Hey, I've got a question.
Mask, did you send in a roleblock on Zito? I think that ani tracked Zito because he didn't see Zito's warning, but I want to confirm something.
Has anyone else claimed to have their minds shattered?
-----
iso0
: "Oh. Hi then, PZ. Also, do you have some sort of doublevote, or is the votecount just messed up?"
This is nothingness.
iso1
: "We don't lynch Spy today."
There is no reason attached. Pom simply says it. She gives a reason in...
iso2
: "I think that we shouldn't lynch SpyreX today, and work off of the quality of his play for the future. I don't see the need to lynch him today. I think that he's playing a miller correctly, and that it fits with the Death Note claim."
This looks kind of like an EBWOP, but it's not. She doesn't add anything new with this post, and I said myself the part about Spy's role flavour making sense between the times of isos 1 and 2. This post is fluff.
iso3
: A throwaway question to kunk, and a promise to post answers to questions tonight.
iso4
: A response to kunk's response. Basically the two of them speculating about Zito's extra vote.
iso5
: Another response to kunk. I don't get the point of this conversation.
iso6
: Responding to Starbuck's question regarding Pom's iso4.
iso7
: Promise to catch up. This is five days after iso6. Pom never does respond to those questions she promised to answer in iso3.
iso8
: "Definitely Vote: ortolan at this point. PZ sums it up nicely."
That's a nice catchup post.
iso9
: Another promise to catch up, this time four days after her last post.
iso10
: This is scummy, now that we know Monkey is scum. Pom supports a mass name claim, but also says that Monkey's flavour doesn't fit and puts the L-2 vote on Monkey.
It's scummy because it's dissonant (am I using the term right?) Pom votes for Monkey, but also supports a mass name claim. If Pom thought Monkey was scum, why did she support the mass claim? It seems like Pom is trying to bus and give Monkey another chance with the mass claim.
iso11
: "Why would Kast be a name cop?"
This basically seems to be the listed reason for her vote. Not a great reason. Looks like bussing to me.
iso12
: An assertion that Monkey should claim his targets, now that he's at L-1.
iso13
: A response to tajo. Basically saying that Monkey gave a paraphrase of his flavour already.
And that's all for yesterday.
iso14
: Asks for clarification on something that I find plenty clear already (i.e. Pom's question looks weak and throwaway), then places the third vote on manho for the reason, "I agree with SpyreX".
In conclusion, Pomegranate is a lurker whose iso is pretty much devoid of independent thought. Her vote on Monkey looks like weak bussing, with a last-ditch (and abandoned; she doesn't bring the mass claim up again after the post where she says she supports it) attempt to save him. This does not look like the town version of Pomegranate I know from
Open 175, where she took clear stances against the people she was voting, and provided independent thought through most of the game, most notably when she voted for people, which is what I'm looking at specifically for contrast with this game here.
And I'm so glad I saved this in notepad last night, because the site decided to crash as I was posting it.
On the manho wagon:
this does not look like bussing. If Monkey was wagonned and lynched day one, manho would get no credit for the lynch. It makes no sense for a scumbuddy of Monkey to post that instead of something decent for town cred. In addition,
this does not come from scum. Posting that would be like asking to be lynched. I know it's a fallacy, but I think this particular post is too scummy to come from scum. Add that to the fact that I don't think Monkey would claim results on his buddies, and I get that manho is town.
If anyone wants to hear my theory on that, it's that if you claim a rolecop result on a townie, they can be like "Oh yeah! That's my role! You're right! I can support your claim now!" and then get lynched the next day. You can't really do that with scumbuddies.
I could go with an nhammen lynch today as well for the reason Zito stated, but I find Pom scummier.
Vote: Pomegranate.
