Mini 950: DCI Mafia (The Results Are In...)

[Nikanor]

For those of you asking: I unvoted Starbuck because I thought she might be fakeclaiming Townie as a power role. I've done it before, so it seemed plausible at the time.

Then I remembered that I'm probably the only one in this game who's insane enough to pull something like that.

Question: Why the hell are people claiming townie?

[Nikanor]

Actually, I'm going to claim, too.
I'm The Cadets, Townie Miller.
I'm claiming now because our beloved cop is probably going to inspect me tonight, and if we mislynch today that would be a very very bad lylo situation.
Carry on.

[CryMeARiver]

Publicly posted? Where?

Riiight. You couldn't be bothered to check, you know, where townie PMs are normally posted.

CMAR IS SCUM

I'm seriously confused. I checked the Sample PM's before I wrote that last post and my claim is not there. I provided flavor info that came with my role and my troop name.

[Parama]

Oh joy.
I'm going to say screw it and claim myself if you guys keep this up.

[Nachomamma8]

I'm back.

Unvote, Vote: Nikanor

[Parama]

*headdesk*
I don't want to lynch Nikanor anymore, why do you guys suddenly want to? Can't we lynch scum i.e. kunk?

[kunkstar7]

I'm back.

Unvote, Vote: Nikanor

I know you've been on a roll this game with unexplained votes...but this one can't be explained with "calling out a lurker", so I'm calling enough. Reasons please?

[Slaxx]

Yeah, Nacho is getting a little ridiculous.

[Nikanor]

Nacho, your town cred can only be stretched so far~.

[Starbuck]

So nobody else sees how Parama is constantly tripping over himself?

[Parama]

So nobody else sees how you're not even trying to prove anything you accuse me of?

[Nachomamma8]

So, kunk. Nikanor's miller claim gives you a townier read on him, then?

[Slaxx]

Parama is tripping over himself. I got to sort stuff out. Something isn't right.

[Stephoscope]

Publicly posted? Where?

Riiight. You couldn't be bothered to check, you know, where townie PMs are normally posted.

CMAR IS SCUM

I'm seriously confused. I checked the Sample PM's before I wrote that last post and my claim is not there. I provided flavor info that came with my role and my troop name.

You provided generic information that was already posted in the sample PMs...so close it could have been copy/paste...except you forgot to type the word "win" when you were typing in your made-up role instead of copying and pasting your scum one.

[kunkstar7]

So, kunk. Nikanor's miller claim gives you a townier read on him, then?

Why couldn't you just state that in your vote post then? It just seems you are voting then finding reasons to substantiate it.

Regarding the miller claim, I'm more inclined to believe claims, so yes its probably more of a townish read seeing the role. It makes sense in my mind for a miller to claim early.

Steph, do you really believe that CMAR's claim is scummy because of the way he claimed? I'm really seeing you just blowing it out of proportion to substantiate your case against him, that's scummy. Also tunneling on CMAR. What say you to Nikanor's miller claim? The back and forth between Parama/Starbuck?

[Parama]

What makes an early claim more believable? Not exactly sure where you got that from. Plus, self-aware millers are supposed to claim ASAP. The claim doesn't make Nik less scummy IMO.
I would still like people to point out where I'm tripping over myself because otherwise all I see is Starbuck accusing me of something and not even bothering to prove it and Slaxx buddying Starbuck's logic because he feels like it. Looks like a scumteam to me. Add in kunk, there's our three scum, gg.

[Slaxx]

So, because you are tripping over yourself, us 3 are scum? Or is there like, something i am missing here.

[Parama]

Yeah you're definitely misrepping what I said and all but that's fine.
Two people have accused me of the same thing and both have failed to point out where. If you can't prove something then there's no sense in making baseless accusations.
Starbuck is scum for overreacting to my initial claim, making a BS accusation that I'm being nervous because of my confidence after the initial nervous response to my list, hypocritical in itself really, then lurking when Nikanor and me were having an argument, following this up with a period of active lurking, and let's not forget her recent accusation that I'm tripping over myself - which she has been doing all game - while doing nothing to prove her accusation.
Slaxx is scum for the attempted buddying with me then later pulling a 180 for no reason, lining up lynches solely because I felt Ani was town (and he was), and now he's blindly following Starbuck's baseless accusation and not giving any of his own reasons for doing such.
Kunk is scum for overreacting to early votes on him, continued active lurking, a quick distancing maneuver when today's Starbuck wagon started to form, and wanting to bus Starbuck in an attempt to save himself. Though it could also be scum trying to get a townie lynched - which is why I want kunk dead first. If he flips scum then Starbuck looks townier, though it could still be bussing.
ANYWHO. Yes you know my opinions I took all these points from my own ISO so there's nothing new here. This is just a summary of accusations that I've made in the past against 3 scummy players who just so happen to be scum.

[kunkstar7]

What makes an early claim more believable? Not exactly sure where you got that from. Plus, self-aware millers are supposed to claim ASAP.

The original sentence went:

It makes sense in my mind for a

miller

to claim early.

So you answered this with your following sentence by stating that they should claim ASAP. I think Nikanor's claim was within a reasonable time frame and he wasn't under pressure of lynch.

[Parama]

IMO millers should claim in their first post.
But honestly this is irrelevant to what I want to happen today.

[Slaxx]

No its not. If you dont believe the miller claim, or think it makes nik more scummy, you should want to lynch nik, maybe not first, but regardless.

[Slaxx]

Oh, and PArama trips over himself again in the above post.

[Parama]

I don't care about lynching Nikanor right now. It's not like Starbuck hasn't claimed either. Nikanor isn't scummy enough IMO to warrant a lynch, kunk is. I'm not tripping over myself if I'm agreeing with my reads. And really, one tiny irrelevant thing does not make someone scum.

[Stephoscope]

Steph, do you really believe that CMAR's claim is scummy because of the way he claimed? I'm really seeing you just blowing it out of proportion to substantiate your case against him, that's scummy. Also tunneling on CMAR. What say you to Nikanor's miller claim? The back and forth between Parama/Starbuck?

Yes. He made it look like it was copied/pasted, but it clearly wasn't. Because he had to type it to put in the fake info.

I think I believe Nikanor. I think Parama and Starbuck are both town.

[Nikanor]

Nikanor (3, L-2) - CryMeARiver, Nicodemus, Nachomamma8
Starbuck (2, L-3) - Slaxx, Nikanor
CryMeARiver (2, L-3) - Stephoscope, kunkstar7
Parama (1, L-4) - Starbuck
kunkstar7 (1, L-4) - Parama

So tonight I'm going to be lynched if the votes don't change. I'm willing to act entirely in the interest of self-preservation here and vote CMAR.
Here's my reason:

That's the Colts logo. Doesn't it just SCREAM evil?

Unvote. Vote: CMAR.