Open 215 - Gurgi EC8 - Game Show Mafia, Over

[Cirno]

On a different tack: how does everyone feel about any other "Cops" claiming today?

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

On a different tack: how does everyone feel about any other "Cops" claiming today?

Please explain to me how ^ is the same as this:

@VRK:

You want all the cops to claim

, but not a massclaim? If all the cops claim, then everyone else must be assumed to be vanilla townies or scum, right? What is the difference?

[Cirno]

If you are not suggesting having the cops claim, then what are you suggesting?

[wolframnhart]

I think i know what VRK is saying but i will let him answer.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

If you are not suggesting having the cops claim, then what are you suggesting?

I wanted to know what others thought of the idea. I was not advocating the idea. In fact, in the same post you pulled this from, I explicitly stated later on that I think we should popcorn again:

On a different tack: how does everyone feel about any other "Cops" claiming today? Can we take the chance that any other Cops revealing now will give us more information than keeping quiet until tomorrow?

...SNIP...

I think our best bet is to do another popcorn.

And we should do as much scum hunting today as possible. I'm not going to vote for Chnorek until we're ready to end the day.

So I'm not suggesting anything. I'm gathering information.

[farside22]

This is all really fasinating stuff people but lets remember a few things at this stage with 6 people left
we have 2 scum
4 town

After yesterday and a dead cop we know as town who the cop was checking. However the scum know at least one play (possible unless we got lucky and scum was forced to investigate scum) that the scum knows of one player that is not a weak cop.
So the scum in more informed then the town on things in my view.

Also a hypoclaim does no good if there is not another cop. Scum will continue to hid and try for a fake claim tomorrow unless there is another cop.
Now think of this for a moment.
We have another cop lets just say. That investigated a player and they are a live.
That means we have 2 players semi confirmed.
(I say semi because the "cop" claim could be a fake). 1 confirmed town (I say confirmed town do to the cop death today)
If I missed anything in this let me know.

[SensFan]

This is not true, for me at least. What I said (and Cirno was the one who put words in my mouth)

Please show me where I put any words into your mouth, sir.

He's the person I was most comfortable assuming was pro-Town, other than myself.

Cirno comes back with

Why did you feel comfortable assuming he was pro-town?

When exactly did you stop beating your wife, Sir?

[Cirno]

>>implying that that is somehow putting words into your mouth and that the "beating your wife" line is even remotely similar.

@VRK: To answer your previous question, Sensfan completely confounds me.

Concerning "what information", the obvious information we get is what role each player claims to be and possibly the results of an investigation.


Also, through process of elimination, this is how I'd placed my bets currently.

chnorek

night results suggests it and his silence confirms it.

Cirno

too adorable for scum

farside22

interaction with chnorek

wolframnhart

gut

SensFan

Sandman's investigation target, no interaction with Chnorek, chooses Chnorek to select after him in popcorn, gut

Vel-Rahn Koon

process of elimination, strategy

[farside22]

Sens chose Vel to select after him in popcorn not Chrnorek.

[Cirno]

I see. Well, I still like these bets.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Mod: V/LA until Monday. I'm going to try to continue to post as much as possible.

[yawetag]

Mod: V/LA until Monday. I'm going to try to continue to post as much as possible.

Thanks, VRK. V/LA noted.

[SensFan]

Is it really any surprise to anyone that Cirno is tunelling on me?

[farside22]

Is it really any surprise to anyone that Cirno is tunelling on me?

No but I did note that sandman was the one to die and he was the one that hypoclaimed to investigate you. It was the part were I speculate that you could be scum do to that and thinking he was a weak cop but it's more speculation. I still like Cirno as partners with chnorek right now.

[Cirno]

>>Cirno: I think SensFan is scum for these reasons.
>>SensFan: Cirno is tunneling.

I hope you have more of a response than that?

[chnorek]

it would be unfair to get replaced in this moment. *dodge prod*

[wolframnhart]

chnorek do you have anything to say about the night kill? The discussion that has gone on today?

[farside22]

vote: chnorek

If we do hypo claiming we should get it out of the way now.

I personally would investigate Cirno if I was the cop.

[wolframnhart]

I will vote after the hypoclaim just to make sure it happens.

I will investigate VRK

[chnorek]

chnorek do you have anything to say about the night kill? The discussion that has gone on today?

would you? i will get lynched whatever i would have said. there is good chance game will end beforeD3 anyways, i consider it as lost, I didnt even imagine scenario that mavs would target someone else. Myself i would lynch whoever was in my place.
Only thing i can say is to leave discussion who is other scumm for next day, there will be enough time to build connections basing on flip.

[chnorek]

sorry for triple post, mod please delete those

[wolframnhart]

Hell yes I would have something to say about the night kill. I would be fighting tooth and nail to prevent my lynch if i was you.

Also your post makes no sense. You say the game will end before day three, that we should leave discussion for who is scum for the next day (even though apparently we won't have one) and that your flip would help build connections. If the game will end before day 3 how will your flip help anything?

[yawetag]

sorry for triple post, mod please delete those

Extra posts deleted

[SensFan]

I'll hypoclaim Wolf.

Cirno, it's obvious you're tunnelling on me; I don't need to spell it out for anyone else.

[farside22]

@farside, wolf, & Cirno:

how do you feel about Sensfan?

Sens feels town in this game but I have that little voice in my head that never trust him.