Mini 950: DCI Mafia (The Results Are In...)

[Nikanor]

This is a terribad answer.
Playing with new people comes going through the same routine. You dedicated time to answering the questions badly, you couldn't have taken 10 more minutes to answer them truthfully?

No, I couldn't have. Answer those questions is a waste of time.
Tell me - do you take the time to fill out 10-minute surveys handed out by people on the sidewalk? I don't.

Yes you do. You can't just accuse random people without any reasoning.
What did the answers and his alignment show you oh king?

No I don't. To quote Pierre Trudeau, "Just watch me."
And I didn't really get much from it, tbh. It would have been much more useful if ani had fipped scum.

That's not what it sounded like. Either you actually thought that or you lied, your choice.

I lied. I said that it wasn't a truth. What're going to do about it, punk?

That's even worse.
You pointed out that Navy was dodging. Then you voted kunkstar with no reasoing, but clear bandwagoning.

lern2reed, scumbag.

Unvote. Vote: kunkstar7.
Active lurking. He has done zero scumhunting in the ~10 posts he's made in this game.

What else could over confidence have meant? Still, none of this changes the fact that you were hypocritical.

Uhm, when it's changed to a

META

tell, it changes everything. I'm always this confident.

This makes no sense.

NO U.

This surprised me. Distancing your buddy? Interesting tactic.
Scum would act hypocritically because they have to lie. Town should not have to lie. Therefore scum has a better chance of being caught in their lie - hypocritical.

I can has strawman?

This is very interesting. He accuses half the player list of being scum.

Your point? Aren't you supposed to be accusing me of being overconfident?

Actually, yeah. I agree with Slaxx here. We can lynch Starbuck the "Townie" now.

Unvote. Vote: Starbuck.

[Trumpet of Doom]

I think I'm just going to replace Nicodemus now.

ToD Presents: The Best of DCI (The Cavaliers, 2004: 007)

Vote Count N:

Starbuck (3, L-2) - Parama, Slaxx, Nikanor

CryMeARiver (2, L-3) - Stephoscope, kunkstar7
Nicodemus (1, L-4) - Nachomamma8
Nikanor (1, L-4) - CryMeARiver
Parama (1, L-4) - Starbuck

Not Voting (1): Nicodemus

5 votes are required to lynch, 3 at deadline.
If deadline were to hit right now, Starbuck would be lynched.

Current Deadline:

Monday, May 5, 2010, ~9:00 PM CDT (GMT-6+1)

[Starbuck]

Mod: Slaxx has a voted me on the prior page

[Starbuck]

EDBWOP *has voted me

[Starbuck]

I was very much looking forward to this game, and I claimed because I have nothing to hide.

If my calculations are correct, I probably hit scum with my suspicions and scum are behind this opportunistic lynch.

[Parama]

You claimed when you weren't even close to being lynched because you didn't want to get to that point. BECAUSE YOU'RE SCUM. My vote's not changing.

[Parama]

You claimed when you weren't even close to being lynched because you didn't want to get to that point. BECAUSE YOU'RE SCUM. My vote's not changing.

[Starbuck]

Town, please remember just how much Parama railed against me when I FLIP AS ONE OF YOUR OWN.

[Starbuck]

Be prepared because he will try and back peddle away tomorrow when the game opens after night actions.

[Slaxx]

Nice AtE. Thats not really a defense at all.

[Starbuck]

It's not AtE. It's the truth.

But then again, you are trying to pin an opportunistic bandwagon on me, along with your scumbuddy Parama.

[Parama]

Town, please remember just how much Parama railed against me when I FLIP AS ONE OF YOUR OWN.

Lol. I'm not going to backtrack because on the odd chance that you aren't scum you're still the scummiest player here.
Also I have no scumbuddy, oddly enough. Might be because I'm not scum.

[Parama]

Actually, new plan that makes everyone happy.
Lynch someone like CMAR or kunk, then have Starbuck get vigged tonight. Personally I think we can get more info out of a CMAR or kunk lynch than a Starbuck lynch, and both are nice and scummy anyways.

CMAR get that quote out of your sig

Vig: shoot Starbuck tonight

unvote, vote: kunkstar

In other news, I don't like Nikanor's vote on Starbuck at all. Is that your only reason for voting Starbuck?

[Starbuck]

And do you remember the questions at the beginning of the game?

Why not go back and re-read mine?

[Nicodemus]

I think I'm just going to replace Nicodemus now.

Yeah, sorry, college has been stupid busy and I know I've made and broken a lot of promises about posting but I'm going to try to stick it out in this game if it's possible.

Nikanor's vote on Starbuck absolutely reeks. Why spend your entire post calling CMAR a scumbag and then vote Starbuck at the end for the early claim? Looks like you're going for the easy target to me.

Vote: Nikanor

[Slaxx]

Nicodemus....What about Stgarbuck's claim. Wtf is with that?

[Nicodemus]

Hmmm. Now that I look at it, it looks fairly terrible. Why say "lowly VT"? It does seem vaguely manipulative, and claiming that early really doesn't make sense from a pro-town perspective. Her AtE are also bad.

Still, Nikanor's vote was bad because of how he framed it. Yours was good because you made your point and voted. Nik called out CMAR for 9/10s of the post, and then tacked on a vote for Starbuck at the end. The revote makes even less sense from Nik considering the fact that he was voting Starbuck and then unvoted AFTER Starbuck claimed, but is now voting again because of your reasoning? It looks too fishy to me. The situation feels more like scumNik jumping on the Starbuck wagon after he realized that he could get support from people like you.

[Slaxx]

I have nothing to hide. Therefore I am clear.

WOW, THIS GAME IS EASY LULZ. Now all the other townies say it and we win!

uh, no. And I agree that ? Nik's vote was a one of suspicions too.

@Nic Specifically: Do you think it could be a bus?

[Slaxx]

-Agree that Nik's vote.

[Starbuck]

You can't clear yourself.

[Slaxx]

@Parama, directing a vig kill is scummy. If anything town will come to a consensus on it. Not like if there is a vig they have to follow it anyway, but I think thats the best move for us.

Also...why are we so sure there is a vig? A game I just got done with had a paranoid gun owner hybrid in it. Mafia visited him and a mafia died, then there was all this talk about a serial killer. Nacho knows what im talking about.

Anyway, dont rule anything out. Although I would agree that looker was probably the optimal vig kill, he could have easily visited a PGO or something else. I wouldn't be relying on any sort a vig kill.

[Starbuck]

As for why I would say "lowly VT", take a gander at my Wiki. Just look at how often I roll VT. It's fucking depressing. As I said, none of what I have said has been meant as AtE, but as none of you have played with me or haven't played with me a lot, you wouldn't understand how I am.

[Slaxx]

You can't clear yourself.

A. You didn't get the sarcasm of my post
B. You didn't get the relevance to your post


Either way, the only thing you've done lately is claim VT and have back and forth game irrelevant or distracting arguments with people, making my confidence in my vote all the more sweeter.

[Slaxx]

In fact, you have done nothing but tunnel on Parama the whole game. I just ISOed you, and you FoSed me once, along with Stephoscope...

[Starbuck]

I know that's all I have done, but as I said, you & Parama have made this game almost unbearable to deal with. The only reason I haven't replaced out is because I have a staunch "don't replace out" policy.