Thor665 wrote:
@Yos - time to explain how BM was obv. trying to get Incog lynched, yeah?
Hmm? What do you mean?
First here:
Battle Mage wrote:Incognito wrote:Trip, Haylen is obvscum because she's pretty obviously making up stuff as she goes along. The meta thing was one piece of evidence, but if you read along with my post 14 you'll see me pointing out more of her making stuff up as she goes along too.
The other reason why I think Haylen is obvscum has to do with meta, which I don't expect you to know about -- Haylen tends to get much more emotional and all over the place as town but in this game she seems fairly stable, which is scummy for her. Plus there's the fact that everyone and their mother hasn't attacked her yet, which would have happened already if she was town.
Explain how this logically follows. You seem to be suggesting that Haylen-scum would not be bussed/distanced from on Day 1. Given that you presuppose that she is lynchbait as town, i'd say the opposite should be true. Haylen-scum would get the stink bussed out of her in the early going to take the heat off later, assuming her partners weren't complete novices.
On the topic, i dont know why you feel confident to draw the conclusion she is "stable" and not "all over the place" when she hasnt said a bloody thing yet. And reading over your post again, i realise that your reasoning for suspecting Haylen actually has no substance whatsoever. So please, please, please, please, explain to me, why you feel that somebody you admit yourself is a pretty easy mislynch at the best of times, is deserving of your vote today?
Oh my, i am looking forward to your reply!
Incognito wrote:
@BM, it's tomorrow. Can you provide that reasoning now?
Yeah, two bits of bad news on that front. First is, it's still today. Second is, i dunno if you're gonna be around to ask me again tomorrow.
Unvote, Vote: Incognito
He continued to try to get people to vote incog:
Battle Mage wrote:PeregrineV wrote:@Battle- Today, right now, I would be against a lynching of me, Green Crayons, Incog, or Haylen. And your Incog vote doesn't make a lot sense. Can you provide further insight about your decision making process in that regard?
Against a lynch of Incog? How can you be against a lynch of Incog??
If you struggled with, what i felt was very very simple and coherent, reasoning for my Incog vote, i'll simplify it even more.
I am voting for Incognito because his Haylen-vote was contrived, the reasoning eminently fictitious.
@Bvoigt - Just random people i felt hadn't been adequately covered.
BM
When I defended Incog, and attacked TripMyWire for his attack on Incog, BM attacks me, and contines to attack Incog in the same post:
Battle Mage wrote:I suppose i'll offer a courtesyFoS: Yosarian2for inconsistency of argument. Why are you attacking Tripmywire for something (admittedly i hadnt noticed this) that i am equally guilty of? I'm not buying the point about Camn either. Sure, he isnt coming over as an inspired scumhunter, but Tripmywire certainly seems like a well-intentioned townie to me.
What i'd really like to see right now is some kind of direction. There's what, 2/3 votes on Haylen for reasons unjustified. I see Bvoigt just cast an inane vote for Peregrine.
I'd like to see Yos explain why Incognito's diabolical logic against Haylen is not scummy. Then explain why he has chosen to ignore me and focus his attack on Tripmywire. Finally, id like to see him give comment on Medicated Lain. A Day 1 Yos lynch isn't ideal, but dont think it's impossible.
I think we're lynching one of Incognito, Medicated Lain or Yosarian2 today. Now would be a good time to step up and plead a case either way on those 3 individuals.
BM
He then scaled it up to a full vote on me in his ISO post #21, while still attacking incognito even in the post where he voted me.
He didn't vote for Incog again, but he continued to attack him, in his ISO post #22 and #29.
BM really expended more energy trying to attack Incognito then he did anyone else.