Fishy wrote:I'm not proposing lynching a confirmed town player. I'm proposing lynching a player who I find likely scum, and whose death won't be a disaster for the town. dana's 363 takes my "if he's town, it's no great loss" bit, and implies that I believe his claim and want to lynch him anyway. Unfortunately for that particular argument, that's nowhere in my posts. Saying that the worse case scenario isn't that bad is not tantamount to saying I'd take it given the choice, and it's not saying I believe it to be the case.
Eh, I'm mostly just making up crap in an attempt to understand/justify my gut read from that post.
Fishy wrote:When MP responded, I felt he might well be pulling things out of his ass to disguise total wagon-hopping - do you really think that's an unrealistic interpretation? Why should I have asked the others about their cases? I wasn't on him for voting Ed, but for a vote with no reasoning.
I have a problem with you only asking Miles the question. After Miles provided a bad answer, you didn't stop to think and check on UK's and SP's reasons, just to be sure theirs were actually good.
Now that I think about it, though, this probably isn't a tell.
Fishy wrote:iso 4: Not mentioning MP's response was an oversight. In fact, looking back, it's rather horrible - he followed UK and SP's hints that they were finding Ed scummy, and jumped on it. His defense is that he didn't jump on a bw? When he voted, there may as well have been a bw. He get's a renewed FoS from me. And yeah, that's a fair point, I feel silly.
Gotcha.
Fishy wrote:iso 6: If you think I'm scum with Dana, that's fine. I'll fight that battle tomorrow. For now, Dana needs lynching.
I'm not entirely sure of my read on dku, tbh. I'll cover that in another post, though.
Fishy wrote:You seem to think I'm scum who knows that my scumpartner Dana is going to flip town, which doesn't gel very well.
No, I even said in my first case that I was unsure about my opinion on you.
Fishy wrote:I notice that you don't even mention the possibility that I'm a Dana-lyncher. It doesn't seem to have crossed your mind. Why is that, given that you think I'm attacking a claimed lynchee with terrible arguments? Could it be because you know he isn't a lynchee at all?
Ouch. Actually, I say in my original case that I like your attacks on dku. Learn to read and such.