In post 301, Kinetic wrote:In post 300, Zdenek wrote:- The attack on him for disappearing was unwarranted.
- The attack on him for skimming when he said Kinetic rather than PV is poor because people get names wrong all the time.
- I disagree with the "setup to vote LLD" as being scummy. LLD's attack was reaching and him wanting her to explain herself makes sense.
- The logic of his attacks makes sense to me.
Here's what I agree with:
- I regard the points relating to him not playing to his post in Mafia Discussion as fairly weak. That argument seems to be something more along the line of a he's not playing what he believes is an optimal strategy argument as opposed to a he's scum argument. It's not an unreasonable point; I just don't think that it's good case for him being scum.
- the OMGUS happened, but I believe this is a bad scum-tell.
- the AtE, this has come up a lot, and it's the thing that I would actually be surprised if he did it as scum, but that's wifom so I like I said, if you want to lynch him for it, I don't care.
God damn it. This is a really good post.
Grumbleunvote.
In post 361, Kinetic wrote:
I'll admit, I'm not 100% sold on the Matt case,butI'm having trouble with his targets as well. Xalve I can see. I would even put PV above Xalve, but I'm not seeing LLD and I'm not sure why he's 100% on Zd as well (although, granted, I've moved Zd to scummy neutral on my list away from solid scum). If anything, that is selling me more on the MattP case then on Tierce's attacks. I agree on his quadz town read though, and although I'm not 100% on his play, I do agree on Tierce though so he's not completely out of it.
Bolded should be "and" then because it makes no sense, it's like saying "I dislike you but I don't enjoy your company"
I don't understand why you thought Zdenek's points were good and it looks not like weird flipflopping because of this new post. I don't understand how you thought Zdenek's points were good (and I would like you to explain how they were good) and then fencesat here and then through out crappy weird opportunistic reads on three lurkers and said without knowing anything about them that there are 1-2 scum there. It's very sloppy