Sorry Trumpet but I don't really care about your other games, I haven't been playing for long enough to know if metagaming works, my opinion at the moment is that you can just pull up any old game where you were town to give an example where you've acted the same way...and considering as scum you'd be trying to act as town as possible it just doesn't hold any value for me.
ToD wrote:When I asked for the name of the other mason, I genuinely believed it would be pro-town to have that information out there.
Why the need for the qualifier "genuinely" in there? I believe you now, I think you're scum and you "genuinely" thought it would benefit town for the other mason to claim and that's why you brought it up - to look town. Perhaps I'm picking up too much on semantics but in my second newbie game where I was scum (until I had to replace out) I was accused of a scum-slip which wasn't actually a scum-slip at all it was just mis-interpreted and I felt like saying "I genuinely meant..." but I thought the word "genuinely" would give me away.
I also fail to see how speculating on the setup makes someone scum, even if you think it's counterproductive that doesn't necessarily mean they are scum. Reading back over your case on Peanutman it looks like you've really stretched to make a townie look like scum (or possibly really stretched to bus a scumbuddy) as none of it looks like genuine scum-hunting, rather it looks more like trying as hard as possible to put a case on someone because you're on the chopping block.
I will be very surprised if you're town.
Vote: Trumpet of Doom
And I'm pretty sure I have no choice but to do this so:
Dear God,
God Bless little Macavity, and keep him safe and Locked,
Although his name confuses me like wearing sandals with socks.
God Bless little peanutman and keep him always salted,
God Bless little SC too, for against DS we revolted.
God Bless little lobstermania, and God Bless his mum,
God Bless little Trumpet though I think he's lying scum!
God Bless Mum and Dad and Gran and Sis and Bro and Pop,
But I ask Dear God - nay beg of you - please make this madness stop!
Amen.
Night-night!