My Little Pony Mafia - GENOCIDAL FRIENDSHIP PONIES

[Jahudo]

[quote="GLaDOS"]since even getting another bandwagon at that point will be nearly impossible given the large amount of V/LA's we've had requested in this thread./quote]
What other wagons would you rather see larger than hers right now? How many other people would make better lynches today?

I think Mina is a good lynch and I'm prepared to hammer.

[Charlie]

Wait.

[hohum]

Wait.

Elaborate.

[GLaDOS]

... Processing ...

Jahudo, reread what you quoted and you'll have answered your own question. The point is that because Mina has managed to not claim and we now have less than two days until deadline, then even we decide to spare her for today then

getting

a wagon on somebody else will be nearly impossible (in part because there

are

no wagons on anybody else, which is exacerbated by V/LAs).

[inHimshallibe]

^Bussing.

Interesting.


P confident on Mina, aintcha.

[Primate]

Nothing really stopping me hammering. Not going to do it before she claims though (unless she waits out the deadline). There's little chance of starting up another wagon, but there are roles she could be for which it's a shame for them to die without revealing actions.

[Pinkie Pie]

IN CUPCAKES WE TRUST.

[Pinkie Pie]

Just wondering, who was/is a part of Fluttershy?

[Charlie]

Wait,
because I'm here and resuming my read. I'll of course address the current issues first.

[Jahudo]

Glados, I meant to ask whether this is a compromise vote for you. And if there was a specific person you would have hypothetically liked to see as a competing wagon.

Fluttershy was an alt of Ant_to_the_max.

I'll also wait for a claim.

Also I sent in my neighborizer info so that's ready to go. Though I might have to change it if her wagon breaks down and we lynch one of the people I picked.

[Charlie]

Page 6 & 7

+1 Arguments for lynching Equinox

What is this? I don't remember this.

Agreement, ATPIT with Gammagooey's 127

Page 8

Can somebody explain to me why are lists floating around?

This is referring to Gamma and I making scumlists in back to back posts. Are you taking an issue with any part of it?

In one game I played in, probably a newbie game, people threw a fuss about making lists because it helps scum narrow down targets for NK. However, in other games lists are generally accepted. I guess it depends entirely on the players. Please note I'm not confused over the issue of back to back lists; I can see it quite clearly.

I stop to think about how much "Town points" Jahudo has accumulated... I don't usually use these points system, but if I do then I'll say he's too Town to be Town... make sense yes? Yes, it does. I'm a bit cautious about him from now on...

I'm kinda surprised to hear you say this. Gamma and others didn't get any overwhelming town sense from me. Do you disagree with his opinion in any specific ways?
Why do you think the other active players didn't make as large an impression on you up to this point?

If any

pony

body is overwhelming, it's you. That's my opinion anyway.
He had a lot of opinions and was influential. Unless you specifically point out which opinion it is you want me to comment on, I can't say because it's too general.

Page 9

Gammagooey says that both nHimshallibe and hohum are Town (This is notable)

Notable as in, you agree with him?

Ah, yes I do.

Page 10

chesskid3 +100 WTF

His inhim vote? Can you elaborate on what you think of it?

I also think hohum is right up there in the first tier of vocal players.

Well at the very least he could try to explain/reason it out! If he wants to throw out votes in a seemingly random manner then he can play with dice.
Hohum was averagely vocal i.e. the fourth from the top.

-----------

...i think im lost about the lark owl refrence.

so, inhim lost the argument because he was emotional? i personally...really tried to understand the points of the inhim, jahudo argument, but i may need a brief explination from the two.

Its nothing much really for others; It is mainly a footnote for myself: larks are early risers and people who are active during the day, owls night people who prefer to sleep late and wake up late.

I'm calling AtE. It basically nullifies a read on a player by masking up a post with emotions.

-----------

Also, Charlie, please find a way to reformat your catch-up posts. The way you are currently writing them essentially requires me to reread the entire game in order to follow along to see if I agree with everything you say. Instead, please use a few blue links (urls) in your posts, or maybe use some sparing quotes to make your points. Right now, they are pretty much useless to me unless and until you link your commentary to something concrete.

I'll see what I can do about that. Hey, I know you're an alt; can I know your main, please?

------------

I've been asked to check up on the Mina case, which I'm going to do now...
But please, a summary? Any

pony

one?

[Charlie]

*Done reading*
I don't think Mina is a very good lynch Today.

[Charlie]

Page 11

hohum +1 vocal
After having second thoughts about Equinox, I

can

justify what she's doing to be Town.
Fluttershy 262 is +2 Discord
Jahudo, your 263 first paragraph first line is wrong. Details, Jahudo. Details! To follow through to your next post, I don't get what you're doing with those line of questioning of Fluttershy. Feels too easy, too easy...
Do you think of yourself as a 'details' kind of person?

Page 12

Surprise! I think Equinox is Town here
Hey, more laughs to be had on this page! Thank you lots, people.
Jahudo, 291 "Anymore", hmm? Interesting... I

would

ask for an elaboration, but I think the details part would suffice.
Btw, that last post is Town-Jahudo (+1 Friendship)
Please note that he has already exceeded the basket of friendship cookies, thus crossing the standardized chart for Town reads.
Yeah, Mina's catch-up @ 294... hohum says: Meh. Jahudo says: It's allright. I say: good effort. But really I don't know what to make of it. Sure provides some fresh content though, and this is always a good thing, right?

Page 13

Interesting! Equinox says Mina is prob Town @ 304. I hope every

pony

body understands the implication of this statement.
305 Jahudo... hypocrite, eh? Well, how about "a vote for -player- because he did not do Y is invalid"?
The arguments begin to intensify towards the bottom of the page until I'm getting confused on who to trust. Good points were made by all, but ultimately I realize that we have a lurker problem. I cannot ignore this.

Page 14

Ugh, look at this post, guys... look at this! 331 I see... a possible connection!
This page is very interesting. Might be the core of things because I read Jahudo as... strange. Ugh, this is creepy.

Page 15

@Mina: Content, Mina. Content! Not fluff.
@CES 368: Scum: CES, Jahudo, Fluttershy (?)Pinkie Pie
Serious.

------------

Goodnight.

[inHimshallibe]

*Done reading*
I don't think Mina is a very good lynch Today.

Alternative?

[Charlie]

Up to page 15?

@CES 368: Scum: CES, Jahudo, Fluttershy (?)Pinkie Pie
Serious.

[GLaDOS]

... Processing ...

Ah, it seems I misread

your

question, Jahudo. As for potential competing bandwagons, suffice it to say that here is where I am currently standing:

Leaning Town

hohum
LobsterCatapult (rep. Fluttershy)
Charlie (rep. Ojanen, rep. Maziek)

Middle of the Road

inHimshallibe
Primate (rep. TheLonging)
Feysal (rep. Espeonage)
Cogito Ergo Sum (rep. chesskid3)
Jahudo

Slightly Worse Off

Pinkie Pie

Leaning Scum

Mina

As you can see, there’s been only some minor shuffling since my first list, but my original two suspects have not changed. Both you and Cogito Ergo Sum have lost your slight edge over the “middles” after my reread; in fact, the only reason you are in the middle is because of your claim (although I have rather recently seen a game with a scum neighborizer). If I were judging you solely on your play, you should be in the “Slightly Worse Off” category.

~

Charlie, my main account is petroleumjelly.

[Twilight Sparkle]

Day 2, Votecount #9

Mina:

hohum, Pinkie Pie, Inhimshallibe, LobsterCatapult, GlaDOS (L-1)

LobsterCatapult:

Cogito Ergo Sum

Feysal:

Mina

Not Voting:

Feysal, Charlie, Primate, Jahudo

Day 2 deadline

Deadline is (expired on 2011-07-21 21:05:19)

With 11 alive it's 6 to lynch.

[Primate]

Is that a c/p error?

[Twilight Sparkle]

Oh, yes.

[Feysal]

It is time I posted an update on my progress, which has unfortunately been slow. At this rate I cannot possibly finish reading the thread before night falls, and I'll need the night to get my bearings in this game. Sorry if this disappoints anyone.

I tried the quick and dirty method of ISO reading Mina, even though I've yet to read most of the thread, and her style appears townish to me. It is what I remember from her in Court of the Gods, and as a head of Twilight Sparkle in Storm of Swords (forgot about that one, it is the last game we have been in together). I have no experience on what her mafia play is like, but it would not surprise me in the least if this turned out to be a mislynch.

I acknowledge the fact that with less than a day remaining until deadline, and not even a claim from Mina, this lynch is practically inevitable. As such, I will not strain myself any further to catch up today. No matter how convincing a case I managed to find, I deem it to be too late for it today. Tomorrow will be a different matter, but for now all I can do is hope that Mina's silence implies caught mafia who has given up.

There is one observation I would like to share though. The reason I was looking for a game to replace into was because one of my games ended and another was ending, which it just did. Conveniently enough both inHimshallibe and TheLonging were in that game, and events in that game make some things they've said here look most odd. Here we have TheLonging claiming he does not know inHimshallibe, even though they played in the same game only some weeks earlier, though TheLonging was killed on night one (by inHimshallibe) so he may have just forgotten. It is inHimshallibe I wonder about. In our past game TheLonging tried to have vezokpiraka policy lynched, to which inHimshallibe did not object, as he did here when TheLonging tried to have Chesskid similarly ousted. Why would inHimshallibe find TheLonging suspicious for supporting a policy lynch, when he had just seen him do the same as town in another game?

The game in question is A Gentleman's Game of Guile, Subterfuge, and Intrigue, so you can see for yourselves.

By the point to which I've read inHimshallibe is my first suspect, so I will

Vote: inHimshallibe

even though I consider the chances of this leading anywhere today to be negligible.

[Katsuki]

Interesting.

[Charlie]

My Little Inquisitor.

[Katsuki]

btw it would be a good idea for someone to hammer soon.

We have 10-12hrs left or something like that.

[inHimshallibe]

o.O

I'm not even sure how to respond, because I'm very confused about the accusation to begin with, but I do want to clear things up about it.

I was suspicious of TL for wanting a policy lynch? I think I was suspicious of TL for wanting to try and push a policy lynch on chesskid, for whom I think there is no ground to policy lynch.

Also, I was an SK that game. I wasn't paying a bloody fuck of attention to anything besides whatever kept me alive, and I was still alive as the SK when I was posting about TL here. By the time I had died in A Gentleman's Game, any thoughts of TL and policy lynches and lynching him for pushing policy lynches was long gone.

Now that I've responded I'm beginning to think that was a really shitty accusation to begin with.

[Charlie]

No need to panic, it's 17 hours and I'll be around at deadline to drop a hammer of Friendship on Mina if need be. Moar reading from me soon.