Open 185 v2.0: JK9 (Game Over)

[mykonian]

confirm vote CSL

Seriously, first acting "towny" as you are unvoting (guess what, unvoting isn't towny, it is

playing

towny. Then, bandwagonning, to L-1, because?

I've got to admit, I am no fan of Kyle's play, but that I can play off more easily as newby play.

[joe478]

Unvote

vote: kyle

because he worded a sentence wrong.

okay, csl, why is wording a sentence wrong a reason to put kyle at L-1?

Actually it was still only L-2

And mykonian missed it aswell, you people need to pay more attention.

[mykonian]

I didn't recount. Anyway, it doesn't really matter. First CSL unvotes very very soon because he wants no quicklynches, and then this. Seems like scum using an unvote to look town.

[CSL]

I hate slow games.

I really hate them.

That was just to get discussion going

But it didn't.

Unvote

[Trumpet of Doom]

Vote Count 1.2
GinzkeyPlatz (2 == L-3) - drowmage, kyle99
kyle99 (1 == L-4) - GinzkeyPlatz
CSL (1 == L-4) - mykonian
purple princess (1 == L-4) - joe478

Not Voting (4): Chaco, purple princess, populartajo, CSL

5 votes are required to lynch, 3 at deadline.

Chaco's V/LA is noted.

Massprod has been sent.

Negotiable deadline has been set for Thursday, Dec 17, at ~10:00 pm US Central (GMT-6). - ToD

[CSL]

Maybe you should start fishing for replacements, Trumpet. Someone who is willing to post.

It's only a matter of time before I replace out, because of the lack of activity in this game.

[mykonian]

reacting to prod

Since the deadline is only in 10 days, I think we should move towards a lynch. I dislike CSL's unvote-vote thingy that reeks of scum playing town, I dislike Kyle reasoning in a few post, I dislike tajo's lurking. But I dislike Drowmage's lurking even more, really hadn't expected that.

[GinzkeyPlatz]

How could you not have a role pm, joe? Has this been settled yet?

CSL's unvote in post 10 now looks contradictory to both his L-2 vote and his reason for voting. I think his first unvote might have been trying to act townie, while the latest unvote is trying to avoid attention.

Why would you do something to get discussion going if you think it will result in a quick lynch?

FoS: CSL

for that and for threatening to flake.

Since the deadline is only in 10 days, I think we should move towards a lynch. I dislike CSL's unvote-vote thingy that reeks of scum playing town, I dislike Kyle reasoning in a few post, I dislike tajo's lurking. But I dislike Drowmage's lurking even more, really hadn't expected that.

Any reason why you omitted purple princess from that lurker list?

[CSL]

I'm not threatening to flake. If discussion doesn't pick up, I will likely replace out of

this

game, not the whole site.

[mykonian]

Yes, I have no idea how PP plays, ginzk. From the others I expected some completely different start of the game.

[joe478]

How could you not have a role pm, joe? Has this been settled yet?

I just missed it in my inbox, ineed to clear it out a bit. Yes I now know my role.

[Trumpet of Doom]

purple princess is being replaced.

drowmage is being prodded (in fact, should have been prodded a while ago, but the 60 hours don't start until I send the prod). - ToD

[kyle99]

confirm vote CSL

Seriously, first acting "towny" as you are unvoting (guess what, unvoting isn't towny, it is

playing

towny. Then, bandwagonning, to L-1, because?

I've got to admit, I am no fan of Kyle's play, but that I can play off more easily as newby play.

So, you want to confirm vote CSL? That makes absolutely no sense to confirm vote anyone this early in the game.

[mykonian]

confirm vote CSL

Seriously, first acting "towny" as you are unvoting (guess what, unvoting isn't towny, it is

playing

towny. Then, bandwagonning, to L-1, because?

I've got to admit, I am no fan of Kyle's play, but that I can play off more easily as newby play.

So, you want to confirm vote CSL? That makes absolutely no sense to confirm vote anyone this early in the game.

I didn't think there was a rule that made that confirming a vote actually means something. It is his non reaction, with the earlier play that makes me more sure of my vote.

[kyle99]

confirm vote CSL

Seriously, first acting "towny" as you are unvoting (guess what, unvoting isn't towny, it is

playing

towny. Then, bandwagonning, to L-1, because?

I've got to admit, I am no fan of Kyle's play, but that I can play off more easily as newby play.

So, you want to confirm vote CSL? That makes absolutely no sense to confirm vote anyone this early in the game.

I didn't think there was a rule that made that confirming a vote actually means something. It is his non reaction, with the earlier play that makes me more sure of my vote.

Oh, I seem to recall that you couldn't unvote a confirm vote, but I'm probably wrong. I guess that makes more sense.

[Trumpet of Doom]

Qooq replaces purple princess. Please welcome her to the game! - ToD

[CSL]

Thank you. Now, the other flaker needs to be replaced.

[Qooq]

/confirm

Reading now.

[GinzkeyPlatz]

unvote
Vote: CSL

I don't believe your concern for the game's pace is genuine. You've made alot of posts but none of them look like you're trying to find scum or create discussion.

[kyle99]

I'm gonna

vote:CSL

and see what he does to defend himself, because he's certainly acting scummy right now.

[Qooq]

FOS: CSL

I shouldn’t need too much of explanation for this one as much of the suspicion has already been raised. All one really needs to do is compare two of CSL’s earliest posts (10 and 14) to the one in which he voted for kyle99 (46). The discrepancy is obvious and it raises similarly obvious questions about what caused such a large gap in his strategy. I’ll flat out say his explanation in post 53 doesn’t cut it for me and that I will need a more detailed response from him before I am no longer suspicious. I will admit that the post where he threatened to replace himself if the game doesn’t become active doesn’t read scummy to me, though.

I don’t put my vote on CSL because on first read, kyle99 looked suspicious to me also. Right now I’m reading kyle99 as overanxious, perhaps inexperienced townie. I believe I need to be careful here because I don’t want to put words in CSL’s mouth (his reason for voting kyle99 was a grammar mistake), but I think I understand why he had his vote there, though I will need confirmation from him to be sure. To CSL: Could you please clarify your vote on kyle99 further.

If it’s worth anything, I’m reading Ginz and populartajo town right now, also.

[CSL]

Eh, now that I think about it, it wasn't justified, and it won't.

[Qooq]

Just so it’s clear, I made my last post before I saw kyle99’s most recent post. I should’ve refreshed the thread. My apology.

FOS: kyle99

kyle99’s voting pattern is sketchy to me and makes him look suspicious. In post 24, he called for a lurker lynch. Then, in post 30, he put a vote on Ginz that from my perspective served no purpose other than to stir up discussion. Now, in post 69, he has made a vote with little of his own reasoning. I am not insinuating that kyle99 is trying to bandwagon, but I’m not sold on the justification behind his vote. We are nearing a lynch and putting someone close to L-1 because you want to hear an explanation is not simply not warranted to me. Neither is scum hunting for the sake of scumhunting. There is only so much you can blame on inexperience.

To CSL: Is that all you are willing to say about your vote?

[kyle99]

Then, in post 30, he put a vote on Ginz that from my perspective served no purpose other than to stir up discussion.

Is that not good enough reason?

[CSL]

That's all I can say...