1. Joined Jackwagon under the most suspicious circumstances D1. (Jack is town via my secret towntell announced D1.)
2. Even though SPS was his major suspect D1, he opted to NOT join the SPS wagon D3, but instead to vote me, even though he had NEVER so much as MENTIONED my name ALL GAME.
In other words, he pushed the alternawagon (mine) against the SPScum wagon, even though his rhetoric had said SPS was the scum before that.
3. Way way way premature softclaim D4.
3. When suspicion on him picked up a little, he tried to establish a tangent about PZ being sort-of-odd-but-not-really-scummy.
1. ooba (probably town due to D2) has a meta towntell on him.
The bolded is the biggest scumtell IMO.
From xvart
1. Said that the scum on Jackwagon was CKD or SPS *IF* there were scum D1, rather than that one of those was scum 100%.
2. Also D1, said that SPS was scummy, but for reasons different than MPR had listed.
From Starbuck
3. Made "assumptions" about time management as part of his case against xvart D3.
From SP
4. Meta scumtell based on "misuse of meta."
1 is purely semantic. 2 isn't scummy. 3 is a miscommunication because I worded the case on xvart poorly the first time. 4 is because all my finished games with SP have had both of us as non-town, so he has a sampling bias thing happening.