In post 2373, mastin2 wrote:Except, they don't. I've already explained in crystal-clear detail the difference between you and Tammy. Khan's already explained in great detail the difference between you and Tammy. Everyone off the Tammy wagon has already explained the difference between you and Tammy.In post 2372, Acosmist wrote:In post 2370, mastin2 wrote:They literally had no choice but to have her dead, and it quite franklyneededto be by lynch.
The assumptions you have here lead to me being 100% confirmed town in your eyes. Do you want to walk this back or can we lynch you now?
The points are there, in our isos. We lay out in detail why the scum needed her dead yesterday.
And we also lay out in detail why you're, in contrast, a very good lynch.
And let's assume, just for a second, that you're hypothetically town.
The scum can endgame a PGO. They don't need the PGO killed, least of all in the hands of a player who if town is a complete moron. They don't even need the PGO lynched, since again, the PGO presents no threat to them. As long as they leave the PGO untouched, there's nothing about the PGO which is a threat. The PGO only helps them, via town roles doubting the PGO claim and targeting the PGO, and/or the town doubting the PGO claim and pushing it through. There's pretty much zero scum motive to push for a lynch on the PGO, since again, the PGO once it's known to be a PGO is completely and totally harmless to them.
It's the exact opposite of Tammy. During the day, I imagine the scumcan'tendgame her, because she can still shoot. Maybe during the night, they could, especially since she wasn't bulletproof. They do need her killed, especially since she is a competent player who was clearly showing a town mindset. They could kill her, yes, and had we not lynched her, they would have, but because they could push her mislynch (AND I DO CALL IT A MISLYNCH!), they did so. Tammy had been shown to shoot scum. Tammy had been shown willing to play ball with the town, to roll with their ideas. Her role was already known and PROVEN, so there was no town doubt. She was an extreme threat, hindering them every step of the way. There was EVERY scum motive to want her dead, as laid out in my iso, among others. Tammy, once known to be a day-SK, was even MORE of a threat to them than Tammy was before she was known to be a day-SK.
The difference is as clear as night and day.
'Course, it's all pointless to talk about the difference between scum pushing the PGO vs. scum pushing the day-SK, since Acoisn'ta PGO and is, in fact, still scum.
The lynch is the only way to kill Tammy because...oh no, you just confirmed my PGO claim.
How does that feel?