RC. Wouldn't call it scummy, though.
137 (RC) - Also a bad vote on Kid A. Should have stuck with the DCL vote.
152 (absta) - I guess this is a decent point about AJ. I'm not "feeling" AJ as scum though, but that might change depending on what I see as I catch up.
157 (AJ) - Satisfies me somewhat... still think that AJ is placing less pressure on Bub than one would expect from town. Though AJ is hardly the only one to do this.
I'm a little weary of someone with "Best Mafia Performance" under their username, though. I don't know how recent that is.
160 (Kid A) - Blunt. I kinda like it.
159-162 - People need to learn to cut down their quotes. It reduces clutter.
169 (Smudger) - It's around this time that I realize that half the players in this game will OMGUS at the drop of a hat.
176 (N) - This is some of the most scattered voting I've ever seen. With only Gen not voting anyone, 9/13 players have a vote on them, and no one has 3 or more votes. Also these jokes really are extremely shitty.
206 (DCL) - Nothing scummy, but I don't see any new scumhunting from a player who has just been sitting on a levio vote for what seems like forever.
231 & 232 (NTP, Om) - Agree with Om's analysis for the most part. Definitely think NTP is exaggerating his case on Gen massively.
242 (yessiree) - Wow, thanks for quoting Generic's posts about NTP. I can't think of a feature literally encoded into mafiascum that could have enabled me to find this information myself. This will greatly help my analysis of Generic, which is important because you didn't provide any yourself.
248 (yessiree) - You've got to be fucking kidding me. Could you be any more useless? You're not fooling me with your smilies.
233-249 and so on - Feeling better about DCL after this exchange with Om. Had a scum read on DCL, but this bumps him up to null.
251 (NTP) - Can I just say how shitty the bolded-replies-within-the-quote system of responding is? I would literally prefer a series of broken up quotes, even though that's cluttery as hell too.
NotThePope wrote:What makes those games take prominence over this one? Maybe the fact he [Generic] ALREADY KNOWS THE SCUMTEAM
Do you read what you type?
255 (N) - The real shitty jokes are the ones that people are trying to pass off as cases in this game.
260 (RC) - Well, at least this case is well-constructed for a change. But I feel like it fails to account for the fact that Kid A is a wildcard/newbTown.
278 & 279 (Smudger) - I will grant Smudger that this is a legitimate callout of DCL and RC, respectively.
295, 296, 300 (yessiree (x2), Kid A) - This game. This fucking game. Is ridiculous.