Mini 950: DCI Mafia (The Results Are In...)

[Parama]

Then why did you ask me why I FoSed those three?

[Starbuck]

Because I would like you to elaborate on how you can pick out all 3 scum at the very beginning of Day 1.

[muh316]

Im sorry i lost my internet for a few days becasue we were switching to verizon. Ill catch up.

[Parama]

Because I would like you to elaborate on how you can pick out all 3 scum at the very beginning of Day 1.

Oh geez. Those are the most likely scum right now. And for now I will be sticking to calling out the scummiest players because it's scumhunting!
Starbuck's response looks like: Scum is curious as to why two of their scumbuddies have made my list of likely scum this early in the game!
I think I see a Kunk-Nacho-Starbuck or a Kunk-Stepho-Starbuck team now. More likely the first, though I want to see something from Stepho before I make a decision.

[Trumpet of Doom]

ToD Presents: The Best of DCI (The Cavaliers, 2002: Frameworks)

Vote Count C:

kunkstar7 (4, L-3) - Looker, Parama, Slaxx, NavyCherub

animorpherv1/Clank (3, L-4) - Nikanor, Nachomamma8, Starbuck
Nicodemus (2, L-5) - animorpherv1/Clank, muh316
Nachomamma8 (1, L-6) - kunkstar7
Looker (1, L-6) - Stephoscope
muh316 (1, L-6) - Nicodemus

Not Voting (0):

7 votes are required to lynch, 4 at deadline.
If deadline were to hit right now, kunkstar7 would be lynched.

Current Deadline:

Friday, April 16, 2010, ~7:45 AM CDT (GMT-6+1)

[NavyCherub]

Starbuck's response looks like: Scum is curious as to why two of their scumbuddies have made my list of likely scum this early in the game!
I think I see a Kunk-Nacho-Starbuck or a Kunk-Stepho-Starbuck team now. More likely the first, though I want to see something from Stepho before I make a decision.

More like, you seem awfully confident in your scum choices so early in the game by making connections

because those are the only connections that have been made at all.

[Parama]

And is there a problem with that?

[NavyCherub]

Yes, you're jumping the gun by a longshot and that doesn't really help.

[Parama]

Okay, look.
Here's the deal.
This game was dying before discussion had really begun.
I jumped the gun.
We have achieved discussion.
And is there a problem with that?

[NavyCherub]

It was Easter weekend.
You didn't have to call out an entire scum team like you're the God of mafia to create discussion.
Oh look, discussion!

[Parama]

The implication of my initial post was to spark discussion as well as giving my thoughts and hopefully getting reactions. The lack of discussion was the root of the problem, though - there wasn't much to take info from yet. And if I had failed to spark discussion, then I wouldn't be getting much of a reaction.

As you can tell, everything's been going as I hoped it would - we have discussion, reaction, and *GASP* scumhunting!

[animorpherv1]

OK, I got my account back.

Also, Cherub is right.

[Parama]

Okay, why is Cherub right?
More specifically, what makes me wrong?

[animorpherv1]

You didn't have to call out an entire scum team like you're the God of mafia to create discussion.

[Parama]

Comment on my opinions.
Give your own scum reads.
Spark discussion yourself.
At least I'm doing something, right?

You may not agree with my reads or my opinions but you have to admit that I did spark a nice discussion, and it seems I'm not the only one who thinks kunk is scum at the very least.

[Parama]

And another question - do my actions (scumhunting, trying to spark discussion) make me scummy? If so, for what reason? If the answer to the first question is No or if you can't come up with an answer to the second one then this whole exchange is rather pointless IMO.

[animorpherv1]

And another question - do my actions (scumhunting, trying to spark discussion) make me scummy? If so, for what reason? If the answer to the first question is No or if you can't come up with an answer to the second one then this whole exchange is rather pointless IMO.

It's not the fact that your doing it, it's

how

you did it.

[Parama]

And again I am forced to ask - what is wrong with me giving 3 scum reads? Assuming three scum in a mini is a safe bet, so it's always good to have 3 suspects to pursue.
If you have an issue with the abrasiveness of my accusations, suck it up. It's not going away any time soon.

[Slaxx]

Param sparked discussion. I don't see whats wrong with that.

[Stephoscope]

I want to see something from Stepho before I make a decision.

Here ya go.

*disco dancing*

I don't find you particularly scummy, by the way.

[Starbuck]

Parama, the game was dead because it was fucking Easter weekend. I don't expect people to take time from being with their families to play mafia.

[Slaxx]

I see people trying to hop on a lets bash Parama verbal wagon. He tried to create discussion. It doesnt matter when it is. He tried to get things moving forward. If you've got a problem, vote for him. Otherwise just let it go and let his scum reads react. You guys have distracted the entire intent of his post. The only one who has really defended themselves is kunk.

Frankly I agree with Parama's FoSs, although not with the Nacho one.

[Nikanor]

Oh crap, I meant to post in this game tonight. XD
I'll do so tomorrow.

[Nikanor]

I find it strange that, on page 3, you already want people to commit to something.

Nice dodge!

Unvote. Vote: kunkstar7.

Active lurking. He has done zero scumhunting in the ~10 posts he's made in this game.
Obvious scum is obvious.

[Starbuck]

Unvote
Vote: Parama

It would be really awesome if you could drop the egotistical arrogance.

I will be sticking to calling out the scummiest players because it's scumhunting!

You will be sticking to calling out anyone who disagrees with you. That, my dear, isn't scumhunting.

His sudden suspicion on me in Post 103 for asking for further elaboration doesn't sit well. I mean, it wasn't like I was suspecting him. Just asking for further clarification. His overreaction feels like nervous scum.



I've been playing mafia for awhile. I don't understand how ANYONE can have 3 suspects in 5 pages. Maybe 1, but definitely not 3.



Also,

FOS: Slaxx

for quickly trying to come to Parama's defense. I'm pretty sure Parama can handle his own.

On top of that..

Frankly I agree with Parama's FoSs, although not with the Nacho one.

Already being lazy and parroting?

Why don't you agree with him about Nacho?