Mini 950: DCI Mafia (The Results Are In...)

[Starbuck]

Because it doesn't read like Aniscum to me.

On Day 1, I'm lucky if I have one scum read. So I will keep presenting my case.


Also, I guess it wasn't obvious enough that I also suspect Slaxx.

[animorpherv1]

@Starbuck: I have experience with Ani town, and I've read games with AniScum. The over-seriousness with the RQS combined with a failure to do anything else with a side of posting everywhere else BUT here suggests AniScum. What's making you disagree? Also, I think everyone's understood your case on Parama, so you can stop presenting it now. More than one scum read is good.

I don't remember playing with you. Links pl0x?

Also, Parama has never presented how he got 3 scum reads in the first 3 pages, although he was asked many many times.

[NavyCherub]

Navy, what makes you think Slaxxx/Parama scum?

They seemed like a little buddy-ish in the middle of the day, but it wasn't too weird at that point. The recent events of Parama calling Slaxx out for buddying and then them both distancing themselves from each other looks really suspicious to me.

Who more? Why?

Slaxx; so far I've had a more town read on Parama, and similar to Nico this is different for me but that's what it is.

Why not together?

It's not that they can't be scum together, but right now I think its more likely that only one of them is scum because it doesn't seem like a scum team would make the distancing that obvious.

[Parama]

Also, Parama has never presented how he got 3 scum reads in the first 3 pages, although he was asked many many times.

*headdesk*
I GAVE MY REASONS IN THE POST WHERE I GAVE MY READS. IS THERE A PROBLEM WITH THAT?
I also have changed 2 of my reads.

[Starbuck]

But if you knew from page 3 that those 3 people were scum, why'd you have to change your reads?

[Parama]

I gave initial scum reads.
They changed.
Reads have an odd tendency of doing that y'know.

[Trumpet of Doom]

It has come to my attention that this game has (already) eclipsed my previous modded game in length. Keep it up.

ToD Presents: The Best of DCI (Bluecoats, 2008: The Knockout - Part 1, Part 2)

Vote Count I:

animorpherv1 (5, L-2) - Nachomamma8, Nicodemus, NavyCherub, Slaxx, Nikanor

Looker (2, L-5) - Stephoscope, kunkstar7
Parama (2, L-5) - Starbuck, Looker
kunkstar7 (1, L-6) - Parama
Slaxx (1, L-6) - animorpherv1

Not Voting (1): CryMeARiver

7 votes are required to lynch, 4 at deadline.
If deadline were to hit right now, animorpherv1 would be lynched.

Current Deadline:

Friday, April 16, 2010, ~7:45 AM CDT (GMT-6+1)

[Nachomamma8]

Starbuck, if I told you I knew all the scum in this game, would you believe me? Would you take me seriously?

[Nikanor]

Also, Parama has never presented how he got 3 scum reads in the first 3 pages, although he was asked many many times.

I am still very happy with an ani lynch if this is all he can come up with after the past couple pages.

[Slaxx]

I'd love to hear Kunk's opinion of the Ani wagon.

[Nikanor]

Oh, and I think that if one of Parama and Slaxx are scum, it's Parama.

[Starbuck]

Nacho, coming to Parama's defense as well.

Noted.

[Nachomamma8]

Starbuck, is it not a valid question?

Ani, I replaced into games where you've replaced out; most notably, Teleportation mafia.

[Parama]

Nacho, coming to Parama's defense as well.

Noted.

It's cause the attack is illogical and unjustified. Usually players will come to defense of other players if the attack looks scum driven.

[Starbuck]

How is it illogical and unjustified?

[kunkstar7]

I'd love to hear Kunk's opinion of the Ani wagon.

It seems to me that ani's play is kinda standard coming from him lately, so for example I've got more of a nulltell from what Nikanor last stated about ani's play. Imo the ani wagon is building more out of a neccessity for a wagon at deadline rather than anything truly scummy.

@Nikanor, why Parama?

Starbuck, your clutching at straws on your attack on Parama now. Nacho was asking a legitimate question, and you avoided it in favor of using it to build your Parama case. I say answer his question, because he probably has some point to make regarding it.

[Starbuck]

Which question? I thought I did answer every question that's been put towards me.

[Parama]

Starbuck, if I told you I knew all the scum in this game, would you believe me? Would you take me seriously?

[Stephoscope]

On Day 1, I'm lucky if I have one scum read. So I will keep presenting my case.

Same here, and I am sorry I'm being perceived as a lurker, but there's not much I can do when the person I bring accusations against disappears. Let's lynch Looker and then I promise I will post more tomorrow.

[Parama]

Question; has anything that Looker has done since you originally posted your case against him done anything to change your opinion of him?

I'm just glad you're not using lurking as a part of your case or I would have to brutally murder you for hypocrisy.

[Starbuck]

Starbuck, if I told you I knew all the scum in this game, would you believe me? Would you take me seriously?

Probably not, but it's all about the tone.

Parama came out swinging and then the minute that I questioned him, I went on his scumdar? How does that make sense?

[Starbuck]

I mean, I wasn't even suspecting him at that point. I just wanted him to elaborate and if he overreacts that way to someone who wasn't even suspecting him, what does that show?


It shows that he's nervous scum. Look at how he was acting over Easter weekend. Crediting himself with starting conversation, and acting like this whole game began because of him. No, doesn't fly with me.

[Stephoscope]

Question; has anything that Looker has done since you originally posted your case against him done anything to change your opinion of him?

I'm just glad you're not using lurking as a part of your case or I would have to brutally murder you for hypocrisy.

If anything, I'm more convinced he's scum. I'm willing to take the heat tomorrow if he is lynched today and flips town.

[Parama]

It shows that he's nervous scum. Look at how he was acting over Easter weekend. Crediting himself with starting conversation, and acting like this whole game began because of him. No, doesn't fly with me.

Okay, how am I nervous? Because I'm believe I'm right? Because I'm confident in my reads? Isn't that, y'know, the OPPOSITE of nervous?
I didn't "start" the game, but I really got the ball rolling with my 3-scum post. And you can't deny this because at least half of what you've said to day has been because of one post.

[Slaxx]

Parama's 3 scum post might have created more discussion, but my 3 scum post is better.

Case coming soon.