Oversoul wrote:Someone kill Andrew please so we can go to night. Town is tearing itself up and I am almost positive after people have died things will be easier.
Who called it?
*sigh*
Coventry wrote:The problem with lynching Andrew is that it gives us very little information and for exactly the reasons you outlined earlier, Oversoul, I am very uncertain he is a bad guy. From my first read I was almost sure Little Grey/Silver and Amrun were scum, with Neil close behind, because I didn't think he was reacting to pressure the same way he had in our last game with him (I know, he eventually did). Given how the day has developed now, though, I can't imagine us going forward in any useful fashion without dealing with the 800 pound gorilla that is zMuffin's strangely bullying and seemingly scummily opportunistic play.
Just lynching someone to clear the room is still preferable to no-lynch but the reason for the "easy lynches", Hoopla's plan, is now mangled beyond recognition and I believe strongly that you lynch from information and to get information. It is just not clear to me how lynching Andrew is from the first or would offer much of the later.
As always, if anyone can explain to me how I'm wrong I'll certainly reconsider.
Oversoul wrote:zMuffinMan wrote:2 of {neil, Amrun, Coventry} because the rest of the vig pool are town, as are hoopla, andrew and myself. I'm not even going to try to guess who's lying in the PR pool. It doesn't concern me. If I'm still alive when it matters, then I'll get to figuring it out.
It isn't me.
neil1113 wrote:VOTE: Muffinman
Do we not realize the deadline is in 4 days? Muffin is the only sure fire lynch I see here, because if anybody deserves to be lynched this game, it's this kid.
[...] Also, I'm pretty sure Hoopla (when Muffin flips scum) is his partner, it makes so much sense it hurts.
neil1113 wrote:Not if Muffin keeps playing the way he's playing, he'll be doing the Mafia more of an advantage staying in then any of his other two teammates.
zMuffinMan wrote:No, I couldn't have foreseen this happening. It couldn't have been planned.
Quilford wrote:NO MORE VOLUNTEERS FOR THE LYNCH POOL, PLEASE. YOU'RE NARROWING DOWN THE VIG POOL FOR SCUM. IF WE'RE LYNCHING TODAY, WE'RE LYNCHING ONE OF THE PEOPLE WHO HAS VOLUNTEERED. OTHERWISE, WE NO LYNCH.
neil1113 wrote:Are you serious Muffin? Glow? Quil? Is my mislynch really more important then the fact that I'mNOT SCUM?
Okay, we'll play by your game. Let's do this. I'm tired of this game anyways, and it'd probably help from me possibly having to be replaced from the missions trip I'm going on Sat. If this is what it'll take to show you all how wrong you are, so be it. I'm the vig.
UNVOTE: Muffin
VOTE: Neil_1113
Good game.
Quilford wrote:Glowball, you somehow imply that zMuffin is responsible for neil outing himself.
chkflip wrote:Quilford wrote:If there are counterclaims I want them.
I knowsomeoneelse HAS to be reading Quilscum here. Check the ISO. This is getting ridiculous.
neil1113 wrote:well at least it eliminates me from being lynch and gives us another confirmed townie
Hoopla wrote:Muffinman is obviously town. I'm kind of surprised he is even being considered. He's claimed a PR, so at best, he has a 1/4 chance of being scum.
neil1113 wrote:To be honest, my vig desires right now are Andrew, Amrun, and Darkflashlight (where has he been by the way??)... I don't like how Dark and Am have basically ridden the shadows...
DarkFlashlight wrote:chkflip wrote:Quilford wrote:If there are counterclaims I want them.
I knowsomeoneelse HAS to be reading Quilscum here. Check the ISO. This is getting ridiculous.
Better yet was how it was disregarded instantly. Quilford didn't fight for it for any reason, he just wanted it to happen before anyone caught it.
Coventry wrote:Why am I the most likely scum in the vig pool? Because it would seem to me that I am the most likely scum in the vig pool because...
...I disagreed with you. Or perhaps my worst crime was being right. This game has become terrily topsy-turvy, so perhaps wanring someone of the possible consequences of their strangely anti-town behavior only to have those consequences come to pass is now considered a scum-tell.
neil wrote:But then if I'm alive on Day 2, wouldn't I be a sure fire lynch suspect?
DF wrote:Imagine if Neil was scum. This would be the best move ever. You guarantee yourself not to be lynched unless real vig CC's, in which case there's an easy dead vig, and convince the town to throw away its own plan.
DF wrote:If you must kill Coventry, vig her. I'm not lynching based on horrible process of elimination.
andrew wrote:unvote vote darkflashlight
i also have a town read on hoopla, my gut says its you, chkflip and someone else
Muffin wrote:DFL is probably town
Muffin wrote:I don't care if DF is scum, he can be dealt with later.
Muffin wrote:No, DF. It's the dumbest move ever if neil is scum because he's just going to get vigged tonight. The vig doesn't need to CC...
Muffin wrote:No. We lynch Coventry, we vig another likely scum. Stop trying to derail the Coventry lynch.
DF wrote:Before I disagree with you:
Muffin wrote:DFL is probably town
After I disagree with you:
Muffin wrote:I don't care if DF is scum, he can be dealt with later.
DF wrote:This is cute. I said he could vig Coventry if he really wants so whatever your last sentence was trying to imply is a lie. I don't see the point in killing her, the case was made up on the spot, but I don't have the final say, and regardless of vigging or lynching her, she's dead, and you win.