Mini 950: DCI Mafia (The Results Are In...)

[Nikanor]

I don't like your apparently judging posts as to whether or not they're "scumhunting". I am scumhunting every second that I am in a game as town. Every interaction provides something else to analyze. "Anti-town" moves can often win games for town.

Scum don't scumhunt. They fakescumhunt. Therefore it's good to see who is scumhunting and who is not, because the non-scumhunters are more likely to be scum themselves.
Also, your second sentence kind of proves my point. You weren't posting, so you weren't scumhunting.

[CryMeARiver]

Vote Count J:
animorpherv1 (5, L-2) -

Nachomamma8, Nicodemus, NavyCherub, Slaxx, Nikanor

Looker (2, L-5) - Stephoscope, kunkstar7
Parama (2, L-5) - Starbuck, Looker
Slaxx (2, L-5) - animorpherv1, Parama

Not Voting (1): CryMeARiver
7 votes are required to lynch, 4 at deadline.

I realize that possibly two of the probable 3 scum were likely on the animorph wagon since it was easy to blend in there because it looked like town just trying to get a lynch in. I would like reasons for why you voted animorph and which post(s) you show this reasoning in.

[Starbuck]

Someone's been avoiding the Nik-Parama argument in hopes that I get lynched without their help! That someone is Starbuck! Who still need to post a case on me so I can rip it apart!

1. I have a case posted on you and I don't feel the need to reiterate.

2. Avoiding? No. It's a pointless "ZOMG, YOU DID THIS AND THIS AND THIS IN THAT GAME!", "BUT NO WAIT! YOU DID THIS AND THIS AND THAT IN THAT GAME" fucking argument. It's stupid and distracting and I'm waiting for you two to be done.

3. I think you just felt like OMGUSing me, which doesn't move you anywhere towards my town list.



And, why don't you try and spell "NAVY" correctly?





I'd also like to state that I really don't post much over the weekends. So to prod me anywhere between like Thurs night and Sunday is just redundant. I do try and keep up at least, but I don't really do substantial posting (where I have to re-read and all that good stuff) during that time.

[Parama]

It's stupid and distracting and I'm waiting for you two to be done.

Well then, is there anything you'd like to comment on about the exchange? I'm sure you have at least something to say about the argument.

And, why don't you try and spell "NAVY" correctly?

I am definitely spelling Nvay correctly. You're the one spelling Nvay wrong.
(it's an inside joke - ask Nvay himself)

[Starbuck]

I am going to be giving this game a good read through before the end of the week. Maybe I'll have a comment on the argument then, but right now, I really don't have one.

[Slaxx]

CMAR....How come 2? Could it not be all 3?

[Starbuck]

For the record, Parama, I have been enlisted in the UNITED STATES NAVY for 6 years. Inside joke or not, please try to spell it correctly, he's dead and no longer playing.

[Slaxx]

Chill. Seriously.

[Parama]

For the record, Parama, I have been enlisted in the UNITED STATES NAVY for 6 years. Inside joke or not, please try to spell it correctly, he's dead and no longer playing.

Okay, this is completely irrelevant and I will continue to spell Nvay correctly.
NvayCherub =/= US Navy

[Starbuck]

Nah I don't feel like chilling. It would work if he was alive, and he's not. He's dead, so the inside joke thing just doesn't work anymore.

[Parama]

No, the problem is that must continue to refer to Nvay as Nvay and not as Navy because there's a difference and it's not based on interactions as much as referencing.
I don't understand why you are getting so worked up about this and are continuing to actively not provide content.

[Slaxx]

As amusing as it is to be a 3rd party in this discussion, it has absolutely nothing to do with the game.

[Starbuck]

That's the funny part, I'm not worked up.

But you keep on misrepresenting me as so. You're pretty good at that.

[Parama]

Yes that's exactly what I said. Seems like Starbuck is active lurking IMO.

[Starbuck]

Lawlz.

My vote is on the person I find scummiest. So how exactly am I active lurking?

[Parama]

That's the funny part, I'm not worked up.

But you keep on misrepresenting me as so. You're pretty good at that.

Um... what? You're commenting more on something that doesn't have anything to do with the game than you are on the game itself. There's an obvious problem here.

[Starbuck]

What problem?

You're the one who's kept this going.



You are also the one who is accusing me of active lurking when I'm not.


Do you mean to say those last however many pages of meta WEREN'T active lurking? Because they surely weren't about this game.

[Parama]

What problem?

You're the one who's kept this going.

Lol. You started it first of all and you're the one who continued to argue about it after I gave all the explanation necessary. It's completely irrelevant yet you continue to comment solely on it. This allows you to ignore the actual gameplay while still letting you post plenty. Thus, active lurking.
Also, stop saying the word "meta". There's a new rule - if you say it you get modkilled.

Is there now? I wasn't informed of it. - ToD

[Starbuck]

Little do you know me darling, I was making a point.

I was hoping to end that stupid meta discussion so that we could move on, and scumhunt.


Our other people's need to get their asses in here and give some opinions.

[CryMeARiver]

CMAR....How come 2? Could it not be all 3?

Could be if scum doesn't work well together. There was no need for all three to be on the wagon, he would have been lynched either way. It's just incriminating.

[kunkstar7]

Ok, back from my trip.

Some thoughts on whats happened since I left (like the bottom of pg. 15):

We can always just vig him, I suppose.

Awesome rolefishing.

If anyone wants to know why I think that is the scumteam, it is because I drunkenly wrote that in my notes last night, but I can't remember why.
I trust my drunken reasoning, though.

I hate how you copped out of responsibility for your reads with this.

I don't like your apparently judging posts as to whether or not they're "scumhunting". I am scumhunting every second that I am in a game as town. Every interaction provides something else to analyze. "Anti-town" moves can often win games for town.

If you're scum, just say so and then we probably won't need a replacement.

Its nice of you to show up. If this is your definition of scumhunting then I find it very poor. Seems more like just commentary than anything. Any reads today? I see a vote on CMAR, for the stated reasons of his case seeming poor and a scummy predeccesor. Why is his predeccesor scummy? What do you think about Looker having flipped town? From your ISO:

If anything, I'm more convinced he's scum. I'm willing to take the heat tomorrow if he is lynched today and flips town.

How do you think this reflects on you? I'm undecided if this was meant to be so blatant we would ignore it or if you really thought he was scum.

Conclusions: ~~WIFOM about NK~~

In this case I don't find it productive to speculate about the NK(s) as there are too many possibilities in this situation.

I realize that possibly two of the probable 3 scum were likely on the animorph wagon since it was easy to blend in there because it looked like town just trying to get a lynch in. I would like reasons for why you voted animorph and which post(s) you show this reasoning in.

Why do you believe that there are 3 probable scum?

CMAR....How come 2? Could it not be all 3?

Same line of thought, this sentence seems like you know for certain that there are three scum.

FOS: Slaxx & CMAR

, there's no way you can know what the scum setup is unless you are one.

Also, stop saying the word "meta". There's a new rule - if you say it you get modkilled.

*meta meta meta meta meta*

[Slaxx]

Lol kunk. GENERALLY a 12 person setup has 3 mafia. Are you sure that wasnt a cheap shot because I have expressed some suspicion on you?

[kunkstar7]

Lol kunk. GENERALLY a 12 person setup has 3 mafia. Are you sure that wasnt a cheap shot because I have expressed some suspicion on you?

No, my statements are detached from the fact that you are voting me
I FOS'ed CMAR for the same reason and he hasn't voted me.

Maybe the setup does, maybe it doesn't. Generally isn't enough in my mind to explain the fact that your statement was written as if you were certain that that is the setup, or at least have some hint as to what the ratio is in this game.

[Slaxx]

True. I'm going to continue to assume 3 because thats all ive seen these 12 player setups with, but im sure there are exceptions.

[Nicodemus]

Prod received.

I am not giving this game the attention I need to, and I'm going to fix this tonight. expect a mega post soon-ish.

Well I suck.

If I don't get something up in the next 24 hours, replace me please.

working on this now