Mini #893 - Dollhouse Mafia (Game Over!)

[elvis_knits]

Okay, this is what I think we should do:

We can lynch buttonmen and imprint nobody

OR

We can lynch KoC and imprint some people

My thinking is that since buttonmen is scum, if he is lynched, I would be fine with no imprints because I don't think farside or lim is scum. Therefore nobody should have an imprint (as only scum would have one and I don't think they're scum).

If buttonmen is not lynched, we need some town people imprinted to balance out what I think is a scum having a NK imprint.

I think buttonmen and KoC are both scum, but since buttonmen has been previously imprinted and KoC hasn't, the way we deal with imprints depends on which we are lynching.

[xRECKONERx]

Elvis, your plan sucks.

We lynch KoC and imprint nobody.

[farside22]

Elvis, your plan sucks.

We lynch KoC and imprint nobody.

I find myself in agreement with not imprinting. If scum was imprinted (which I think buttonman is scum so dont' start with the if thing please) and they shoot someone tonight our pool of people imprinted is small.

Reck: I'm sure you answered this and I'm a bit tired right now but who do you suspect to be scum with KOC?

[farside22]

EK did you have questions not anwsered as well. I'm going to post everything right here so it's clear as day (again) so buttonman can stop trying to pretend he doesnt' know what questions.

questions to buttonman:

If I was scum why would I not shot anyone if I was given the ability?

What about my claim do you find false and reasoning do you find false

See post 1419

Also what case do you have against me to what to see me lynched that did not satisfy your questions thus far?

[elvis_knits]

I did have questions for buttonmen, but I'm done trying to make him answer him. He had his chance. Now he should die.

[xRECKONERx]

Who is scum with KoC? I dunno.

[Pug89]

Okay, this is what I think we should do:

We can lynch buttonmen and imprint nobody

OR

We can lynch KoC and imprint some people

In terms of the lynch, I think I would be fine with either player (I need to reread both of them though) but I'm not for imprinting tonight, and if we do imprint tonight I don't button to have an imprint if he is not lynched.

[SerialClergyman]

If you're fine with both players, why do you need to re-read them? Why don't ou reread them then let us know your thoughts?

[Limerickx]

Hey all, just want to let you know I wont be able to check the thread until this weekend.

[xRECKONERx]

conveeeeenient

nah jk

[Socrates]

Between this site making me want to tear my hair out, and my computer making me actually tear my hair out, and stressful classes making my hair fall out, I have not been able to post much lately.

Tomorrow. Maybe.

[iamausername]

-=Vote Count #44=-

Ohio (3) - Colorado, Georgia, Iowa
Hawaii (3) - Virginia, Kansas, Alaska
Kansas (1) - Florida

Not Voting (3) - Hawaii, Montana, Ohio

6 to lynch.

-=Imprint Count #44=-

Kansas (3) - Alaska, Virginia, Florida
Florida (2) - Florida, Hawaii
Hawaii (2) - Florida, Hawaii
Alaska (1) - Virginia
Virginia (1) - Virginia
Georgia (0)
Colorado (0)
Iowa (0)
Montana (0)
Ohio (0)

6 to imprint.

ALASKA = SerialClergyman
COLORADO = CrashTextDummie
FLORIDA = Limerickx
GEORGIA = Socrates
HAWAII = TheButtonmen
IOWA = xRECKONERx
KANSAS = farside22
MONTANA = Pug89
OHIO = Knight of Cydonia
VIRGINIA = elvis_knits

-=CrashTextDummie and Knight of Cydonia have been prodded=-

[Knight of Cydonia]

I apologise for not posting more, but my connection is already shit and recent server issues have not been helping.
Any questions you have, repost/quote them and I will try and try again until a reply gets through if it kills me.

[CrashTextDummie]

I have also been struggling with the unbearable condition the site is in, and unfortunately, I don't have time right now for a longer post.

I will try to get in an elaborate post by this time tomorrow, detailing why I find recent developements in this game so very frustrating and outlining again why I want KoC lynched above all else.

Also, I have an advanced V/LA notice: I will be on vacation from February 8th through 12th.

[xRECKONERx]

blah blah blah cop outs blah blah blah blah

koclynchplzthx

[Socrates]

Man, I LOOOVE lurking! Its so much fun. We should all do it! owait we already are.

no seriously, I am considering moving onto Buttonmen just to try and dislodge this deadlock.

Limerickx, do you really think that your vote is doing ANY good where it is right now?

Buttonmen, KOC, Pug, fraking VOTE!

[farside22]

Unless people tell me why they think buttonman is town I'm not changing my vote.

[TheButtonmen]

Back sorry, extremely limited time the last few days due to me helping someone pack / move all in a 2 day period and the MS seems to get slower everytime I log in.

Longer post by tonight I've finally got the time to sit down and catch up.

@Soc, I'll vote when I'm done my reread of KoC (Shouldn't take long)

[elvis_knits]

Unless people tell me why they think buttonman is town I'm not changing my vote.

[farside22]

Oh that reminds me I had a theory last night (yes I don't sleep)
Anyways the next time we decide to imprint I want to let's say do a just in case the mod put it in there type thing.

So my theory is this. Right now no one has a clue what imprints will be given. I just want to play it safe in case the mod has a lie detector imprint to be given out.
In case this imprint is in the game I think everyone should say something like this:

I, (player name here) am an ordinary active.

So I would say I, farside am an ordinary active.

That way if there is a lie dectctor imprint ever in this game a player can look for this and see if someone is lying.
Like I said just theorizing and trying to outguess the mod a bit.

[elvis_knits]

I, elvis_knits, am an ordinary active.

[Pug89]

So my theory is this. Right now no one has a clue what imprints will be given. I just want to play it safe in case the mod has a lie detector imprint to be given out.
In case this imprint is in the game I think everyone should say something like this:

I, (player name here) am an ordinary active.

Seems unlikely, but it can't hurt.

I, Pug89, am an ordinary active.

If you're fine with both players, why do you need to re-read them? Why don't ou reread them then let us know your thoughts?

I still had to decide who to vote for.

I did quick rereads of both of them:
KOC: There are certain things I don't like. First, there is very little content from him since his catch up post on Dec 31st and Jan 1st. Second, his ISO post 10 which seemed like him trying to force his way into an imprint. On the other hand VMD (whom KOC replaced) didn't vote for SB day 2, and wasn't voting day 1 although I believe she said she wanted DN lynched, but at that point it was obvious DN was scum so it doesn't indicate much.

TheButtonmen: I mostly had a town read on him up until he got imprinted (I did vote imprint him after all), but since then he as done several things that bother me. First his shooting is investigating comment. Then him stating that he would have protected SC if he had been given a doc role, which makes little sense given he has been gunning for him most of the game. He said it was because one of the others could kill SC to frame him but that seems weak since if that happened and he was lynched there would only be two other suspects. Also, looking at the vote record he wasn't voting for DN day 1 and continued voting for SC day 2.

Vote:TheButtonmen

In the end TheButtonmen is more dangerous than KOC if he is scum since he has a NK. While I doubt he would use it anytime soon if more scum get NKs they can have multiple kills in one night which could be enough to win them the game and the town wouldn't see it coming.

I believe that puts him at 4 votes.

[TheButtonmen]

Appologies for long post.

To start off with I'll get this out of the way I, TheButtonmen, am an ordinary active.

After the reread of KoC / Skim of Vala I'm thinking I'd rather get a replacment / prods for the slot rather then a lynch as nothing really jumps out as being scummy however KoC has pretty said nothing outside of his summary posts so the sample size is quite small.

@Pug:

Shooting is a forminvestigating, you start the next day with their aligment known.Also what about me saying I would doc SC do you find strange?

@Farside:

If I was scum why would I not shot anyone if I was given the ability?

I got a NK, you think I'm scum so I ask you that question. As for why you wouldn't going into night there was a large consesus to your townhood and you knew that you wouldn't be investigated as the other imprintees had already said who we would investigate. Thus there was no risk to you biding your time.

What about my claim do you find false and reasoning do you find false

Your handling of how you claimed (saying you needed to go last and you could catch one of us lying) and that you said you hinted/bread crumbed where as I can't find anything of the sort.

See post 1419

What about it am I supposed to see? In refrence to why I didn't shoot I explained in the post you quoted,you yourself said that it was planning for the worse case, but to you it seemed scummy. I play by the numbers and try to avoid scenarios that can lead to town loss, this isn't new I direct you to the first part of the game as an example.

vAlso what case do you have against me to what to see me lynched that did not satisfy your questions thus far?

Boiled down it's; I don;t like the way you handled your claim and I don't like how you you reacted to both mine and Lim's questioning of you.

@Elvis

I did have questions for buttonmen, but I'm done trying to make him answer him. He had his chance. Now he should die.

Quotes or it didn't happen.

[TheButtonmen]

EBYOP: In my

@Pug

that should read, is a form of investigating.

[farside22]

*COUGH* The question you missed on 1419
Who did you think before the night came was scum?
Addition to that question
Since you analysis is thinking someone scum who do you think it was and why didn't you not say anything about said person being scum at that time