In the Court of the Gods (Game Over)

[Jack]

fos:farside

[DrippingGoofball]

I think farside is town.

As for MeWeird, I currently have no evidence either way. But I'm pretty sure I will soon be able to tell whether if he's town some way or another.

[farside22]

fos:farside

Don't worry hun your already on my scum list. Nothing flashing coming from you, no try and drawing things out and no craziness....your actions far are not what I expect from a town Jack.

[zoraster]

Day 1 Vote Count

Andrius ( 0 )
Brokenscraps ( 2 ) hitogoroshi, Equinox,
hitogoroshi ( 0 )
me=weird ( 6 ) Andrius, SpyreX,

Fishythefish,

Lady Lambdadelta, Zang, farside22,
SpyreX ( 0 )
Equinox ( 0 )
farside22 ( 1 ) Mina,
Feysal ( 0 )
Mina ( 0 )
themanhimself ( 0 )
Benmage ( 0 )
DeathRowKitty ( 0 )
Jack ( 0 )
Lady Lambdadelta ( 0 )
Zang ( 0 )
Not Voting ( 9 ) Brokenscraps, me=weird, Feysal, themanhimself, Benmage, DeathRowKitty, Jack,

DrippingGoofball,

Nobody Special,

Total Votes ( 18 )

Deadline: February 14th at 23:00 EDT
With 18 able to vote, 10 needed to lynch.

1) Does the evil god know who the scum are?

2) Do the scum know who the evil god is?

3) Would the evil god be able to communicate with the scum as well as in the QT?

There is a scum QT with daychat abilities.

Just a reminder because it makes my life a lot easier: Please post votes on a new line

. Using the VOTE: function makes my life even easier, but it's not required.

[farside22]

I think farside is town.

As for MeWeird, I currently have no evidence either way. But I'm pretty sure I will soon be able to tell whether if he's town some way or another.

Although it was pregame chat I didn't like Me=Weird's vote on LL when 2 other people where doing the same thing and he doesn't acknowledge it. I see it as someone looking for an excuse to vote for that person when it looks to be a BW forming.

[DrippingGoofball]

Although it was pregame chat I didn't like Me=Weird's vote on LL when 2 other people where doing the same thing and he doesn't acknowledge it. I see it as someone looking for an excuse to vote for that person when it looks to be a BW forming.

True, but nearly everyone knows that the first wagon right out of the RVS is almost never the lynch of the day. It's possible that MeWeird doesn't realize that, but normally this sort of action would mean more later in the game, when a wagon could actually lead to a lynch, than it did when MeWeird did it... early in the game, and early on the wagon itself.

[Equinox]

I want me a new red-colored wagon to put my toys in.

Unvote, Vote: Jack

[Fishythefish]

I don't understand why you are making a big deal out of it. I can't even prevent a NK on a townie because the "protect" is a public one, so the scum can mow down some other townie. How could it hurt the town if I use it unilaterally? Even the worse possible scenario that I PUBLICLY protect a scumbag... from a NK... every 4 nights.

Why don't you look for scum instead, this is IIoA.

That's fair, actually. Not that important.

[Nobody Special]

I acknowledge that even though I'm Immortal, that may have been a tad aggressive.

And potentially a mistake.

What do you mean by the bolded statement?

Well, you've seen the backlash of my actions as well as I have. Perhaps, in my power-drunkenness, I came on a

tiny

bit too strong.

I confirm that I sent one (or more) PMs asking after abilities. I acknowledge that even though I'm Immortal, that may have been a tad aggressive. And potentially a mistake.

Why is it a mistake? Because it makes you look scummy? Because you risk harming the town? But furthermore, you're skirting over something important.

Even if you feel like being coy about your alignment, is Jack joking, yes or no? Did he send you a PM claiming to be scum? Did you claim to be the scum god in reply? Why don't you paraphrase the exchange between yourself instead of brushing it off as a joke?

Do you think that Jack is more or less likely to be town for his stunt?

Jack, bless his heart, is flat-out

lying.

I did send him the PM in question; he replied with two (very short) words. That is the extent of our communication thus far. I certainly did not claim scumGod.

I think Jack's actions are quite far from something Town would do.

NO. My towndar is near-infallible

as everyone knows

,

I shall revisit this at a later point. I have a bit of research to do.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

I acknowledge that even though I'm Immortal, that may have been a tad aggressive.

And potentially a mistake.

What do you mean by the bolded statement?

Well, you've seen the backlash of my actions as well as I have. Perhaps, in my power-drunkenness, I came on a

tiny

bit too strong.

I confirm that I sent one (or more) PMs asking after abilities. I acknowledge that even though I'm Immortal, that may have been a tad aggressive. And potentially a mistake.

Why is it a mistake? Because it makes you look scummy? Because you risk harming the town? But furthermore, you're skirting over something important.

Even if you feel like being coy about your alignment, is Jack joking, yes or no? Did he send you a PM claiming to be scum? Did you claim to be the scum god in reply? Why don't you paraphrase the exchange between yourself instead of brushing it off as a joke?

Do you think that Jack is more or less likely to be town for his stunt?

Jack, bless his heart, is flat-out

lying.

I did send him the PM in question; he replied with two (very short) words. That is the extent of our communication thus far. I certainly did not claim scumGod.

I think Jack's actions are quite far from something Town would do.

NO. My towndar is near-infallible

as everyone knows

,

I shall revisit this at a later point. I have a bit of research to do.

Well, since
A) I'm inclined to believe NS here and
B) NS is unlynchable

I'd like to see some pressure on Jack for an explanation of why he would lie about NS claiming scum etc.
If Jack continues to deny lying, and sticks to his story about NS claiming scum, I want him lynched. Worst case scenario, he turns up town, and we know which of the 3 gods is scum.

UNVOTE: VOTE: Jack

[hitogoroshi]

I'd like to see some pressure on Jack for an explanation of why he would lie about NS claiming scum etc.
If Jack continues to deny lying, and sticks to his story about NS claiming scum, I want him lynched. Worst case scenario, he turns up town, and we know which of the 3 gods is scum.

Sorry Spy and Andrius, but I think LLD is my favorite person here.

Unvote, Vote: Jack

[Equinox]

I'm not thrilled about the reasons behind the new Jack votes, but it's a Jack wagon, so I'm not going to complain (too much).

[hitogoroshi]

We either catch a lying scum or learn which god is the scum god. HOW IS THIS NOT THRILLING

[Andrius]

We either catch a lying scum or learn which god is the scum god. HOW IS THIS NOT THRILLING

I am very down for this plan. 8D

hito... </3

Vote: Jack

GREAT JUSTICE AND GREAT REWARDS

[SpyreX]

This is all well and good and I'm fine with it.

However, bet me now, Jack is gonna be town. Sooo is figuring out NS is the scum lord (when he is) actually worth it?

[Andrius]

KNOWING NS is the scumlord is worth the tradeoff.
Spy, its like sacrificing 4 VTs to get rid of a Bulletproof RoleCop.
(Not that extreme though.)

[DrippingGoofball]

...Sooo is figuring out NS is the scum lord (when he is) actually worth it?

I have theories that are best kept to myself.

[DrippingGoofball]

HEY WAIT

Shouldn't the scumgod know his mortal scumpals' identity? Does that change anything?

How could Jack trick NS to 'fess scum??? Unless NS was very careless and not paying attention?

[Andrius]

Ok guys, why would knowing who the scumgod is NOT be worth it?!?

[Jack]

HEY WAIT

Shouldn't the scumgod know his mortal scumpals' identity? Does that change anything?

How could Jack trick NS to 'fess scum??? Unless NS was very careless and not paying attention?

THANK YOU

ONE PERSON IS NOT BRAIN DEAD

Which probably means you're the scum god

Anyway I honestly can't figure out whether those people pushing the "lynch jack to learn about NS!" theory are scum (they should know better) or town (they should still know better) at this moment.

vote:LL

Is still scum however.

[Jack]

Ok guys, why would knowing who the scumgod is NOT be worth it?!?

You know I'm town thus you are scum.

[Andrius]

I don't, actually.
Give me a night and I'll get back to you.

[Jack]

Oh, andrius's ISO is filled with obvscumness.

unvote, vote:andrius

[Equinox]

How could Jack trick NS to 'fess scum??? Unless NS was very careless and not paying attention?[/color][/b]

Ergo, Jack-NS interaction is a null tell.

Ok guys, why would knowing who the scumgod is NOT be worth it?!?

It is worth it, but I wouldn't put in excessive amounts of effort into finding the scum god. Lynching mortals is faster and easier.

vote:LL

Is still scum however.

I don't understand.

[Jack]

You talk to the scum god and her scum minion like they are town, I'm not surprised you don't understand