OK, just did a reread, updated reads below:
Starbuck
didn't look great my first time through the thread, but on reread looks much better. I'm going to go ahead and call town v town on her and Parama. She's playing fairly openly and I think she's town, just confused by Parama's playstyle.
kunk
doesn't look good on a reread. He's given a few opinions, but overall has basically just defended himself and voted lurkers. I'm still not really seeing the paranoia of his first comment that makes him scum, but I always have a hard time picking up on the gut-scummy stuff, so. I think I'm going to put that post down to playstyle, and I can't fault someone for disagreeing on theory. Doing so is a great way to look like you're contributing when you're not, however, so kunk is still scummy.
Nacho
has dropped off significantly since I've begun to read his play better. His posting still seems like it would be a great way for scum to get by without much effort, but I like what he's been saying so far. Leaning town.
Stephoscope
has actually dropped on my scumdar after my reread. I don't know what it is, but I'm getting a gut town read on him. I feel like scum would, I don't know, try to disguise their uselessness a bit more.
Looker
is a complete null. Has done absolutely nothing, needs to step it up.
slaxx
is playing a very townie game, his posting is as clear, concise, and sincere as always.
Navy
is still null, even though he's contributed more than Looker and Nikanor combined. I just haven't gotten a good read on him yet, hopefully that can be rectified soon.
CMAR
is solidifying in my scum reads, due to his continued absence in this thread. His predecessor was lurky, only placed a RV when slaxx called him out on it, and then disappeared. CMAR has been no better. I would support a CMAR wagon if we could get it going.
Nikanor
is also null for me. Minimal input, minimal involvement. I need more from him.
ani
is still scum. Read him in ISO. 75% of his posts have to do with the RQS, which he took way too seriously, like he was trying to get it to pass for scumhunting. The rest contain minimal effort beyond buddying with Starbuck and Navy. His lurking now that he's become the popular wagon is pretty telling.
Parama
is looking quite town in this game, which is actually a first for me in games with him. I guess I'm getting used to his playstyle now, but yeah, he looks good to me.
Confirm vote: ani
Other lynches I would agree to: CMAR, kunk, Looker.
Ythan, on my play: "Scummy and bad are not the same. Some players manage to keep them separate, though I applaud how masterfully you blend them."
