Newbie 1368 - Will there ever be a title? (GAME OVER)

[Core_H86]

I'm here just reading the 19 pages. My third game taking my time trying to take advantage of all the content and interactions between players hoping to find a consistent scum partnership. Don't plan on readng previous game treating this as a new game and never used meta as a tell. Hi all!

[Syryana]

I'm here just reading the 19 pages. My third game taking my time trying to take advantage of all the content and interactions between players hoping to find a consistent scum partnership. Don't plan on readng previous game treating this as a new game and never used meta as a tell. Hi all!

Welcome! We look forward to your reads.

[Candillan]

Okay so I'm home
What did you guys want me to comment on?

[Core_H86]

^#1 suspect

[Core_H86]

^#1 suspect

[Candillan]

Why?
I honestly don't understand what's so scummy/suspicious about me.

[Core_H86]

sorry double post and dont start OMGUS attacking me, Candillian I'm still only up to page 9 took a break back to reading....

[LnGrrrR]

Sorry for the delay guys. Got in-laws coming into town tomorrow, a bit busy.

TOWN:
Me
Grim - been over this already
Homer - asks good questions, gives solid analysis
Syr - This is more gut than anything, but I think upon realizing his "scumslip" mistake, if he was actual scum he would've tried to spin it instead of just owning up to it. Felt annoyed by his mistake in later posts and refuses to justify attacks based on it.

NULL
Crand/David - Provides a lot of analysis, but doesn't actually challenge many people with questions
RachMarie - Leaning slight town. She has stopped lurking and I don't see anything coming from a scum mindset.

SCUM
Ravenpaw - Didn't scumhunt, didnt pressure with votes, really didn't do much. Lets see what Mothrax does.
Candy - duh

INCOMPLETE
Shaboo

Actually looking over the thread and ISOs, Im surprised by how little questions are actually being asked. A lot of analysis, but not a lot of questions. The huge amount of lurk replacements probably isn't helping much.

Are there any questions anyone has of me in case I am the lynch? Any posts they want me to explain? I don't have a lot of info, and I could be completely wrong about the scum team, but Im willing to answer whatever.

[Candillan]

sorry double post and dont start OMGUS attacking me, Candillian I'm still only up to page 9 took a break back to reading....

I didn't attack you o_o
How did my post look like an OMGUS attack?



Also, everyone misspells my name as 'Candillian'
There's no second "I" ;~;

[Syryana]

I didn't attack you o_o
How did my post look like an OMGUS attack?

He's saying don't OMGUS him yet, he's not done

Also, everyone misspells my name as 'Candillian'
There's no second "I" ;~;

Hush, Candyland

[Candillan]

I didn't attack you o_o
How did my post look like an OMGUS attack?

He's saying don't OMGUS him yet, he's not done

Also, everyone misspells my name as 'Candillian'
There's no second "I" ;~;

Hush, Candyland

Ah, alright, I'll OMGUS him when he's done, then.


That name is acceptable.

[Core_H86]

Sorry for the delay guys. Got in-laws coming into town tomorrow, a bit busy.

TOWN:
Me
Grim - been over this already
Homer - asks good questions, gives solid analysis
Syr - This is more gut than anything, but I think upon realizing his "scumslip" mistake, if he was actual scum he would've tried to spin it instead of just owning up to it. Felt annoyed by his mistake in later posts and refuses to justify attacks based on it.

NULL
Crand/David - Provides a lot of analysis, but doesn't actually challenge many people with questions
RachMarie - Leaning slight town. She has stopped lurking and I don't see anything coming from a scum mindset.

SCUM
Ravenpaw - Didn't scumhunt, didnt pressure with votes, really didn't do much. Lets see what Mothrax does.

Candy - duh

INCOMPLETE
Shaboo

Actually looking over the thread and ISOs, Im surprised by how little questions are actually being asked. A lot of analysis, but not a lot of questions. The huge amount of lurk replacements probably isn't helping much.

Are there any questions anyone has of me in case I am the lynch? Any posts they want me to explain? I don't have a lot of info, and I could be completely wrong about the scum team, but Im willing to answer whatever.

Sorry for the large post... I'm reading from both sides here could you elaborate, only ask because from page 1-10 he's my #1 suspect

[Syryana]

Ah, alright, I'll OMGUS him when he's done, then.

This is acceptable.

[mothrax]

I'm not fully caught up but we have Aprox 25 hours to lynch. Someone please explain the case on Lngrr to me.

I'm much more interested in a candi lynch. He constantly calls his "tells" reaction testing, and I'm amazed the whole thing with "it was a joke" was dropped. I'm going to bed but I will be around tommoroe hopefully to finish my catch up.

Vote Candillan

[Syryana]

I'm not fully caught up but we have Aprox 25 hours to lynch. Someone please explain the case on Lngrr to me.

Long story super short, the tone in his posts this game is dispassionate and emotionless compared to last game.

Spoiler: Longer now

Spoiler: Longer then

[Candillan]

Wait, am I at L-2, or L-1?


Also, Syryana, I'm offended. That was nowhere near my case on him. ;-;

[mothrax]

I'm not fully caught up but we have Aprox 25 hours to lynch. Someone please explain the case on Lngrr to me.

Long story super short, the tone in his posts this game is dispassionate and emotionless compared to last game.

Spoiler: Longer now

Spoiler: Longer then

So it's basically meta? Not sure if I like that. And by not sure I mean I don't. Anything more specific?

[Candillan]

This.

To be honest, the part that initially bothered me about you was the fact that you called Grim town for something he did as scum. Then, from that discussion, you twisted my case into "whatever he does that's town is scum, and whatever he does that's scum is scum" which was a blatant misrep that you still haven't rescinded. My case was different, and you refuse to acknowledge it. Closed-mindedness is anti-town at least, if not scummy. Your dismissing of him as town for something he did when he was scum still rubs me the wrong way. I don't think a townie would do that, and it seems as if you know he's town.

Then, you made post 194, which read as super scummy. It made it seem like you were justifying him being alive so you could pin blame on him D3 for still being alive.

Also there's the point about the Switzerland complex he's having. He isn't making enemies of anyone aside from me. He hasn't listed any scumreads aside from me, and that, especially, bothers me. Not because of OMGUS, but because he's trying to get you all to warm up to a mislynch by getting on all your good sides. He didn't even deny it when he was asked about buddying to Grim.

Is that enough?

[Syryana]

Also, Syryana, I'm offended. That was nowhere near my case on him. ;-;

I posted my case on him. Why would I post yours?

[imkingdavid]

I'm not fully caught up but we have Aprox 25 hours to lynch. Someone please explain the case on Lngrr to me.

Long story super short, the tone in his posts this game is dispassionate and emotionless compared to last game.

Spoiler: Longer now

Spoiler: Longer then

Can you provide specific examples of posts last game vs this game to better illustrate your point?

Also, is his change in tone the only reason you find him scummy?

Although, I suppose given your "100%" confidence in Candi being town, you're just going for the next most probable lynch, no?

Wait, am I at L-2, or L-1?

L-2 by my count.

I too would prefer a Candi lynch today. I am definitely willing to put Candi at L-1. However, is there anyone that's willing to hammer (after a claim of course)? Me moving my vote back to Candi would be pointless if no one is willing to hammer. Then again, I'm don't remember if anyone has yet stated intent to hammer LnG.

[Syryana]

Can you provide specific examples of posts last game vs this game to better illustrate your point?

Also, is his change in tone the only reason you find him scummy?

Although, I suppose given your "100%" confidence in Candi being town, you're just going for the next most probable lynch, no?

Gimme a minute on that one.
Yes.
I'm not lynching LnGrrR because I don't want to lynch Candyland; I'm lynching LnGrrR because nobody wants to lynch Rach.

[Core_H86]

still reading from both ends of th wick and have no vote. any player feel my vote should go one way or the other?


Preview edit^obviously still catching up because that makes NO sense.

[Core_H86]

I mean seriously Syrana WTF does that mean in post 489 please dont confuse me. I feel i'm at a disadvantage to help.

[Syryana]

So it's basically meta? Not sure if I like that. And by not sure I mean I don't. Anything more specific?

Part meta, part tone analysis.

Spoiler: Have a look at LnGrrR last game

Not posting IS scummy. That said, if someone comes out and says, "Hey guys, I'm ACTUALLY town, but I just figured, why don't we mass claim all the power roles so we can coordinate during the night chat? "... Then I reserve the right to swing my vote over to them.

Numberfour, technically we don't have to lynch, but its better for us to lynch because otherwise we give the mafia a "free" kill. Also, you're off my list.

You know we are eventually going to have to lynch right? If we don't lynch the first day, then we are one person down, and we have no way to reliably look at info for the first day and analyze based on scum/townie flip. So we would be back to square one. How a person votes for a lynch is probably the most important information to review. Or we could just all talk about sports and the weather until the mafia picks us all off one by one.

Grimgroove is quite correct in his assessment of what list I was talking about. Thanks for saving me the trouble of explaining.

That said UNVOTE: , VOTE: Archetype.

It's likely that he will be prodded anyways, but I haven't read enough from others to get any strong townie/scum reads.

EBWODP: Er, I meant quieter, not quoted. Damn you autocorrect!!!!

Maybe the title is "Title Pending"

Blah!

VOTE: RachMarie

There

Yeah I get that slow games suck but what if he's a PR? And if he never comes back then we'll get a replacement, so either way it's better to wait and see. In the meantime if Number4 is scum, there's still one other scum we can be hunting for while we wait for him.

The other scum is probably Rachel :p

God, we would've lost so bad. Though I think Candy and Raven's overt buddying would've caught up with them.

Spoiler: Look at him now

OOC: Thanks Candy. I'm near the St Louis area. So far nothin too bad, though our tree in the backyard broke a little and we will probably have to take it down. No more shade for us.

The second spoiler doesn't actually even need the spoiler, really. I grabbed all the posts with an emotional tone (be it joking, happy, sad, whatever) from the first game I found on quick inspection of his ISO from the first game and this game. See the difference? You can see his mood in his posting in the first game: cracking jokes, easily interacting with others on a not-game level (e.g. joking, little asides not related to Mafia, etc.). Here his posting is almost purely mechanical; he's simply acting and reacting in accordance to stimuli thrown his way. It really shows when I can only find one post in his entire ISO (excluding RVS, that's silliness by default) that isn't mechanical. It really helps a lot if you do a side by side of his ISO there and his ISO here, the difference is much more noticeable.

And some of you are probably wondering why I find this such a strong point against longer; the reason is that tone, above all other things in this game, is the hardest to fake. I know this is true from personal experience, both in my own scumgame and that of others. Longer was more easy-going, less purely reactive in the prior game. He shows none of that here and has been pretty much pure game-face (Mafia is srs bznss ) since the start of the game.

Pedit: Core, it was mostly a joke. I'm pretty much saying that I think Longer is scum based on his tone this game. This post should clarify it for you.

[Core_H86]

Hey it's ok Syryana I'm not voting yet...But for the rest, I lean a candillan/syryana team (only read up to page 13) I could note Candillan has never voted for Syryana and Syryana only voted for Candillan for two post (for insignificant reasons) Where is the pressure of your votes?(Syryana?) What throws me off is seeing your join date and knowing you (syryana) can't be that good of scum. ----Taking input from others beings we have less than 24 hours to investigate and catching up this far is proving to be difficult.