I think you just did.AGar wrote:Am I supposed to respond to 246?
But if you want a direct question to answer, why BQ first instead of sims?
I didn't refuse to acknowledge it because for me to refuse to do so I would have to accept it as scummy, and I don't. What did you want, a post of me quoting you going 'this is possibly a scumtell, but I don't agree with it, Carrot should/should not continue' If i did that for everything that was raised in thred (even if only tangentially involving me) I would be responding to a lot of stuff. AGar and I are friends and we are likely to joke and be friendly while playing a game of Mafia together. I've called AGar on things he's done I've considered scummy, and I haven't called him on things he's done that you consider scummy. That seems pretty darn normal.Carrotcake wrote:Thor:
I called him on it. But you refused to acknowledge it - important, as he is creating a relationship between you two. And you are trying as hard as you can to keep it down low. Even you know, i'm sure, that your case against poweree is garbage.
Making garbage cases is fine, day one, as it creates discussion. But your follow-through perverts any discussion really, and just tries for a mislynch.
Actually all I was trying to do was show the inherent weakness of the logic you used.ConfidAnon wrote:To me, your original response was not true to my original point. By restating, I thought I was clarifying. You ignored the main point and instead, kind of tried to turn it back around on me, using a different line of logic than I originally did.
I pressed you for a response mainly to see your reaction. Admittedly, I'm not the best at this stuff, but I was thinking that if my line of thinking had merit, you would react in a manner that would incriminate yourself. You were fairly calm (though snarky, which I appreciate ), which looks good for you.Thor wrote:Actually all I was trying to do was show the inherent weakness of the logic you used.
Besides, your tell is that I'm the SK because I leaped to a presumption. I showed you where I drew the presumption and other than doing that there's no way to respond to a case as ephemeral as yours as you'll either see the obvious information in Gud's posts that I used or you won't. What do you want me to respond to besides that?
Refusal to claim is more likely to launch a stray missle, and incredibly scummy when your at L-1.Gud wrote:For one, Im not going to say anything about my role unless someone unvotes, because I don't want a stray missile to come in here and blow me up if they 'don't believe it.'
Thank you. I know we simulposted. When that occurred that was the second asking.Guderian wrote:I looks good, nice defense. Well laid out. There didn't seem to be any specific questions launched at me, So I think thats why I didn't respond.
I still think you're slightly scummy. Are you concerned because my vote is still on you?
Yes. You will argue that. And the fact that you even have to shows that it really wasn't. Pro-town is what it is. There aren't any real discrepancies about it.Guderian wrote:I would argue my play this game has been the most pro town out of anybodies.
Misrep based on confirmation bias. VIs aren't always scum but certain players are always going to look scummy when you push their buttons.He accepts that VI's aren't necessarily scum, and that going after them is scummy.
LOL STRAWMAN TRY AGAIN. Guder isn't a VI. If he's town, his play was stupid, yes, but not indicative of a VI.He basically votes for Guder for being a VI.
If I have insider knowledge,Baseless complacency. Indicative of inside knowledge. Definitely a scum-tell.
self voting. didnt know that was good for town.here's what happens: You get lynched
Please self-vote
Oh this is absolute nonsense. I didn't think you were scum only because you claimed SK. Go back and read my posts; that was just one folly in a long list of scummy moves you've made this whole game.Guderian wrote:by the way, from my view, All of sims/singer/power had the same reaction to my claim, which I didn't expect. All are newer, so I expected the scum among them to act differently. But, Basically along the lines of, he claims SK, hes mafia, lynch him!
I'm starting to think maybe Gud is scum and claiming SK in hopes that we'd offer allegiance (as CarrotCake has done), thus ensuring the survival of at least one scum to endgame. Other people have pointed out some scummy behavior from CC; it would make sense that she, as scum, would try to jumpstart a ridiculous campaign to offer him sanctuary and use him as anti-scum rather than anti-town. Thoughts?
Unvote
Vote: Guderian
This.sims5487 wrote:Oh this is absolute nonsense. I didn't think you were scum only because you claimed SK. Go back and read my posts; that was just one folly in a long list of scummy moves you've made this whole game.Guderian wrote:by the way, from my view, All of sims/singer/power had the same reaction to my claim, which I didn't expect. All are newer, so I expected the scum among them to act differently. But, Basically along the lines of, he claims SK, hes mafia, lynch him!