Amrun wrote:Yes. Crazy isn't scum.
I'm planning on voting empking and/or tar. Any problems?
Well I'm town and I'm more confident of the quicklyncher than Tar.
Crazy wrote:I hammered Quilford because I thought he was scum, knew that nothing would change my mind, and I wanted to lynch him before anyone had a chance to unvote.
Why is that a problem?
Amrun wrote:I'm planning on voting empking and/or tar. Any problems?
Empking wrote:Because you din't give anyone else a chance to work out who (if nor Quilford) was the scum.
Crazy wrote:
You can argue against my actions, I suppose, but I don't understand why that would necessarily make me scum. I've explained why, as town, that I felt the need to quickhammer Quilford. Can you accept that, or not? If not, then why would the quickhammer benefit me if I was scum?
Crazy wrote:What I mean is, if I was scum, why would it especially benefit me to hammer Quilfordthen, as opposed to waiting? The only people in danger of being lynched were Quilford and you, and obviously from your perspective, you're town, right?
Crazy wrote:I suppose so, but you're already arguing the point that it'spossiblefor me to be scum. Of course anything's possible, but why is itlikelythat I'm scum? Why is your argument for why Crazy-scum would hammer Quilford better than my argument for why Crazy-town did hammer Quilford?
Empking 1560 wrote:I'm really sure that one of Tar and Quil is scum
imaginality wrote:I'm not at all happy with Crazy's quick-hammer. There's obvious scum benefit to cutting the day short and hammering a townie. It would be bold for scum to hammer like that considering the other quick-hammerers this game (kunkstar and DGB) both got lynched. I'm going to meta him and see how he plays as scum.
Empking and Crazy could be distancing/bussing scum, I think. I'm wary of how Empking only commented on Crazy so far - for example:@Empking, what happened to this theory?
Empking 1560 wrote:I'm really sure that one of Tar and Quil is scum
I got a really really cool semi-bastardly role, a Mafia Godfather that would flip Vanilla Town when he was lynched. Instead of doing the logical thing and just acting like Vanilla Town, I decided to do an absurd fake-claim. When 3 people claimed miller Day 1, I made a not-so-hidden "breadcrumb" that hinted that I was also a miller, or as I later changed it, a "miller-like" role. I think I changed my mind about exactly what I wanted to claim several times.
My eventual role-claim on Day 3 was that I was a Kleptomaniac that would be forced to steal something from another player each night (which would also roleblock them, I think) and then I would be revealed as whatever that person's role was when I died. That got me lynched, and I flipped Vanilla Town, but everyone knew I was scum anyway. If that wasn't bad enough, I used my role to confirm one of my scumbuddies which inevitably got her lynched the following day.