Mini 950: DCI Mafia (The Results Are In...)

[Parama]

Hello Mr. ANI IS SCUMZORZ!!!!
Are you really one to be saying that?

[Slaxx]

Yeah. And I was the first one to move off the damn kunk wagon too. But I did think Ani was more scummy than kunk. Of course now it's obvious I don't.

[Nikanor]

My God. I can't believe I actually wrote that last night.
Anyway,

Unvote. Vote: kunkstar.

I've forgotten why I thought he was not scum. Even doing a quick read-through of his posts in iso doesn't give me any clues to why I thought he was not scum.
So, bandwagon ahoy.

[Parama]

I'm staying on Starbuck until I get a response. And tbh kunk started looking townier at the end of yesterday but he's still on my list in case you were wondering.

[Parama]

Okay quick Nvay ISO because I've been forgetting to do it.
ISO 5 - the only one of my suspicions here that Nvay agrees with is kunkstar. Nvay votes kunk.

ISO6 - Concern that Nik is already committed to an Ani lynch.

ISO 7 - Nvay tells me I'm rushing things.

ISO 10 - Happy with kunk vote, vote stays.

ISO 14 - One of Slaxx/Me is probably scum. I'm overreacting, Slaxx is setting up lynches.

ISO 15 - Town reads on me and Nico

ISO 16 - Says he would to lynch me if Ani wasn't being scummy

Conclusions: Usually it benefits scum to leave people who have town reads on them alive. Nvay had a town read on Nico - maybe the only player to have such - so it's unlikely Nico would want Nvay dead.
Nvay had a scum read on kunk early on but abandoned the wagon in favor of an Ani vote. It would make sense that Nvay is a good target for kunk-scum to kill.
There were also brief mentions of Slaxx and Nik though Nvay was leaning town on Nik for most of the day. Slaxx-scum killing Nvay would probably make sense as well.
I'm not going to weigh in on Nvay's comments about me - you guys can do that yourself.
From the kill the most likely scum is either kunk or Slaxx. HOWEVER NK analysis should not be playing a major part in today's lynch. I'm only putting this up for reference and to hear your guys' thoughts on the matter.

[Nachomamma8]

Mod: Starbuck, Kunkstar, CMAR, and Nico all need prods. Make it happen.

RE: Navy ISO: Out of everyone, I think it incriminates you and Slaxx the most; in fact, you even bringing it up makes me feel a bit more suspicious of you. Why? Well, mafia is ALWAYS hesitant to kill people who have them as their number one suspect. Rarely, however, are they nervous about killing someone who just happens to be their second suspect, especially if they are suspect someone else far more.

If kunkscum wanted to kill someone who suspected him, then it'd be a far better idea to kill Slaxx, no?

[CryMeARiver]

Mod: Starbuck, Kunkstar, CMAR, and Nico all need prods. Make it happen.

RE: Navy ISO: Out of everyone, I think it incriminates you and Slaxx the most; in fact, you even bringing it up makes me feel a bit more suspicious of you. Why? Well, mafia is ALWAYS hesitant to kill people who have them as their number one suspect. Rarely, however, are they nervous about killing someone who just happens to be their second suspect, especially if they are suspect someone else far more.

If kunkscum wanted to kill someone who suspected him, then it'd be a far better idea to kill Slaxx, no?

I haven't given this game a lot of respect that past few day and haven't been posting, but I'm here and alive

[Parama]

Nvay was someone who suspected kunk early on and then moved away from the suspicions in favor of lynching Ani. But it means Nvay would probably be willing to lynch kunk further down the road. AKA, a good target to take out.

[Nachomamma8]

So? In ISO 16, Navy practically comes outright and says that he was going to lynch you today...

[Parama]

Nvay said that yesterday before any flips. Does it mean it would hold true after 3 people died?

[Nikanor]

OR the scum just noticed that nobody was going after Navy, and so killed him. This conversation isn't going to get us anywhere unless one of you can tell us that that wasn't the case.

[Nikanor]

Actually, now that I think about it, Nico is very likely to be scum. I don't see how else he's been allowed to lurk for this long.

Unvote. Vote: Nicodemus.

I'm thinking Nico+Starbuck+kunkstar. Don't ask me why. Nico is a much better lynch than the other two, though.

[Slaxx]

That is just Nico's town meta. I would prefer not to policy lynch on day 2.

[Parama]

STOP SAYING THE WORD META

[Nikanor]

Not a policy lynch. PoE lynch. Big difference.
Also, lurking is not anyone's town meta.
We can always just vig him, I suppose.

[Slaxx]

Parama....i don't see how three flips have anything to do with anything.

[Slaxx]

Assuming there is a vig. Tracker could have visited town killing role...etc. WIFOM. Not getting into it.

[Nikanor]

If anyone wants to know why I think that is the scumteam, it is because I drunkenly wrote that in my notes last night, but I can't remember why.
I trust my drunken reasoning, though.

[Trumpet of Doom]

Mod: Starbuck, Kunkstar, CMAR, and Nico all need prods. Make it happen.

kunkstar7 is V/LA, and CryMeARiver has avoided prodding by virtue of me being a slacker. Starbuck and Nicodemus, however, are prod-eligible and have been prodded; this is the second prod for both - the next time I catch them being prod-eligible, I'll begin a replacement search.

ToD Presents: The Best of DCI (Santa Clara Vanguard, 2005: Russia: Revolution - Evolution 1917-1991)

Vote Count M:
Nicodemus (2, L-3) - Nachomamma8, Nikanor
kunkstar7 (1, L-4) - Slaxx
Nikanor (1, L-4) - CryMeARiver
Parama (1, L-4) - Starbuck
CryMeARiver (1, L-4) - Stephoscope
Starbuck (1, L-4) - Parama

Not Voting (2): kunkstar7, Nicodemus

5 votes are required to lynch, 3 at deadline.

Current Deadline:

Monday, May 5, 2010, ~9:00 PM CDT (GMT-6+1)

[Nachomamma8]

Speaking of V/LAs, I'll have one of those until Wednesday...

Noted. - ToD

[Nicodemus]

Prod received.

I am not giving this game the attention I need to, and I'm going to fix this tonight. expect a mega post soon-ish.

[Nicodemus]

Prod received.

I am not giving this game the attention I need to, and I'm going to fix this tonight. expect a mega post soon-ish.

Well I suck.

If I don't get something up in the next 24 hours, replace me please.

[Stephoscope]

If I don't get something up in the next 24 hours, replace me please.

If you're scum, just say so and then we probably won't need a replacement.

[Stephoscope]

Gotcha. Too bad there is no scumhunting in this post, or I would be completely satisfied.

Unvote. Vote: Parama.

Speaking of scumhunting, why is it that I'm the only one doing any right now?

I don't like your apparently judging posts as to whether or not they're "scumhunting". I am scumhunting every second that I am in a game as town. Every interaction provides something else to analyze. "Anti-town" moves can often win games for town.

[Starbuck]

It's the weekend and I was checking in periodically, but at the time there were only like 2 or 3 posts under my last one, and I really had nothing to respond to.

Now, all of a sudden the thread exploded over night. Catching up later today.