Scummers Mafia: Greatest Bash? (Game Over, Scum wins?)

[Cuttlefish]

Can we please get some activity? I thought my case on Pom would at least get SOME reaction, but it feels like you're all (save Spy, who is town anyway) trying to ignore it for some reason. Are we just going to blindly speedlynch another person without even looking at the alternatives?

[Pomegranate]

Look, I have finals, this is a bad week.

[nhammen]

maybe he was telling the truth and he investigated me randomly in night 0.

Actually, I think that the order he gave at first (Starbuck, manho, pop) is probably correct. Then he had to change his order when he realized he had claimed to have investigated a player for scummy behavior N0.

question to all who think i'm scum with MM: why would MM lie when he claimed his results?

To make a scumbuddy appear Town. But the question is whether a player like MM would think to do this... No offense to MonkeyMan, but I'm not sure he is capable of this.

unvote

But I have a question for you: Why do you attack me for this, but not even mention kunk?

Why should I have mentioned kunk?

Because kunk voted manho yesterday too. He turned my single vote into two, and stated that he liked a manho wagon. Your case against me is that I was trying to start a counter-wagon. kunk was doing the same thing. Why are you suspicious of me but not kunk, when we have been exhibiting the same behavior? Behavior that you state is scummy enough for a vote.

I thought my case on Pom would at least get SOME reaction, but it feels like you're all (save Spy, who is town anyway) trying to ignore it for some reason. Are we just going to blindly speedlynch another person without even looking at the alternatives?

My problem with the pom case is that she is playing exactly the same way in another ongoing game. I can believe her "too busy" claims...

[dramonic]

Votecount 14: Babble!

Manho (3): Mask, Pom, Kunk,
Nhammen (1): Zito
Pom (2): Cuttlefish, SpyreX

Not Voting (6): Niv, Zang, Ani, Manho, Nhammen, Starbuck

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch

Zang has been prodded, Niv's replacement has yet to PM me back :S

Deadline is the 17th

[manho]

i've skimmed through pom's posts as i don't have much time. and this post is strange:

Moneky, I want a paraphrase of your whole PM.

Now.

...

He basically gave it. But it was very short and nondescript.

it gives a scum-buddy vibe.

vote: pom

[manho]

and she is not a hard MM-lynch pusher, while slightly pressuring him with the "why is kast a namecop" comment but not real scum tell, which is more likely bussing.

[kunkstar7]

Please take a look at Pomegranate in detail ye old faithful town.

468 makes me reaaalllly itchy.

Why is it itchy? I'm not sure if you are mentioning the wrong post or if you actually trying to point out how manho is saying something suspicious? Which in turn doesn't jive with your "lets go after Pom now" first sentence.

I don't like manho's reiteration of Cuttlefish's recap on Pom. Feels to much like scum trying to grasp onto something to shift attention away from him. If it wasn't exactly what Cuttle had said about Pom and maybe something original, but no. Regarding Pom, she just seems way too apathetic. Its more of a nulltell as I can't really see scum being that open about it.

[dramonic]

xRECKONERx replaces Niv, effective immediately!

Yeah Reck =D

[Pomegranate]

Please take a look at Pomegranate in detail ye old faithful town.

468 makes me reaaalllly itchy.

Why is it itchy? I'm not sure if you are mentioning the wrong post or if you actually trying to point out how manho is saying something suspicious? Which in turn doesn't jive with your "lets go after Pom now" first sentence.

I don't like manho's reiteration of Cuttlefish's recap on Pom. Feels to much like scum trying to grasp onto something to shift attention away from him. If it wasn't exactly what Cuttle had said about Pom and maybe something original, but no. Regarding Pom, she just seems way too apathetic. Its more of a nulltell as I can't really see scum being that open about it.

I agree- I like manho less because of his recent posts- grasping for straws or what? I sounded like MM's scumbuddy because I told tajo that he'd already claimed? And I still can't tell why he thinks I was bussing.

Yes kunk, I am a bit apathetic. I missed a lot of Days 1 and 2, which took a lot of my interest in the game away, But I'm going to make an effort not to replace out. I need to ask Dram something.

[Cuttlefish]

I recommend everyone take a look at this. Pomegranate has been much more active in her other games, and she's been coasting in this one. Take a look at May 10-15 and 16-18 in particular, as those were the times she almost flaked from this game.
Apparently, not only does she have time to post in her other games, but she inned for one on the 10th, and offered to replace into another just two days ago.

[SpyreX]

No, I meant what I said. 468 is really itchy. Real, real bad.

Separately, I want actual for reals input on Pom.

[xRECKONERx]

STARBUUUUCK <3 <3 <3 <3

And hello to nhammen, SpyreX... actually I don't feel like listing off everyone else.

Hey is the first post a list of all the replacements? And alts? And uh... well, I'd like to say I can catch up on 20 pages in no time flat buutttt there's a good chance I might not, so how's about someone gives me a brief of what happened and I'll iso people and get a feel for the game, k?

[Cuttlefish]

We lynched the cop d1.
We lynched the (*cough*uncounterclaimed*cough*) mason vig d2.
We lynched obvscum d3.

[Pomegranate]

I recommend everyone take a look at this. Pomegranate has been much more active in her other games, and she's been coasting in this one. Take a look at May 10-15 and 16-18 in particular, as those were the times she almost flaked from this game.
Apparently, not only does she have time to post in her other games, but she inned for one on the 10th, and offered to replace into another just two days ago.

The evening of May 18th until the night of May 20th was a Jewish holiday called Shavuot, which is not so well known.

Yes I /inned for one game on the 10th.

The /in to replace... long story.

You're right, I'm not posting as much as I can in this game. I fell behind, never really had a chance to catch up, and therefore don't care about this game as much as I should.

[Cuttlefish]

The evening of May 18th until the night of May 20th was a Jewish holiday called Shavuot, which is not so well known.

Well I know that you didn't post anywhere onsite for that time. That's why I said 16-18 and not 16-20. I'm obviously not going to use your V/LA against you. However, that holiday doesn't change the fact that you were posting extensively elsewhere on the 18th in particular.

I fell behind, never really had a chance to catch up, and therefore don't care about this game as much as I should.

Are you caught up now? Because if you're caught up now, that excuse doesn't really work.

Could you tell me why you think my case for manho being town is wrong?

[Pomegranate]

Am I caught up?

Well, depends how you define it. I haven't read most of D1 or D2 (and a good part of D3), but at this point I'm not behind.

[animorpherv1]

vote:Pom

Nikanor = right.

[xRECKONERx]

There needs to be a sexier response to my replacing in. I'll hopefully do some sort of reread tonight. Writing a script for my friend right now.

[Zang]

Sorry, I haven't posted, I've been busy. I will try to post something tommorow.

[SpyreX]

Sup RECK give the quick skinny on Pom in iso.

[xRECKONERx]

oh kay brb

[manho]

I don't like manho's reiteration of Cuttlefish's recap on Pom. Feels to much like scum trying to grasp onto something to shift attention away from him. If it wasn't exactly what Cuttle had said about Pom and maybe something original, but no. Regarding Pom, she just seems way too apathetic. Its more of a nulltell as I can't really see scum being that open about it.

i haven't noticed cuttlefish's recap.

[Starbuck]

STARBUUUUCK <3 <3 <3 <3

RECKKKKKKKKK <3 <3 <3 <3

You are my favorite kind of breaded chikin.

Am I caught up?

Well, depends how you define it. I haven't read most of D1 or D2 (and a good part of D3), but at this point I'm not behind.

Are you going to give a response to the case that Cuttlefish built on you in Post 466?

[Papa Zito]

Oh lawd it's Reck.

Because kunk voted manho yesterday too. He turned my single vote into two, and stated that he liked a manho wagon. Your case against me is that I was trying to start a counter-wagon. kunk was doing the same thing. Why are you suspicious of me but not kunk, when we have been exhibiting the same behavior? Behavior that you state is scummy enough for a vote.

I don't believe you and kunk didn't behave the same way yesterday at all.

Please draw up the list of parallels for me.


Re: Pom, I always want Pom dead so I'm not really an impartial observer here. I'm not opposed to seeing her swing at all.

[xRECKONERx]

Zito, you love me.

Hey I haven't caught up yet. Im'ma iso Pom real quick.