1.) It's the Vig's choiceCES wrote:If you're so sure we have a cult and a vig, then why don't get the vig to claim?
2.) If the Vig claims, they could:
->
->
3.) I would rather force scum out into the open as opposed to a useful town role
1.) It's the Vig's choiceCES wrote:If you're so sure we have a cult and a vig, then why don't get the vig to claim?
So you were a gunsmith and not a cop but in the process of discussing what a gunsmith is, you didn't even consider that it's most often accompanied by a vig in the game?klebian wrote:This is the reasonin from my claim of pooky/adele as scum yesterday, I really didn't consider a vig (what's a forced-vig, exactly? He HAS to kill every night? And how would his choice work if he forgot to send in a choice?) as I didn't think that a reasonable vigilante wouldn't think through his kills enough to kill the cops both nights..
Hardly. I believe I was the first head to post the possibility of a cult, and I considered it because I agreed with your comment that three cops didn't make sense and thus the "results" demanded another explanation. The scum are the people who'd prefer to rush the day through without getting everyone on the record or fully exploring possibilities.amb wrote:To me, I feel as though the whole cult thing is springing up from Glork's scum buddies (or being pushed along that line) to create confusion.
No, my MGM comment was in reference to something else.I see MGM is being credited by MrBuddyLee for MBL's theory that SV/Kleb are cult
MoS is basically right/telling the truth.Mastermind of Sin wrote:Please vote Lowell/Sprontalic, they're scum. My other head thought it would be funny to claim scum since he doesn't have time for this game anymore, especially since someone seems to think we're scum. Cops are often considered to have guns when the gunsmith role is used, since RL cops usually do carry guns. The gunsmith claim could also be a lie, however, which would give us two scum now. This is a pretty open and shut case. Lynch Lowell/Sprontalic, then SV/klebian.
I have gone over this already. If spec/kleb are cult, they would only have hadAmb wrote:THe mafia havent managed to nuke a single cult member to date, and we havent managed to lynch one. Either the 'cult' is very inactive in it's recruiting abilities, or we are very unlucky. 9 Deaths out of 17 players, that would make the cult so potentially big that it would be an all out Cult vs Mafia game. That doesn't appear to be the case.
Yes, I know. That's why I said I don't buy it.Cogito Ergo Sum wrote:Zindaras, MoS is Glrok.
No. There's a chance of there being 3 Mafia left and no Cult. Not lynching Glork would be a horrible horrible move in that case.MrBuddyLee wrote:If I was the least bit unsure about kleb/sv before this recent activity, the gunsmith claim removed just about the last speck of doubt.
The only question is what to do now. I think some number crunching is in order, and everyone should participate. The fundamental question is: does it make any sense to lynch cult right now instead of GlorkOs? My guess is no.
Vig-->Cult=Ouch.Cogito Ergo Sum wrote:I mentioned straight away that any vig should claim.petroleumjelly wrote:1.) You tried to downplay it until it was obvious I was not going to curl up and go away.
Dude, trackers are clearly more common than gunsmiths. Gunsmiths aren't really common, but they definitely occur.
If you're so sure we have a cult and a vig, then why don't get the vig to claim?