(2) ThAdmiral (DemonHybrid, drmyshottyizsik)
(1) DemonHybrid (ThAdmiral)
(4) Not Voting (Far_Cry, redtail896, Thor665, saporovirus)
With
Deadline is
First bit is correct.Thor665 wrote:@DH - he's not saying the argument (case) is retarded he's saying the argument (debate of it) is retarded. Both are viable beliefs that can coexist.
That said, there is an angle here I now find disturbing.
@Admiral - the way you phrased your desire to end the argument now looks weird to me. By the sheer fact of you backing off in the way you did tends to suggest that you believe that DH legitimately believes his Far_Cry standpoint. If he really believes it then how is it scummy?
Why do you think scum would be "stubborn" about having a town read?ThAdmiral wrote:As to the second bit: it's more that I believe he's very stubborn
"Stubborn" as in set in his ways. He would be stubborn as either town or scum as he would either be stubbornly sticking to his read or stubbornly sticking to what he said was his read about jimfinn.Thor665 wrote:Why do you think scum would be "stubborn" about having a town read?ThAdmiral wrote:As to the second bit: it's more that I believe he's very stubborn
Why wouldn't you be saying scum is "lying" about having a town read?
You're trying way too hard at this point.ThAdmiral wrote:"Stubborn" as in set in his ways. He would be stubborn as either town or scum as he would either be stubbornly sticking to his read or stubbornly sticking to what he said was his read about jimfinn.Thor665 wrote:Why do you think scum would be "stubborn" about having a town read?ThAdmiral wrote:As to the second bit: it's more that I believe he's very stubborn
Why wouldn't you be saying scum is "lying" about having a town read?
DemonHybrid wrote:You completely missed Thor's point.
Why is it "stubborn" both ways, when I would be inevitably "lying" to everyone as scum? Sure, I'm stubborn in my demeanor, but you can't be "stubborn" if you've had a plan all along, surely.
Well I guess we have a different understanding of language as I think someone can be "stubborn" about keeping to their position, even if that position is a lie (in fact, especially if that position is a lie). In any case my sentence wouldn't have made sense If I changed the word stubborn for lying. It would have read: "I believe he's very lying".Thor665 wrote:Uf da!
Vote: ThAdmiral
DH is basically hitting it on the head as to what angle I'm coming from. Your language seems to indicate a belief that DH is town minded - which would suggest you shouldn't be advocating him to lynch, which means you're doing so under a false premise. Scum wouldn't be being 'stubborn' about a town read on a townie. Also, I can't see any scum advantage for DH to be playing the game like he is, and suspect you'd be a good enough player to see that as well.
You sound pretty sure.DemonHybrid wrote:How sure am I?
I don't know. Pretty sure, 75-80%ish. Why do you ask?
What a silly question.ThAdmiral wrote:You sound pretty sure.DemonHybrid wrote:How sure am I?
I don't know. Pretty sure, 75-80%ish. Why do you ask?
Are you sure enough to vote for yourself tomorrow if you are wrong? Knowing that if I'm scum, which in your eyes is very likely, you don't have to worry about a thing?
Uh...yeah, I'm with saporo. What kind of question is that?saporovirus wrote:What a silly question.ThAdmiral wrote:You sound pretty sure.DemonHybrid wrote:How sure am I?
I don't know. Pretty sure, 75-80%ish. Why do you ask?
Are you sure enough to vote for yourself tomorrow if you are wrong? Knowing that if I'm scum, which in your eyes is very likely, you don't have to worry about a thing?
Pot, meet kettle.Far_Cry wrote:EBWOP: Where the Smurf is redtail? He is the only one not participating in the discussion. Lurking much?
That's a ridiculous request. Claim now.ThAdmiral wrote:@dh: if you believe I'm dodging my claim because I am scum put your money where your mouth is and agree to my wager. If I am scum you don't have to worry about voting yourself tomorrow. So what do you say? Are you man enough?
@ everyone else: I swear to god I will claim after dh answers this.
Haha, I was about to say, I didn't know we were playing russian roulette.saporovirus wrote:ThAdmiral: this is not a goddamn Wild West saloon. You'd have absolutely no way of enforcing that bet even if DH agreed to it. Now play like a normal person.