The Lord of the Rings Mafia - GAME OVER (KABOOM)

[Edge]

Ah VV is cleared apparently by Mari.


Excellent excellent.

Vote: Rewq

Madness ASIDE we need to trim the fat.

OH DAYKILLER ARE YOU GOING TO BE FUCKING USELESS AGAIN TODAY?

[Nero Cain]

HEY YOU.

KATY SAID YOU WERENT A RING BEARER.

LOL CLAIM.

I DONT REMEMVER WHY I WROTE YOU OFF AS TOWN (DAMN YOU SPYREX) BUT YOU SURE HAVENT DONE FUCKIN SHIT FOR SCUMHUNTING LATELY.

And you screaming that a diffrent person is scum every 5 mins is? But I've already claimed.

because SCUM HAVE BEEN KILLING EACHOTHER

as far as I know there's only bee one scum kills scum.

[Edge]

I WAS TALKING TO REWQ FFS. BUT YES, ME TRYING DIFFERENT ANGLES AND APPLYING CHINESE ACUPUNTURE TO DIFFERENT PEOPL EIS ACTUALLY FUCKING SCUMHUNTING.

as far as I know there's only bee one scum kills scum.

HOW DOES THAT MAKE IT ANY LESS VALID.

[VasudeVa]

Rewq targetted no one, btw. Sooo, are we cleaning house today or are we cleaning house today?

Vote: Dekes

[VasudeVa]

SuperTown:

LegoVas
Mariyta
Katy
jenniwren

MaayybeTown:

InHim

NotMordor:

Edge

Today's lynches:

rewq
Dekes
Nero Cain
Locke

[Katy]

Vote: Dekes

I think this is a good place to look today. I don't buy the claim.

[Edge]

Katy don't sheep VV over me today... just don't.

That said until Dekes shows up yeah that's fine.

Also VV's list is sadly fine with the EXCEPTION of Nero. Nero is NOT MORDOR with me if you look at his posts early D4 he thought that SpyreX was the red team's kill for reasons that don't even make sense logically and it just didn't read as "herp derp play dumb!" more as "EDGE IS SCUM WHO KILLED SPYREX BAWAHWAHWH" in that stupid kind of sock on head townignorealllogic kind of way.

And LL is worth keeping around, so rewq/Dekes, fight to the death, etc.

[Katy]

I'm not sheeping anyone. I have my own reasons for voting Dekes right now.

Nero is NOT MORDOR with

me.

Oh really? Well then who is Mordor with you? Just tell us and make this game easy.

[Locke Lamora]

Right, so both VV and Mari's abilities are confirmed unless they're scum together.

Mari: did you look at how the situation unfolded? Was anyone seriously pointing the finger at Sly at that stage? He wasn't even on the radar. With his roleblocker dead, Zwet clearly going to get lynched/vigged sooner or later and a2 with zero town points, don't you think that to come out and counter-claim like that just because he had a scumread on you is a bit insane? Not only would it have made him the prime lynch target if you are town, it also made him a target for the other scumteam, which is exactly what happened. So yeah, it could have been that he had a scumread on you, but I think it's pretty damn unlikely that he'd have done it with no information whatsoever because it's simply not a logical trade-off. Unless I'm missing some of Sly's likely thought process somewhere, in which case, provide me with some suggestions to think over.

To anyone trying to draw links between Mordor and Isengard: we have two dead Mordor scum. How about you draw links between them and the living players, instead of saying 'well maybe we have all the scum working together like one giant scumteam with a co-op wincon' and proceeding to identify highly speculative cross-scumteam links.

[Locke Lamora]

Hold up a sec. Mari, why Rewq?

[Mariyta]

Locke, I don't know what else you want me to say. I DON'T KNOW WHY SLY WOULD CC ME. It makes little sense. I'm not dealing with this again, BECAUSE I DON'T KNOW!!!!! And what do you mean "Why rewq?" Why target him last night? So I could confirm VV. Why vote him today? I already explained that, so go read.

VV's claim that rewq didn't target anyone and the fact that no one died should definitely be taken into consideration today. More likely, they targeted Edge or Katy (who damn well better have been protected), but we can't rule out the tracking result either.

[Locke Lamora]

Well, 'I'm so tired of Locke repeatedly pointing out this fact, I confess I'm scum' would be nice. I guess I feel a little better about you given that your role has actually (probably) produced a result, but I just keep returning to that Sly situation in my head, which is why I keep bringing it up. On Rewq, I realise now that you stated you were going to watch him towards the end of yesterdays' madness. Wasn't VV's tracking ability already confirmed by Jenni, though?

[Mariyta]

Wasn't VV's tracking ability already confirmed by Jenni, though?

Yes, but many people wanted another confirmation. Now he's twice confirmed.

[Edge]

Not buying the VV-conftown BS. Nobody is confirmed.

That said, wagon ho on a Dekes or rewq lynch.

~Reaper

[Mariyta]

I'd love to hear from Dekes, who quickly disappeared as soon as the wagon on him dismantled. VOTE: Dekes L-3.

[Nero Cain]

look at his posts early D4 he thought that SpyreX was the red team's kill for reasons that don't even make sense logically and it just didn't read as "herp derp play dumb!" more as "EDGE IS SCUM WHO KILLED SPYREX BAWAHWAHWH" in that stupid kind of sock on head townignorealllogic kind of way.

Oh I'm sorry that I ended up typing Spyrex instead of SlySly.

[Nero Cain]

@VV at the end of yesterday you were pretty much against Edge, what made you change your mind?

[VasudeVa]

I was trying to fool scum into ordering their NK with rewq via insult sword fighting with Edge.

Although meh. No deaths last night is putting me off. . I'm not sure what to think of it.

[Mariyta]

Although meh. No deaths last night is putting me off. . I'm not sure what to think of it.

Agreed. I've come up with

four

five possible reasons, listed in the order of likeliness (IMO).

1. They targeted Katy and she was protected.
2. They targeted Edge and he was protected.
3. rewq assumed he would be tracked and decided not to kill.
4. Someone decided not to kill to frame rewq.

4.

5. Scum was RBed.

4 may actually be more likely than 3, considering the game rewq has played.

[Locke Lamora]

No-kill makes no sense, in basic mafia logic and in the context of trying to get all the rings. That just gives town more chance to lynch scum and get rings back, and Gollum more chance to kill them.

[Mariyta]

It doesn't make no sense. It just makes less sense than the first two options.

[Nero Cain]

I was trying to fool scum into ordering their NK with rewq via insult sword fighting with Edge.

Fair 'nuff.

Although meh. No deaths last night is putting me off. . I'm not sure what to think of it.

Agreed. I've come up with

four

five possible reasons, listed in the order of likeliness (IMO).

1. They targeted Katy and she was protected.
2. They targeted Edge and he was protected.
3. rewq assumed he would be tracked and decided not to kill.
4. Someone decided not to kill to frame rewq.

4.

5. Scum was RBed.

4 may actually be more likely than 3, considering the game rewq has played.

As much as it pains me to say it....2 is the most likely scenario but that hinges on Edgetown and apparently everyone but me considers him confirmed town.

[Katy]

I don't think 2 is actually the most likely scenario. I don't think scum would have targeted Edge last night because:

(1) If InHim is Mordor, killing Edge would reveal his lie
(2) If InHim is not Mordor, scum would know their kill would most likely fail except for the off-chance that InHim was the DK. I don't know that Mordor would risk a failed kill just to test if InHim is the DK or not.

I think a doc is a more likely scenario, than the above.

[jenniwren]

Although meh. No deaths last night is putting me off. . I'm not sure what to think of it.

Agreed. I've come up with

four

five possible reasons, listed in the order of likeliness (IMO).

1. They targeted Katy and she was protected.
2. They targeted Edge and he was protected.
3. rewq assumed he would be tracked and decided not to kill.
4. Someone decided not to kill to frame rewq.

4.

5. Scum was RBed.

4 may actually be more likely than 3, considering the game rewq has played.

Considering there are probably two Mordor scum left, #3 is highly unlikely; with everyone calling for Rewq to be tracked yesterday, if he were one of the scum, he would be pretty bad to turn in the kill himself.

The fourth option would hinge on it being confirmed that there was only one Mordor scum left.

I think options 1, 2, and 5 are most likely.

I would be happy with a Dekes or Rewq lynch today, but I'm leaning more for Dekes at the moment.


Prev. Edit: Katy's point about #2 is good. So, options 1 and 5.

[Mariyta]

Considering there are probably two Mordor scum left, #3 is highly unlikely; with everyone calling for Rewq to be tracked yesterday, if he were one of the scum, he would be pretty bad to turn in the kill himself.

The fourth option would hinge on it being confirmed that there was only one Mordor scum left.

I think options 1, 2, and 5 are most likely.

I would be happy with a Dekes or Rewq lynch today, but I'm leaning more for Dekes at the moment.


Prev. Edit: Katy's point about #2 is good. So, options 1 and 5.

Good point. I tend to assume there is only one (due to the bulletproof rolecop), but it is still very possible that two remain. I think #5 is less likely because we've already had two roleblockers flip. They were both scum, but I've never seen three RBs in one game.