Zdenek makes a good point about redtail in 330.
349 from yabbaguy feels off, the 'I'll let you know if you hit a trap' bit. Has a scum read on SC/redtail.
tarsonisocelot's posts on that page, and 350, read well to me.
I'm happy with UnclePain's 356 - his answers to me and questions to tarsonisocelot. And this question to yabbaguy:
"So your case against redtail896, which reads to me basically as gut feeling, is more convincing to you that the C-Worl wagon? Plus, why are you suddenly not so sure any more about tarsonisocelot-scum?"
361 from Me=Weird seems scummy-ish, like trying to get a quick-hammer (especially since any townie who did so would likely be lynched tomorrow regardless of C-Worl's flip). C-Worl calling her scum for voting him suggests she's bussing him, if he flips scum.
Jase's point about a possible Uncle Pain - redtail connection is interesting, though I still have a good townread on Uncle Pain.
373 from yabbaguy misrepresents crazypianist, I think? I thought lining up lynches is when you say, "If X flips {scum/town} then we lynch Y tomorrow." crazypianist is just saying "lynch TO tomorrow". It seems independent of today's lynch. This is just a terminology point though.
374 tarsonisocelot's reasons for worrying about a self-hammer sound genuine.
378 from Zdenek (answering Uncle Pain's question) sounds genuine
C-Worl's posts on this page are townier than the previous couple of pages.
tarsonisocelot's reads in 386 are mostly well-reasoned but I disagree with this on yabbaguy: "There are a few inconsistencies, such as where he's not sure if [L] is an ok wagon or a terrible one but I think scum would have been more careful to avoid this." Scum make mistakes, it's how we catch them. It doesn't seem too glaring a mistake to use that 'too scummy to be scum' dismissal of it.
wow, interesting to see bvoigt follow up yabbaguy's suspicion of Uncle Pain. And boldly calling C-Worl town.
I think Uncle Pain is right to question bvoigt's read of him, it seems like bvoigt just trying to stick with his slot's previous reads, which I see as scummy. On the other hand, the "I'm not affiliated with redtail" remark is pretty odd - tarsonisocelot is right to call him on this.
406 from crazypianist I like.
413 from redtail feels inadequate as an explanation.
415 where bvoigt says he'll keep his vote on redtail cos yabbaguy voted him - I don't like that.
To answer the question to me ("One random thing I noticed. Why did you say that hammering in that situation made them likely to be buddies?"), that misrepresents what I said, which was only that it was
possible
[L] was scum, despite the quickhammer on him. I thought if [L] flipped scum, I could see the hammer as an attempt to get townpoints for bussing while also cutting the day short. i.e. the hammer looked scummy to me whichever way [L] flipped.
@Uncle Pain, I think the other point that's been made against redtail896 is Surprise Carcinogen's fluff-posting.